3 ms·
To me, a "suck less" philosophy means that my environment should: * Mount flash drives automatically when I plug them in. * Let users configure the wireless n
by klodolph 14y ago
To me, a "suck less" philosophy means that my environment should:
* Mount flash drives automatically when I plug them in.
* Let users configure the wireless network connection, and set it to automatically reconnect with the same settings to different APs on the same network, and let users override certificate settings for the same, and remember the overridden settings.
* Let users configure printer settings.
Sure, dwm is great if you spend all of your time in xterm and emacs/vim. But I spend at least 0.02% of my time doing the above tasks, and I don't want to inflate that number.
Some people believe that the fewer lines of code they write, the more elegant their software becomes. Bull. Just like writing more lines doesn't make your code better, writing fewer lines doesn't make it better.
- joshka 14y agoNone of the tasks you listed are anything to do with window management. Perhaps I'm misunderstanding your argument. Could you elaborate? Shouldn't the OS handle most of those things, or perhaps some app?
- klodolph 14y agoSure, I'll elaborate. I read the argument as "Gnome versus dwm", not as "Metacity versus dwm". Every moment of my life that I spend editing fstab, running mount commands, or scripting my system is a moment that I could spend doing anything else. If I install Gnome, it will automount USB drives with no intervention on my part. Call this "low interface complexity." The same thing happens on OS X and Windows. Now remember that it's not just about automounting. It's about monitor calibration, input devices, keyboard layouts, text conversion software, assistive technologies, wireless network configuration, printer configuration, etc. "Myriad" is a good word here. If I uninstall Gnome, all of those tasks get shoved into the "unsolved" category, except for one — window management. For each task I have to find an application for it, compare different applications that solve the same task, and configure it. If it's something that has to always run in the background, like automounting, then I have to figure out a way to make it start when I log in. Call this "high interface complexity." What I'd like to get across is this: optimizing for the number of lines of code is the wrong thing to optimize for. It's wrong (incorrect) to optimize for a large number of lines of code, and it's wrong (incorrect) to optimize for a small number of lines of code. Lines of code is a poor metric for almost everything, with the exception of bug count. You should always be optimizing for "quality of life". If your idea of a higher quality of life is using a more minimalistic window manager, then what we have is a disagreement of a spiritual nature. To me, Gnome sucks less than dwm by a mile. And yes, I still know that Gnome is a desktop environment and dwm is a window manager.
- drbig 14y agoAnd for me that is exactly opposite - I prefer i3 + my own set of scripts, and Gnome/KDE/Windows/OSX sucks more than by a mile... And you know what? We're both correct and have good arguments. The point is: _your_ use case, habits, needs... So now let us compare and discuss whether bricks or helium are better for doing the dessert topping...or was that a floor wax?
- AskHugo 14y agoI think you're confusing Window Managers (WMs) with Desktop Environments (DEs)
- eikenberry 14y agoNone of those things are desktop settings either.
- klodolph 14y agoI'm not really confused, just not very fond of cobbling together a usable system out of several dozen different applications, which I must individually install and configure. Gnome fixes that problem.