3 ms·
"they can react faster than a human sitting behind a computer separated by a further thousand miles away" Maybe. The problem is identifying friend and foes.
by protomyth 14y ago
"they can react faster than a human sitting behind a computer separated by a further thousand miles away"
Maybe. The problem is identifying friend and foes. An AI might need more time than an actual person. Beyond that, losing a robot is not a big deal compared to losing a person, so the mistakes made in the field (ex. killing an innocent person who happened to get in the way) can be lessened because the fear of death is no longer there for the soldier.
- DanBC 14y ago> Beyond that, losing a robot is not a big deal compared to losing a person, so the mistakes made in the field (ex. killing an innocent person who happened to get in the way) can be lessened because the fear of death is no longer there for the soldier. "Friendly fire" from remote-operated robots would be pretty hard for people to cope with. 'Robots killed my dad, a hero soldier who fought for this country' is a headline no-one wants to read.
- tlb 14y agoFWIW, here are the causes of death of US soldiers in Iraq [1]: 2573 Hostile action 2496 IED 665 Non-combat 402 Helicopter accident 361 Vehicle accident 63 Unknown 39 other-unknown 31 Airplane crash Over 800 are accidents, and IEDs are just enemy robots. 1. http://apps.washingtonpost.com/national/fallen/ http://apps.washingtonpost.com/national/fallen/
- protomyth 14y agoI need to rephrase, I guess... If we put robots in the field and leave our soldier at home / base using telepresence to control the robots, the soldier don't have the immediate fear of death and can take the moment needed to identify friend, bystanders, or foes. Friendly fire wouldn't be much of a problem if none of our soldiers are actually in the combat zone. Robot blowing up, bad but no headlines.
- Symmetry 14y agoExactly. "You can't safely return fire, so allow yourself to be killed" is something you can say to a robot, but not to a human.