3 ms·
Please. All the engineering in the world may not may a human stop having a heatbeat -- but you are overlooking two factors that you really shouldn't in this day
by tomjen3 14y ago
Please. All the engineering in the world may not may a human stop having a heatbeat -- but you are overlooking two factors that you really shouldn't in this day and age:
1) It doesn't matter if your target has a heartbeat when the seven civilians loitering in the area also have heartbeats (and you don't know which one it is) or when your targets heartbeat stops because he just blew himself up in the middle of a market square, and you didn't even knew there were enemies around. Or when your soldiers die because they accidentally kicked over a piece of trash that was wired up to blow an old soviet grenade.
The attitude that all we need is much better equipment is the same attitude the current leadership of the pentagon has -- but it couldn't be further from the truth, because compared with the weapons the iraq fighters and the Taliban currently have, our weapons are already much better.
What we really need is much better intelligence.
- DanielBMarkham 14y agoI don't disagree, but I think you're having some other conversation about eyeballs on the ground versus more and more expensive weapon systems. As a former marine, this is an argument in which I'm very much inclined to agree with you. God knows we don't need many more B-2 bombers to fight the Taliban. Having said that, the point here is that massive, inexpensive, intelligent, and mobile systems will work alongside troops on the ground more and more as warfighting evolves. This will happen much the same as the dog, horse, or mule worked alongside fighters, only the robotic versions will continue to increase in functionality. But in the end that's a process discussion -- how will things advance over time. My point was that just like in all other fields, our helpers will soon become our betters. Won't happen for decades yet, but you can be sure it's coming sooner or later. And at that point, just like every other human endeavor, some pimply-faced kid in a Starbucks can control just as much firepower as a four-star general. It will just be a matter of credentials and security.
- lostlogin 14y agoSort of agree. Improving the quality of soldiers is about the worst way to go about making the world a better place. It's like the ambulance and the bottom of the cliff, but worse.
- tomjen3 14y agoActually, we need better soliders -- specifically more teams to do raid like the one on Bin Laden. It is just that we need much better intel to be able to do these kinds of raids.
- lostlogin 14y agoExtrajudicial killing isn't something that needs to increase. Hunting down and killing those that have hurt and harmed us isn't the best way to deal with those who have hurt and harmed us.
- ovi256 14y agoWell, Dick Cheney, along with a large number of other people, does not have a heartbeat anymore. He was implanted a continuous pump.
- 3A2D50 14y agoNot to diverge the conversation, but that is no longer true... http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/26/us/cheney-heart-transplant-a-recent-decision.html?_r=2&ref=health&pagewanted=all& http://www.nytimes.com/2012/03/26/us/cheney-heart-transplant...;