4 ms·
I've often wondered how most people read comments. There's something funny you see in voting patterns if you make a comment, and then someone replies with refut
by luu 14y ago
I've often wondered how most people read comments. There's something funny you see in voting patterns if you make a comment, and then someone replies with refutation, and then the refutation is refuted, and so on.
Fist, you see your comment get upvoted. But, if someone replies with a refutation that uses the word because[1], or is otherwise convincing, and calls you an idiot, you'll start to get downvoted (downvotes are rarer if there's no invective). That happens even if the 'refutation' consists purely of blatant logical fallacies. I tend not to reply to those, because it seems like a waste of time, so I'll often get downvoted to or below 0 before someone replies to the reply, at which point my comment score will start climbing upwards again.
This is the only site I regularly comment on, because I don't know of any public forum that has a similarly high level of discussion. I'm not sure the level of reading is the same, though. Skimming is dangerous. I do it, too, unfortunately.
There's actually been a set of studies that have shown that people are more likely to be convinced by nonsense they've read if they're distracted. The dangerous part here is that once you've been convinced by something, you don't tag that information as being unreliable because you didn't think critically about it when you first saw it. I'll sometimes catch myself, in a friendly debate, repeating something I've read, and then immediately saying "nevermind; that doesn't make any sense", because I'd absorbed the information unconsciously without thinking about it, but the act of saying it reveals that it's not logically sound.
[1] http://bps-research-digest.blogspot.com/2009/01/would-you-give-way-at-photocopier.html http://bps-research-digest.blogspot.com/2009/01/would-you-gi...
- kafkaesque 14y ago>...people are more likely to be convinced by nonsense they've read if they're distracted. This reminded me of a thought Albert Camus wrote in The Fall (in its context, it holds a deeper, more revealing meaning and meta commentary on human nature): "Sometimes it is easier to see clearly into the liar than into the man who tells the truth. Truth, like light, blinds. Falsehood, on the contrary, is a beautiful twilight that enhances every object."
- psyklic 14y agoI often read the comments on Hacker News even before reading the article.
- shardling 14y ago>There's something funny you see in voting patterns if you make a comment, and then someone replies with refutation, and then the refutation is refuted, and so on. I've noticed that sometimes, if someone makes a post agreeing with a comment but not explicitly saying so, it'll get interpreted as a disagreement simply because folk have fallen into the back-and-forth rhythm.
- andrewflnr 14y agoI hate that. I dont think it requires an existing back-and-forth either. If you say something different than the person you're replying to, they assume you mean the opposite of what they believe, presumably because that's easier than untangling the web of agreements and disagreements, errors and truths and unknowns, that exist between any two real people... If you're reading this, for the love of all that is sane, next time you make a comment, reply to what the other person actually says, not what you think they mean. If you feel the need to respond to something unsaid, make it explicit.
- ExpiredLink 14y agoEverything seems to deteriorate to a fight between parties. Rational argumentation that contributes to the presented subject becomes rare. Instead you see the pro/con, fanboy/hateboy 'debates' with low signal to noise ratio. I guess the political system (government vs. opposition, left vs. right, ...) has had a negative influence on public discussion in general. People increasingly think that public discussion means the clash of parties that fight against each other until there is a winner and a loser. The popular TV debates are based on that format.
- illuminate 14y agoWell, that's also a part of communication. Snapping into the back and forth mindset isn't constructive, but there are plenty of times when someone replies to me and I can't quite parse whether they're explicitly agreeing with me and/or adding context or arguing with me without spelling that out. I tend to take those as learning examples of how to improve my clarity of speech.
- noonespecial 14y agoI'll sometimes catch myself, in a friendly debate, repeating something I've read, and then immediately saying "nevermind; that doesn't make any sense" I'm nearly 40 and I find I'm still "defragging" my childhood. I still come across things I've "known" for decades but haven't explicitly thought about in as long turning out to be useless garbage as soon as I try to load them back into "working" memory. Its rather disorienting. I'm afraid my subconscious might actually be using some of the stuff I haven't fixed yet.
- alan_cx 14y agoWell, at least you know you are normal.