5 ms·
I can't speak for the Maps team because I'm not involved, and I can't speak for Google because, well, I can't speak for my employer. But I've been a developer
by nostrademons 14y ago
I can't speak for the Maps team because I'm not involved, and I can't speak for Google because, well, I can't speak for my employer. But I've been a developer in very similar situations before, and here's what pops into my mind when I hear statements like this:
The team has been pushing hard to get the new functionality out the door. They are perhaps behind schedule, nobody has yet looked at IE, and then someone finally gets their hands on a Windows 8 phone to test. It doesn't work. The product manager makes the call: cut IE support so that the Webkit version can launch on time. A redirect's put in place to avoid serving a completely broken experience to Windows 8 users, so they can at least do a search for businesses instead of having it not work.
They launch, the press picks it up, and conspiracy theories start flying. Somebody pages the team, emails start flying, there's a huddle to figure out how to fix it. An engineer (or a few engineers) "donate" their weekend to fixing IE compatibility. They work day and night until the bugs are fixed, and then remove the redirect.
PR makes a statement, and then another one once the problem can be fixed. Like all PR statements, they try to say the minimum amount possible to calm people down, since everything they do say will get picked apart by the press. They aren't engineers, they know only what the engineers tell them, and they say even less because whatever the engineers say will get wildly distorted as it passes from engineer -> PM -> PR -> press -> Hacker News.
Just my humble conjecture, as an engineer who's been in this situation several times before at a few different organizations (both Google and otherwise). I'd think critically before reaching for pitchforks, though.
- drivebyacct2 14y agoThis seems to fit with the fact that even here on HN, people were claiming that Mobile Google Maps did not work with Mobile IE10 but now(?) does. That seems like it would be easy to overlook: Block for broken version, push new version, people change UA and find the new version works in IE10M? Who knows, either way, it seems like Google would rather have more users (for data/to brag about/to show ads to) than block them out of spite for a mobile platform that is still struggling to be relevant.
- Strshps1MoreTim 14y agoThis is a possible scenario. On the other hand I've heard first hand a story about MS devs being ordered to break an MS web property on a competing browser. The manager who gave that order now works for Google.
- nostrademons 14y agoEegads, that's depressing. I'd like to think that he'd find that engineers at Google are nowhere near as compliant as they are at Microsoft if he tried that, though. There've been times I've questioned VPs about whether their decisions really are in the best interest of users. Sometimes they explain and I'm satisfied that it really is, and other times I've just flat out refused to do it without an experiment to verify, and we run the experiment and find that it's not, and then the executive lets it drop.
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoIf this is to be believed as anything other than rumor and innuendo, it would be productive if you could supply the manager's name. Both to prove that it's a real person, and so that anyone in a position to do so is better able to have them fired.
- taligent 14y agoYou deserve to be banned for this. You don't attempt to publicly slander a person's reputation (on an influential site like HN no less) based on unsubstantiated heresay.
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoI'm sorry, what? My primary point is that the poster won't be able to supply any name because the story is exceedingly likely to have been spread by public relations flacks and no such person actually exists. And if such a person does exist, then it isn't slander if it's true.
- 14y ago
- Steko 14y agoSane perspectives like the above are why I come here instead of say r/technology where the dominant mindset currently paints a picture of Larry Page sitting alone in a room like Mojojojo, disabling APIs from Google properties to competing platforms with the pull of a lever.
- kenjackson 14y agoIn most cases I think I'd agree. I'm suspicious here because of the other things I point out: 1. Google apparently not allowing Windows Phone to use YouTube APIs, although everyone else seems to have access. 2. Google cutting EAS support. 3. Google explicitly stating they are not going to support Windows Phone 8. 4. FRAND patents against XBox. 5. The Google Maps debacle. Any of these by itself doesn't seem like a big deal, but all put together makes it look like an orchestrated plan by Google, rather than just bumbling Google engineers and incompetent PR people.
- mtgx 14y ago> Google apparently not allowing Windows Phone to use YouTube APIs, although everyone else seems to have access. What? Everyone who? Nobody has access to Google's Youtube API's. Android has a Youtube app because Google made it, and it's the same with iOS. WP will only have a Youtube app if Google makes it, and they won't, and nobody can force them to write for all platforms. Giving Microsoft access to them would mean giving them preferential treatment over anyone else. Obviously Google is not going to do that. > Google cutting EAS support. Microsoft has used those patents to threaten other Android manufacturers before or make them pay for them. Google wants everyone using Android to move away from EAS, and it makes perfect sense from their point of view, to cut costs for themselves and Android manufacturers, and to be less dependent on Microsoft's proprietary technologies. I'm not saying Google didn't do the Maps thing on purpose. Maybe they did. I'm just picking on these because you seem to think that somehow it's not Google's right to do all that.
- rbarooah 14y agoI don't see anyone saying it's not Google's right to do these things. People are simply saying that it looks as though Google is attacking Microsoft.
- AnthonyMouse 14y ago>I don't see anyone saying it's not Google's right to do these things. I've seen plenty of people claiming that they think it's an antitrust violation and arguing that regulators should go after them for it. Though I'm not sure when not supporting a small minority platform like Windows Phone became an antitrust violation; if it has then Microsoft had better get to work shipping that edition of Office for FreeBSD. Also, Google and Microsoft are competitors. And Microsoft has been attacking Google at every opportunity. I suppose using Microsoft as the standard for corporate citizenship is kind of a low bar, but you can only turn the other cheek so many times before some kind of response becomes an inevitability. Especially when you have such a large organization. People keep thinking that corporations are like individuals, as though the CEO and the full legal department approves every decision an engineer makes before pushing an incremental update to one of a thousand different products. Stories like this are completely plausible to have happened by accident or by a tiny minority of rogue individuals -- and then, multiply by tens of thousands of engineers, you see more than one such story because Microsoft PR turns every single one into front page news, and confirmation bias makes you believe it's the rule rather than the exception. Opposition research working as intended.
- Shooti 14y agoSeems like it was WP7 performance that was the deciding factor: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UfTS1f8vqAo http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UfTS1f8vqAo The mistake seems to have been not testing WP8 performance with the new IE engine before setting up a blanket block. Only the older devices needed to be blocked.
- Athtar 14y agoThe only problem with that is the follow-up statement(1) from Google indicating that the re-direct was not something that was recently added and that it has always been in place when that has not been the case. The fact that they made a couple different statements (first it was that Google Maps only works with Webkit-based browsers, and now the re-direct nonsense) that are not completely truthful makes me doubtful. 1) http://www.zdnet.com/google-shouldnt-forget-history-when-blocking-its-competitors-products-7000009411/ http://www.zdnet.com/google-shouldnt-forget-history-when-blo...