5 ms·
Putting aside the idea of whether marriage should happen after N years of dating...to my point, we still don't know enough to make any judgment on "Jacob" becau
by danso 14y ago
Putting aside the idea of whether marriage should happen after N years of dating...to my point, we still don't know enough to make any judgment on "Jacob" because we only have glimpses of the women he is said to have dated. Relationships are two-way streets and the man is not the sole arbitrer of tying the knot.
And I'm old enough to be starting to harangue the next generation for not things the way I remembered doing them...but I think you're a bit too judgmental. One of the underlying themes of this piece is that Internet dating makes the "market," so to speak, much more liquid. The people whom you know who got married after 2-5 years...can you, or they, say that who they matched up with and vowed "till death do we part" was conclusively the best person for them in existence? Isn't it slightly coincidental and solipsistic to think that the universe arranged things so that out of billions of human beings, these couples who met mostly in real life (before the spread of e-dating) happened to have the physical proximity needed for their paths to intersect?
Whether or not marriage is the ideal state is a whole different argument...but you have to take into account the different worldview that the Internet unavoidably propagates. I think this is why I'm defending the OP (even though I've never online dated)...it's almost not necessary to provide hard evidence for the OP's assertion (or the admittedly self-interested online dating professionals quoted) because the Internet has so fundamentally changed how we interact and what we believe in. Right now, it is strange to me when friends don't have the intent to eventually marry...but I grew up with that being the status quo. The generation entering adulthood now did not and so it seems impossible to think that e-dating had (or will have) no impact on how we perceive and carry out relationships.
- mattchew 14y ago> Relationships are two-way streets and the man is not the sole arbitrer of tying the knot. This is true, but from what I've seen in these multiyear LTRs, the woman wants to get married, the man wants to keep his options open (or, "doesn't want to make a mistake"). I've never seen the reverse scenario in an extended relationship. If Jacob's girlfriends didn't actually care about getting married and settling down, then I agree there's nothing to fault Jacob for particularly. My guess is that a woman who sticks with a guy five years typically wants to get married, but you're right that I don't know, and we may be back to me not understanding the younger generation. > The people whom you know who got married after 2-5 years...can you, or they, say that who they matched up with and vowed "till death do we part" was conclusively the best person for them in existence? Of course not, but what kind of wacky standard is that anyway? That's an idea for teenage girls who haven't gotten over their Disney Princess movies, not mature adults. > Right now, it is strange to me when friends don't have the intent to eventually marry...but I grew up with that being the status quo. The generation entering adulthood now did not and so it seems impossible to think that e-dating had (or will have) no impact on how we perceive and carry out relationships. Oh, the new generation will muddle through somehow, I'm sure of that. But from what I've seen, I am skeptical that these ever cooler, ever more casual notions of romance and partnership are actually improvements for the people practicing them.
- rgrieselhuber 14y agoI think that many men feel that the risks are much higher for men (at least in the US) when it comes to marriage and making a mistake.
- mattchew 14y agoWell, there is something to this. If I were single, I'd want to be pretty cautious myself. That said, I think not wanting to make a mistake, and not wanting to make a decision, are two different things. If you're with someone who wants to get married, there comes a point where you should make up your mind one way or the other.
- ownagefool 14y agoI've just recently had a 4 year relationship end on me here (28, male, UK). She wanted marriage and kids but I did not. There were three key reasons for this in my mind. * I was always fairly sure it was love but I was never sure I could put up with her in the long term (whether thats her fault or mine isn't really the point). * I had a lot more to lose than her by entering into a marriage and even being in a relationship and separating was a fairly large financial burden on my part. * I don't really feel I'm ready for either thing, though maybe I'd consider marriage if I felt the relationship was right. You're attitude appears to be that because I worked at my relationship, but didn't commit the rest of my life to it, that I am not a catch. Maybe its true but its not how I feel about the situation. Its fair to say that it could have ended sooner, but just because you think your relationship isn't going to work, doesn't mean you stop loving that person and want to give up.
- mattchew 14y agoWhat you say is understandable. Your first bullet point made me chuckle. I'm not out to bash you personally. If you or your girlfriend had entered the relationship with the intention of either committing or moving on, and (let's suppose) ended the relationship after one or two years instead of four, do you think that would have been a better outcome for either of you?
- superuser2 14y ago>he people whom you know who got married after 2-5 years...can you, or they, say that who they matched up with and vowed "till death do we part" was conclusively the best person for them in existence? That's the primary argument of the original article. People feel they have a more effective way to search for "the best person for them in existence" and leave perfectly good relationships because the grass might be greener somewhere else.