3 ms·
> Narratively, the story focuses on Jacob, an overgrown manchild jackass who can't figure out what it takes to have a real relationship. The problem, however, i
by danso 14y ago
> Narratively, the story focuses on Jacob, an overgrown manchild jackass who can't figure out what it takes to have a real relationship. The problem, however, is not him, and his desire for a "low-maintenance" woman who is hot, young, interested in him, and doesn't mind that he is callow and doesn't care very much about her. No, the problem is online dating, which has shown Jacob that he can have a steady stream of mediocre dates, some of whom will have sex with him.
I basically stopped reading at the ad hominem. An article that claims to be about "evidence" clearly is not if it needs to win reader approval by bashing the opposing subject. This was a theme in the Atlantic's comments section of the article in question, too.
We can't tell if Jacob is truly a "douche" or not. The last article was all about him but mainly focused on his dating life and not other circumstances of it. And he sounds like an average male professional...what seems offensive is that we're more privy to his desires and decisions and as they say, familiarity breeds contempt.
The OP also blasts the article for not including a single female voice. If we're trying to make an objective evaluation of the effect of online dating, then it does not matter if the article is single gender (either male or female). If it can be argued convincingly that one-half of a couple has much more incentive to leave, then that by definition is enough to have an effect on traditional relationships, no matter what the other gender thinks
- icebraining 14y agoThat's not an ad hominem. An ad hominem is a personal attack on the author of the argument (i.e., Dan Slater). This is a refutation of the actual argument. It may not be well grounded, but that's another issue.
- mattchew 14y ago> We can't tell if Jacob is truly a "douche" or not. He had a girlfriend for five years and didn't marry her, and then had a girlfriend for two years and didn't marry her. That doesn't mean he's a douche, but he's not much of a prize either. I suppose this attitude is a generation or more out of date. But it sure looks to me like the younger generation is screwing it up bad. Guess I'd better get some signs to post on my lawn.
- evincarofautumn 14y agoCounterexample: my girlfriend and I have been together for about two years, love each other deeply, and are strongly committed to one another. And still, for us, marriage is basically a political and financial decision. So if she can get a free ride at some school where I can get a professorship, or if one of our jobs transfers us overseas, or if we can get a significant break on our taxes by filing jointly, then we’ll do it. Gaming the system is awesome. Otherwise, marriage just doesn’t mean anything to us.
- abrowne 14y agoThis is exactly how my partner and I feel. I was able to get a Canadian work permit as her common-law spouse, so we didn't need to get married when she did grad school in Canada. (We're from the US.) Until there's some other reason to get married, we have little interest in doing so. [edit: added closing parenthesis]
- NickPollard 14y agoWhat's wrong with having a girlfriend for five years and not marrying her? It might be unusual, but it's not wrong. Some people aren't into marriage. Some people like to wait - my brother was in a relationship over 10 years before he proposed (and is now happily married). Don't judge everyone by your own ideas.
- rayiner 14y agoI know some people like that. But to be honest, I know a lot more couples where the guy just kicks the can down the road, paralyzed at the thought of sleeping with the same woman forever. Which is fine, except when they deflect instead of being forthright about their feelings and letting the woman decide whether to keep going.
- Tichy 14y agoIsn't it statistically most often the woman who breaks up? I suspect that might be because it is easier for women to find new partners.