12 ms·
A Million First Dates
- casca 14y agoTL;DR: anecdotally, "internet dating has made people more disposable"
- aes256 14y agoThe argument goes that internet dating has made commitment less attractive, and divorce more common. That's not necessarily a bad thing. In the future we will have fewer people clinging to abusive partners and putting up with destructive relationships. Online dating provides more options. On the other hand, a lot more children are going to grow up without both their biological parents. Is that such a bad thing? I'm not convinced it is, but I've never really bought into the concept of family.
- ZoFreX 14y agoYes, I thought that most of what the article stated was well supported, but they made a leap from "people are more likely to leave relationships that aren't that great" to social values suffering. I'd rather be single than trapped in a marriage I don't really enjoy.
- furyg3 14y agoIt's tough, though. If you ask very happily married 60+ old couples, I think most will tell you that there was a patch or two they didn't really enjoy, and that they are happy they rode it out. The trick is knowing when to make that call. Having a list of a thousand compatible singles a click away probably lowers the "walk away" threshold quite a bit.
- Evbn 14y agoAffairs have existed as long as marriage. There is a "walk back" threshold as well. People are practical by nature, if shortsighted.
- mr_luc 14y agoCounterpoint: I'm young, but I still measure my core friendships in decades ... I'm not going to settle for a life where 'romantic partner' is not a core friendship, one which I can rely on in the same way as my lifelong friends and close family. I think that a lot of people feel the same way. To me, that's more persuasive even than the 'think of the children argument', and much less likely to change. The 'think of the children' argument is pretty strong here. We all know the stats: kids from single-parent families tend to grow up in more negative environments, tend towards worse outcomes. But maybe society can solve that problem! For instance, if a kid's parents are divorced, but are constantly in caring relationships, maybe society can evolve to a point where those kids aren't disadvantaged, and where they have a relatively stable upbringing. But that won't change my mind about 'romantic partner' belonging in the category of 'secure, long-term friendships.'
- jacquesm 14y agoNow you have to really hope that your romantic partner sees things just the way you do.
- GuiA 14y agoThat's a primary concern in pretty much every single romantic relationship.
- mr_luc 14y agoWell, I haven't solved that part! Nor do I think the permanence-of-marriage problem is any more or less solvable than the disadvantaged-single-parent-children problem. But the permanence-of-marriage problem interests me, at least in my case. And it seems like a problem that can be addressed in ways that improve outcomes, even granting that it has random/unknowable components.
- aes256 14y agoPeople change; they come and go. To me, the notion of marriage flies in the face of this basic observation. How can you possibly commit to spending the rest of your life with someone when you know so little about how they will change, intentionally or not? > The 'think of the children' argument is pretty strong here. We all know the stats: kids from single-parent families tend to grow up in more negative environments, tend towards worse outcomes. This sounds like selection bias to me. At present, in Western society at least, members of certain socioeconomic classes are significantly more likely to become single parents, and it is likely the socioeconomic conditions their children grow up in that have the most significant effect on their outcomes. Conversely, abusive relationships and unhappy marriages also provide negative environments for children to grow up in. A future in which relationships are more fluid could reduce the number of children growing up in these environments.
- DanBC 14y ago> On the other hand, a lot more children are going to grow up without both their biological parents. Is that such a bad thing? I'm not convinced it is, but I've never really bought into the concept of family. May I ask: Do you have children? What would you feel if your partner left the country with those children? Would you still feel the same way if you did not have the money for law to get some kind of custody of those children?
- raldi 14y agoThank you. I kept waiting and waiting for the article to get to its point, and it just kept going on and on as a shaggy-dog story.
- shubhamjain 14y agoThis article considers only the people whose aim in relationship is to aid in their lonliness, find someone to be with, blah blah. What about those who want to have kids, and a family. I dont think anyone will have the same line of thought after having kids.
- danso 14y agoIt's too early to tell what the effect will be on these kinds of couples. Even with kids, you go through phases, and life at age 1 (for the children) is vastly different than at age 21
- theorique 14y agoThe goals may change, but lots of people leave their spouse even after having kids, so it's not a perfect guarantee. Not saying that is right, or desirable, but it's definitely something that happens.
- greggman 14y agoMy personal experience doesn't match some of the ideas presented in that article >> At the selection stage, researchers have seen that as the range of options grows larger, mate-seekers are liable to become “cognitively overwhelmed,” and deal with the overload by adopting lazy comparison strategies and examining fewer cues I find exactly the opposite. People that I would be happy to talk to if I met them in person with no knowledge about them I easily reject because some minor thing in their profile suggests some incompatibility even if it might not be in actuality. >> Easy For whatever reason it's not been easy for me. I'm on several sites. The issue above means I don't write that many people. Of those I write they rarely respond. Through online dating I've not managed to meet more than 1 person a year, probably less. I could go on. Maybe it's that unlike Jacob I actually am looking for "the one" so it makes me more picky.
- vidarh 14y ago> because some minor thing in their profile suggests some incompatibility even if it might not be in actuality. That is a lazy comparison strategy compared to actually getting to know someone to find out whether or not it reflects an actual incompatibility. We see the same in many other settings, like shopping: Give people more choice beyond a relatively small number, and they on average become less likely to find a choice they see as satisfactory. If your choice is ketchup or mustard, it's relatively easy. If you're faced with five of each, you might decide what you really want is mustard from a specific village, hand picked by virgins.
- greggman 14y ago"Lazy comparison strategy" seems like a poor name for that strategy as meeting people in person is far lazier "take what comes along" (ie: no comparison) vs "reading 1000 profiles" (lots of comparison).
- Evbn 14y agoYou aren't disagreeing. Both you and the article state that your decision making process collapses.
- andrewvc 14y ago
- danso 14y agoThis article is a good read, but this following excerpt is an angle I would love to see a more expanded look into: Indeed, the profit models of many online-dating sites are at cross-purposes with clients who are trying to develop long-term commitments. A permanently paired-off dater, after all, means a lost revenue stream. Explaining the mentality of a typical dating-site executive, Justin Parfitt, a dating entrepreneur based in San Francisco, puts the matter bluntly: “They’re thinking, Let’s keep this fucker coming back to the site as often as we can.” For instance, long after their accounts become inactive on Match.com and some other sites, lapsed users receive notifications informing them that wonderful people are browsing their profiles and are eager to chat. “Most of our users are return customers,” says Match.com’s Blatt.
- snprbob86 14y agoOK Cupid's OK Trends blog had an article titled "Why You Should Never Pay For Online Dating", but they removed it after they were acquired by match.com, a paid dating site. You can Google around and find a few copies of the article.
- danso 14y agoYes I remember that, and that's a good example... E-dating has been going on for what seems like forever in the Internet age, but its near-ubiquity is still a relatively new phenomenon. In the short-term and medium-term, it's probably good for dating services to have relationships break up in a timely manner. But successful couples (5+ years and more) are valuable too, because they pass along by word of mouth how happy they are because of their experience with [whateverservice]...and are likely to disparage it (justifiably or not) when the relationship goes sour. For a dating service to have the cynical goal of creating high turnover seems to me to be a race to the bottom that may end up having negative returns in the long run. Just as Apple clearly can make more money this decade from a customer who has to buy a new computer to replace their 2-year-old unupgradeable one -- compared to a customer whose Mac lasts them through high school and college -- I would say that Apple's current cachet (speaking as a long-time PC user) was highly dependent on the latter situation.
- 14y ago
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jacques_chester 14y agoFWIW, the Portland regulars on /r/OkCupid complain that it's an inversion of the classic pattern everywhere else. Men are apparently in the position of scarcity. NYC OKCers talk about the scourge of "trade ups". Still, living as I do in Perth, this all seems like hearing about the problems of people living on Planet Donuts. Oh, you can't settle down because there are just sooo many choices? No no, please continue, I'll be over here stewing in my own bile.
- AJ007 14y agoWeird, from what I've seen male friends who were fairly attractive (over 6 feet tall, blonde) would consistently land with girls that were one to three notches below what they would get "offline." I've attempted to use dating sites on and off several times over the years and barely could get the attention of ugly women. In the end I found it amusing considering the girls I date tend to be models that have appeared in magazines starting with the letter P.
- pyre 14y ago| the girls I date tend to be models that have appeared | in magazines starting with the letter P Like Pyramid[1]? Did you paint the models before you dated them? Did any of them leave you for a Space Marine? </sarcasm> Please leave this chest-beating off of HN. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pyramid_(magazine) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pyramid_(magazine)
- gyardley 14y agoLet's pretend I wasn't happily married and the women I dated tended to be models. Somehow I can't see myself using dating sites on and off several times over the years, trying to get the attention of women I thought were ugly.
- derfclausen 14y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ofIJhUMhqvE#t=2m02s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ofIJhUMhqvE#t=2m02s
- return0 14y ago
- singular 14y agoFor a certain subset (perhaps minority) of the population, these sites are nothing but a bait-and-switch. And I think dating sites attract many of us (as I am indeed a member of this subset.) I'm talking about people who lack the pre-requisites women require for mate selection which if not fulfilled, no other characteristics typically matter. Firstly - height - if you are significantly below the national average, you will find obtaining a partner extremely difficult. I am 2 sigma below the average in my country (5'5", UK). Oh dear. I think those who are not height-impaired find it hard to believe how much of a factor this is, but it really, really, really is. If you lack a certain kind of (I venture to suggest, actually somewhat unpleasant, cocky) confidence, especially good looks or social standing, then your odds drop even more significantly. From what I have read, the general experience of dating sites is that men get very few replies, and women are inundated, so the task for a man is to do anything to stand out, and the task for women is to filter. I think this exaggerates the already heavily filtering criteria listed above for those like myself. However, dating sites give people like me hope, the idea that somehow we might get around this problem, somehow say the right thing or after enough messages sent we might find somebody. I wonder how many people like me fund these sites (OK Cupid have a blog with lots of stats, perhaps some data to work with there.) I say 'from what I have read', as I have sent > ~150 messages with no reply whatsoever. After losing vast amounts of weight, optimising profile, following advice, etc. Apologies for the rantishness/possibly OT-ness of this post, but obv. quite a personal issue for me. UPDATE: Amusing news piece on short men dating - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3LwRe6tyqY8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3LwRe6tyqY8
- dusing 14y agoYou should really try a pay site, OKC in my experience has just been for hookups. People are way more judgemental there. Also I would think a dating site where you could search for shorter girls would be helpful than real life, no?
- mykosmos 14y agoThe thing is... even short girls want tall guys... =)
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- redwood 14y agoDoes anyone else want to take a different tack here? Perhaps we need to start considering if we're entering a somewhat polyamorous age. Perhaps monogamy makes less sense today. This is a dangerous subject... it certainly isn't something I can talk to my partner about openly. But that's why I bring it up: perhaps as a society we need to start admitting that we have changed our level of expectations on what is okay for activity partners and perhaps even sex partners, with members of the opposite sex. Perhaps we can have our cake and eat it too. We should acknowledge that long-term relationships built on friendships may not always provide all the perks we expect in this internet age. Perhaps we need not lose these wonderful relationships in the wake... rather have both. I'm not offering a clear path for how it would work or how to get there. But I'm challenging the baseline assumption here that, somehow, a more liquid market for cross-sexual meeting is a bad thing. It's the reality of today, so perhaps we need to update our lifestyles.
- alecco 14y agoPolyamorous relationships are on the rise due to the age of self-centered and narcissistic people. Don't get me wrong, I don't like the nuclear family for everyone credo. But let's not fool ourselves about being more open minded. It's just the basic irrational impulse, now unrestrained.
- pdeuchler 14y ago“Societal values always lose out,” says Noel Biderman, the founder of Ashley Madison, which calls itself “the world’s leading married dating service for discreet encounters”—that is, cheating. “Premarital sex used to be taboo,” explains Biderman. “So women would become miserable in marriages, because they wouldn’t know any better. But today, more people have had failed relationships, recovered, moved on, and found happiness. They realize that that happiness, in many ways, depends on having had the failures. As we become more secure and confident in our ability to find someone else, usually someone better, monogamy and the old thinking about commitment will be challenged very harshly.” Oh man. Societal values will always lose out? Women (just women, mind you! Not men, or women and men?) were miserable in marriages because premarital sex was taboo? The lack of premarital sex directly leads to unhappy marriages? Some of these quotes border on the ridiculous. Personally, I'm glad the societal value of "Murder is wrong" hasn't lost out to these dating websites. I'm going to pile on real quick and also point out that commitment is hard. It's a disturbing trend that people can now just not deal with commitment (an important societal need, not just in relationships but in business as well) since sites like these offer them an easy way out. I'm far from the evangelical Christian right, but there is no denying family values play a part in a functional society. Stable homes and good role models are invaluable to children growing up. Good marriages can demonstrate valuable social skills, such as compromise, respect and as corny as it sounds, love. Such things should never "lose out". Let's not forget that, as the article mentions, most of these people's goal is to generate repeat users, not create healthy relationships. I'm not denying that online dating can be a great tool, but let's take some of these opinions with a grain of salt.
- gojomo 14y agoNote the quote comes from the founder of AshleyMadison. For his clientele, at least, and for the duration of their patronage, the traditional values lose out. (He's 'talking his book'.)
- PaperclipTaken 14y agoOne question that's come up for me a number of times in the past 2 years or so is "how permanent does a healthy relationship need to be?" Traditional values suggest that "'til death do us part" is the desired level of permanence, but as a society (even preceding online dating) we've been moving away from that idea. More specifically, it used to be somewhat taboo for a widow to remarry, but now it's almost expected that a young widow will eventually find another spouse. As our expected lifespan grows, are the costs and benefits of fully committing to a single person changing? As far as kids are concerned, you want a marriage to last long enough to get the kids to a certain degree of autonomy, but is that level changing too (which is interesting, because it might seem that kids are taking longer to gain autonomy compared to a hundred years ago). But we all expect to become grandparents. This is clearly beyond the point where you need to commit to a spouse for childhood reasons. Is our changing environment enough to justify an expectation that marriage should no longer be permanent?
- zerooneinfinity 14y agoStop investing your time in dating sites and go outside.
- tnk 14y agoOP Singular, I have felt your pain, and I cured it for myself. The answer is not to become someone you dislike or are uncomfortable with - but instead, to grow the person you are into a person you are MORE proud. Besides this arbitrary idea of dating quantities and success score numbers judged by the numbers of responses, let's presume to say you would be happy finding just ONE person to start with who mutually is attractive and fun to be with. Let's not get overeager just yet looking for THE ONE for all eternity, if there even is such a thing (See Dan Savage videos). Let's take this process one step at a time - just get a date, any date. Ugly, fat, tall, short, pretty, sexy, smart, boring. Doesn't matter. Get a date. Then get two. Then three. Then more. And as you realize that people are people regardless of their exterior, you are going to become a far more likable, confidently social, comfortable, and engaging person - who SINCERELY unconditionally appreciates women - your charisma will naturally improve. And women will sense that, because indeed you accept them absolutely regardless of what they would wish to do or say or act around you. You must learn and internalize that you are impervious to any of their negativity. To anyone's negativity, man or woman, because you utterly believe in yourself and the rich, successful, beautiful life journey that you are on. Your positivity is too strong, indeed. You don't beat yourself up, and think YOU are unlovable just because there IS SOMETHING WRONG WITH THEM. If you do these things, if you accept the things you can't change, your height, facial structure perhaps (plastic surgery?), whatever else you consider your lot in life, at the very least, you are going to become an extraordinarily popular personal energy to be around. Now taking this self-embrace further, why not do things that will only better you? For instance, post a picture of yourself here, now that you have such a popular thread. Begin that effort you are no longer sensitive to the negativity anyone might bring to you commenting how you look, what height you are, or any other feature about you. 'Tis all just fodder to be examined, if there is or isn't something you can do to improve your situation. There ARE always things you can do, even if some things you have no control over. Proactivity, unconditional positivity, and pragmatism are your main principles now! If you are indeed a bit scrawny and unhappy with your body structure, then learn to weight lift and grow your body. Take dancing classes, where your skills in dancing might overcome your physical structure. Do whatever else is active and physical, if you think that is the realm in which you lack. I promise you, if you post a picture, or better yet, a video of yourself talking to us about your life situation, you are going to get immense and valuable feedback, far better than you are from the one dimensionality of textual defense and argumentation.. We don't, unfortunately or fortunately, live in merely a world of literal characters, so much as unique, unpredictable, infinitely dynamic human characters. =)