2 ms·
Because of the way we run our agricultural system. We tend to use monocultures, or 'ogilopolies' of certain plant varieties. Past plant varieties were more lik
by graeme 14y ago
Because of the way we run our agricultural system. We tend to use monocultures, or 'ogilopolies' of certain plant varieties.
Past plant varieties were more likely to be safe from hidden vulnerabilities due to the process that created them. Even so, some plants were wiped out by a single surprise event, such as during the Irish potato famine.
If, as I argue, GMO crops present more hidden risks, then we are increasing the odds of a catastrophic failure of a staple crop.
Growth in the food supply tends to produce a growth in population. This new population is dependent on food supply staying at least at it's current level. If a staple crop fails, then the consequences will be dire. There is little slack in the system.
- CamperBob2 14y agoHmm. I don't see a reason to assume that GMO crops present "more" hidden risks -- since by definition any such risks are hidden in both the GMO and non-GMO cases -- and you certainly haven't provided any such reasons in your post. If we want to avoid future unpleasant surprises like the Potato Famine, it seems to me that the best strategy is to gain the greatest possible mastery of plant genetics. There will be unpleasant surprises along the way but science, like life itself, offers no guarantees. Meanwhile I haven't seen any potato famines lately.
- graeme 14y agoThe reason there are more hidden risks is because we're creating breeds that couldn't occur in nature. We can't understand the full effects of modifications. Natural plants have been tested over time so that we can be somewhat sure they don't have that many unknown weaknesses.
- CamperBob2 14y agoWe can't understand the full effects of modifications. That's the Precautionary Principle, which as someone else pointed out is basically a rephrasing of Pascal's Wager with all of its gaping logical holes.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]