4 ms·
>>I'm making a Talebian argument here. Nature is a VERY complex system. When we mess with it, we make incremental visible gains, and run the risk of large, invi
by enraged_camel 14y ago
>>I'm making a Talebian argument here. Nature is a VERY complex system. When we mess with it, we make incremental visible gains, and run the risk of large, invisible losses.
I've never understood this argument. It basically amounts to "yes, there are advantages to GMOs, but we haven't found any disadvantages yet, therefore they are unsafe!"
This is basically the equivalent of early seafarers being afraid of uncharted waters and writing on their maps "here be dragons".
edit: I should also point out that the complexity of a system does not necessarily mean that messing with it will cause problems. If anything, that same complexity may include many fail-safe mechanisms to prevent problems when the system is messed with.
- pyre 14y agoIf an early seafarer went down with his/her ship, it didn't affect a significant portion of the population. GMO foods are more like, "Hey look! I invented this new banana in a test tube! It looks safe, so it must be! Here eat it! Does it cause problems when you eat these types of bananas for 20 or 30 years? Who knows! Just eat it, it looks safe!"
- maratd 14y agoYou could say that about any new product. Here! Use this cellphone! What? The battery can explode when it overheats? Don't worry about it! Almost never happens! And with cellphones ... that's already happened. Yet you still have one in your pocket. > Does it cause problems when you eat these types of bananas for 20 or 30 years? Bananas didn't evolve with "being good for you 20 or 30 years from now" ethos. That doesn't help the spread of their seeds. They just needed to taste sweet, so you would eat them now and spit out their seed somewhere else. Is there even a plant out there that has harmful side-effects two decades after you eat it? If we make one, that would be one hell of an achievement.
- celiac 14y ago>You could say that about any new product. Here! Use this cellphone! What? The battery can explode when it overheats? Don't worry about it! Almost never happens! If the battery explodes you will know about it. Each explosion will be an independent, isolated event. They will not all blow up at once. A better analogy would appeal to concerns over EM radiation from cell phones. In that case, it turned out to be harmless - at least in terms of cancer risk. And that single, highly-controllable factor took years to validate for safety. >Is there even a plant out there that has harmful side-effects two decades after you eat it? Gluten sensitivity can take years to show up, and months to get better after you've cut it out of your diet. For years doctors dismissed patients who claimed to be suffering from wheat allergies. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.
- DanBC 14y ago> Is there even a plant out there that has harmful side-effects two decades after you eat it? If we make one, that would be one hell of an achievement. I understood the post to mean the cumulative effects of eating that plant. One cigarette is not going to do much, but smoking 40 a day for 30 years is probably going to cause a few problems.
- pyre 14y agoThe food you eat has a lot more intimate interaction with your body than the cellphone that you are using. While we know a great deal about human physiology, it's still an equation that we have yet to solve. The systems of a cellphone (and the battery) are probably better understood, with less variables to account for. Also, when the food at your local grocery store is completely replaced with GMO foods, you don't really end up with a choice in the matter. On the other hand, you still have a choice to get a cellphone or not (even in today's world). | Bananas didn't evolve with "being good for you 20 or | 30 years from now" ethos. That doesn't help the spread | of their seeds. They just needed to taste sweet, so you | would eat them now and spit out their seed somewhere else. Yes, but people have been eating them for a long time, and thus far we haven't found any correlations between them and negative outcomes. | Is there even a plant out there that has harmful side-effects | two decades after you eat it? If we make one, that would be one | hell of an achievement. Are you saying that it's impossible for plants to end up having a cumulative effect on your body? For example, checkout this thread: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4494083 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4494083. Summary: Broccoli has mutagenic and anti-mutagenic properties, and in one study of fruit flies the mutagenic properties won out. What happens when GMO broccoli ends up further tipping this balance towards mutagenic? What happens when another food is engineered and tips the balance from the anti-mutagenic side (to the mutagenic side)?
- enraged_camel 14y ago>>If an early seafarer went down with his/her ship, it didn't affect a significant portion of the population. Not necessarily true. Suppose there is a nation-state A. Further suppose a rival nation-state B captured vital trade routes and started charging trades exorbitant sums of fees, and the long-term well-being of nation-state A depends on its seafarers being able to find alternative trade routes to their trading partners. Note that this is exactly how it went down in history. Only those seafarers who were bold enough to take risks were rewarded.
- ScottBurson 14y agoThere's a huge middle ground between "proven safe" and "proven unsafe". People in this debate seem to forget that. Personally, I want pretty good evidence that something is safe before putting it in my body. If the mere lack of evidence that it's unsafe is sufficient for you, well, that's your choice.
- tinco 14y agoYou can never prove something is safe. The only indication that something is safe is lack of evidence of unsafety multiplied by time. What would be evidence for you that something is safe enough to put into your body?
- ScottBurson 14y agoWell, if a population of several thousand humans had been eating it for 50 years without evident ill effect, I suppose that would be more or less good enough. In any discussion of risk it is important to remember the value to be obtained. I might take a drug with known dangerous side effects on the chance it would cure a disease from which I suffered. But to me, the only possible benefit of eating a GMO food is that it would be somewhat cheaper than something else I could eat. For some people, that might be a good enough reason. For me, it's not.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pohl 14y agoI've never understood this argument. It basically amounts to "yes, there are advantages to GMOs, but we haven't found any disadvantages yet, therefore they are unsafe!" You've got the wrong thing after "therefore". The argument you're trying to paraphrase would probably advocate the Precautionary Principle instead: "... if an action or policy has a suspected risk of causing harm to the public or to the environment, in the absence of scientific consensus that the action or policy is harmful, the burden of proof that it is not harmful falls on those taking the action." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Precautionary_principle http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Precautionary_principle
- bcoates 14y agoI never understood how the Precautionary Principle wasn't just Pascal's Wager and subject to the same logical problems.
- enraged_camel 14y agoPascal's Wager: There is more to be gained from wagering on the existence of God than from atheism, and that a rational person should live as though God exists. Anti-GMO Activists: There is more to be gained from assuming that GMOs are unsafe than that they are safe, and that a rational society should live as if they are unsafe. Sounds like the same logic to me.
- pohl 14y agoA casual observer might suspect that the two of you are being deliberately obtuse in order to cast the Precautionary Principle in negative light so that it might be more easily dismissed. I'll respond as if you are earnest students of reason, seeking to see the difference. Fortunately, the main difference is very simple: Pascal was wagering to gain something that cannot be shown to exist (an afterlife). The Precautionary Principle is counseling us to guard something known to exist (the environment in which we live) that is demonstrably essential to our own existence. Had Pascal been arguing as an atheist about why not to play Russian Roulette with his one and only life, the two arguments might be similar enough to legitimately confuse.