7 ms·
His views are insubstantial. His main argument is that his previous ad hominem positions were not sufficient to condemn GMOs (correct) and that GMOs haven't cau
by graeme 14y ago
His views are insubstantial. His main argument is that his previous ad hominem positions were not sufficient to condemn GMOs (correct) and that GMOs haven't caused any problems yet.
He has not presented evidence that GMO's are safe. He has two main arguments:
1. Trial and error crossbreeding affects entire genes.
2. Viruses sometimes spread genes from one organism to another.
First, trial and error crossbreeding isn't likely to produce anything catastrophic. We've been interbreeding plants for milennia. Current techniques may be more risky, but generally speaking it should be hard for plants to produce a horrid mutation based on natural interbreeding mechanisms.
Second, just becauses cross species gene transfers do occur doesn't mean that it's safe when we do it. If such transfers have occurred in nature for a long, long time, then it's safe to say that nature has created pathways that are safe. Our pathways are new.
I'm making a Talebian argument here. Nature is a VERY complex system. When we mess with it, we make incremental visible gains, and run the risk of large, invisible losses.
It means nothing to say that GMOs haven't caused harm yet. All it would take would be ONE catastrophic GMO plant to cause large amounts of damage. By definition, we won't be able to foresee this until it happens.
HN is a very tech positive community, and also a community that's very aware of the complexity of large system, and their fragility when meddled with. When considering GMOs, many forget complexity due to a pro-technology attitude.
- iand 14y agoI read his argument differently. He is not claiming they are safe in an absolutist sense, merely that they are safe enough to alleviate the food shortage the world faces without them.
- DanBC 14y agoThe world doesn't face a food shortage. We already have enough food. We just don't distribute it. One of the big concerns is micronutrients in Asia. We don't need GMOd crops for vitamin and mineral supplementation.
- bascule 14y agoI'm curious what sort of realistic disaster scenario you think might occur due to cross-species gene transfer (and for that matter, purely synthetic genes) in GMOs, and how the existing safeguards are inadequate against it. Normally I'm against FUD, but please, go nuts, so long as there's a reasonable chance of it occurring (i.e. we're not talking about a mad scientist who wants to create man-eating plants)
- Ygg2 14y agoTheir seeds are known to mingle with domestic corn varieties creating corn that is unusable for consumption. That to me seems like a legit reason to be careful around them. Basically if you a corn farmer, have people around you start planting Monsanto Corn, you have two options: change to Monsanto or switch professions.
- DanBC 14y agoWeed-killer resistance transfers to a weed, helping boost it to invasive species? Some mutation makes crop more vulnerable to a particular plant virus, destroying 80% of that crop in EU or US? A huge multinational wants to include "TERMINATOR GENES" in their crops to make sure the cropped seed cannot grow; environmentalists freak out at the name and oppose that; the multinational doesn't include that gene but now inspect the fields of people on the route of seed delivery and if they find any gene-manipulated crop (which is probable from wind-blown seed) they sue the farmer into oblivion.
- cpeterso 14y ago> Some mutation makes crop more vulnerable to a particular plant virus, destroying 80% of that crop in EU or US? This is already a risk because industrial agriculture is optimized for monocrops.
- graeme 14y agoThis is like arguing that it's ok to build houses that won't resist hurricanes, because they're already vulnerable to fire. GMO risks present an additional risk over already problematic agricultural practices.
- enraged_camel 14y ago>>I'm making a Talebian argument here. Nature is a VERY complex system. When we mess with it, we make incremental visible gains, and run the risk of large, invisible losses. I've never understood this argument. It basically amounts to "yes, there are advantages to GMOs, but we haven't found any disadvantages yet, therefore they are unsafe!" This is basically the equivalent of early seafarers being afraid of uncharted waters and writing on their maps "here be dragons". edit: I should also point out that the complexity of a system does not necessarily mean that messing with it will cause problems. If anything, that same complexity may include many fail-safe mechanisms to prevent problems when the system is messed with.
- pyre 14y agoIf an early seafarer went down with his/her ship, it didn't affect a significant portion of the population. GMO foods are more like, "Hey look! I invented this new banana in a test tube! It looks safe, so it must be! Here eat it! Does it cause problems when you eat these types of bananas for 20 or 30 years? Who knows! Just eat it, it looks safe!"
- maratd 14y agoYou could say that about any new product. Here! Use this cellphone! What? The battery can explode when it overheats? Don't worry about it! Almost never happens! And with cellphones ... that's already happened. Yet you still have one in your pocket. > Does it cause problems when you eat these types of bananas for 20 or 30 years? Bananas didn't evolve with "being good for you 20 or 30 years from now" ethos. That doesn't help the spread of their seeds. They just needed to taste sweet, so you would eat them now and spit out their seed somewhere else. Is there even a plant out there that has harmful side-effects two decades after you eat it? If we make one, that would be one hell of an achievement.
- celiac 14y ago>You could say that about any new product. Here! Use this cellphone! What? The battery can explode when it overheats? Don't worry about it! Almost never happens! If the battery explodes you will know about it. Each explosion will be an independent, isolated event. They will not all blow up at once. A better analogy would appeal to concerns over EM radiation from cell phones. In that case, it turned out to be harmless - at least in terms of cancer risk. And that single, highly-controllable factor took years to validate for safety. >Is there even a plant out there that has harmful side-effects two decades after you eat it? Gluten sensitivity can take years to show up, and months to get better after you've cut it out of your diet. For years doctors dismissed patients who claimed to be suffering from wheat allergies. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence.
- bitcartel 14y agoMark Lynas will find a new career in bad Christmas cracker jokes. Q. What do you call someone who supports nuclear power, shale gas fracking and GM crops? A. An environmentalist.
- CamperBob2 14y agoWhen we mess with it, we make incremental visible gains, and run the risk of large, invisible losses. There are uncountable ways in which we all "mess with" Nature on a daily basis, both individually and as a society. Why single out this one?
- graeme 14y agoBecause of the way we run our agricultural system. We tend to use monocultures, or 'ogilopolies' of certain plant varieties. Past plant varieties were more likely to be safe from hidden vulnerabilities due to the process that created them. Even so, some plants were wiped out by a single surprise event, such as during the Irish potato famine. If, as I argue, GMO crops present more hidden risks, then we are increasing the odds of a catastrophic failure of a staple crop. Growth in the food supply tends to produce a growth in population. This new population is dependent on food supply staying at least at it's current level. If a staple crop fails, then the consequences will be dire. There is little slack in the system.
- CamperBob2 14y agoHmm. I don't see a reason to assume that GMO crops present "more" hidden risks -- since by definition any such risks are hidden in both the GMO and non-GMO cases -- and you certainly haven't provided any such reasons in your post. If we want to avoid future unpleasant surprises like the Potato Famine, it seems to me that the best strategy is to gain the greatest possible mastery of plant genetics. There will be unpleasant surprises along the way but science, like life itself, offers no guarantees. Meanwhile I haven't seen any potato famines lately.
- graeme 14y agoThe reason there are more hidden risks is because we're creating breeds that couldn't occur in nature. We can't understand the full effects of modifications. Natural plants have been tested over time so that we can be somewhat sure they don't have that many unknown weaknesses.
- fennecfoxen 14y agoWithout addressing the validity or invalidity of your assessment of the merits of his position (or the position itself), his views are insubstantial (or at least of limited substance) for some other reasons too. For instance, while he appeals to science and reason here, not all the organic-enviro-antiGMO complex holds its positions for reasons of science. There's a substantial number of people for whom it is part of superstitious and para-religious reasoning behind peoples' objections. (In other news, Whole Foods sells homeopathic remedies.) Even beyond the superstitious, there are a lot of anti-GMO advocates whose primary form of investment is emotional, not intellectual. (Actually, you could probably say that about most political positions...) It's easy enough to treat the guy as a heretic in that sort of environment.
- cheeseprocedure 14y ago> Current techniques may be more risky, but generally speaking it should be hard for plants to produce a horrid mutation based on natural interbreeding mechanisms. What about the (widespread) practice of mutation breeding? [1] Blasting seeds with X-rays and gamma rays in an attempt to generate new cultivars is a genetic wrecking ball compared to performing genetic engineering. Conventional breeding has given us plenty of Oopses. The modern kiwifruit, whose progenitor (the smaller and less tasty Chinese gooseberry) may have been safely snacked upon by many folks who would today suffer a lethal allergic reaction after eating a kiwi. In the 1980s, a mutant variety of zucchini began producing enough cucurbitacin toxin to hospitalize a number of people. [2] > If such transfers have occurred in nature for a long, long time, then it's safe to say that nature has created pathways that are safe. Our pathways are new. We're still playing by nature's fundamental biological rules, and nature has had hundreds of millions of years to develop resiliency inside that same framework. One example: bacterial mechanisms to mitigate the damage from undesirable horizontal gene transfers by recognizing and deactivating to foreign genetic material: [3] > I'm making a Talebian argument here. Nature is a VERY complex system. When we mess with it, we make incremental visible gains, and run the risk of large, invisible losses. I think "incremental" is a bit of an understatement if we can, for example, feed tens of millions of humans in parts of the world where conventional crops cannot (yet?) provide reliable and sufficient nutrition, a critical step in reducing poverty. Having said all this, I think crop monoculture is a serious problem, but I think it's an issue that needs to be solved through sound policy, not just through science. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutation_breeding http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mutation_breeding [2] http://books.google.ca/books?id=Jcq1wTe_93UC&lpg=PP1&dq=genetic+glass+ceilings&pg=PA3&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=kiwi%20fruit&f=false http://books.google.ca/books?id=Jcq1wTe_93UC&lpg=PP1&... [3] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17575047 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17575047
- hcarvalhoalves 14y ago> I think "incremental" is a bit of an understatement if we can, for example, feed tens of millions of humans in parts of the world where conventional crops cannot (yet?) provide reliable and sufficient nutrition, a critical step in reducing poverty. You can argue about many benefits, but genetic engineered crops is hardly a solution to poverty and malnutrition.
- revelation 14y agoThere are no magic pathways for gene "transfer". Theres chromosomal crossover and there are random mutations. These are very very blunt instruments and the only reason they work to create complex organisms is through sheer number of different organisms and natural selection. Nature is messing with nature all the time through pure randomness, the penultimate chaos monkey. Nothing has collapsed.
- ScottBurson 14y agoVery well said, and I'm heartened to see your comment at the top of the page. I think it's worth emphasizing that GMOs aren't a category, from a safety point of view. There can't be any evidence that all GMOs that will ever be produced will be safe, any more than there could be evidence that all drugs that will ever be synthesized will be safe. We have to look at them individually. I don't think the public has digested this point yet. EDITED to add: It's also worth keeping in mind that in some cases, the primary danger may not be from the plant itself, but from pesticides to which it has been engineered to be resistant. I'm speaking, of course, of glyphosate, which I understand is being applied in growing quantities as the weeds it is intended to kill evolve their own resistance.
- andylei 14y ago> Nature is a VERY complex system. When we mess with it, we make incremental visible gains, and run the risk of large, invisible losses. this is an argument against literally any kind of technology. electricity, medicine, computers, steam engines, light bulbs, animal husbandry, farming, ...