7 ms·
There are (at least) three valid perspectives on the patent situation within the software community but part of the reason so little constructive progress is ma
by jandrewrogers 14y ago
There are (at least) three valid perspectives on the patent situation within the software community but part of the reason so little constructive progress is made is that many people with strong opinions will often flat-out deny or reject the validity of the other perspectives because it is outside their experience.
Three perspectives of which most people ignore one or more:
- Computer technology is over-run with frivolous, vague, stupid, conflicting, and contradictory patents. Any pretense of quality control by the USPTO was lost in the 1990s. This imposes a non-trivial cost on the entire ecosystem and a complete absence of quality control is arguably worse than no patents at all.
- R&D into new computer algorithms is a non-trivial investment, frequently requiring years and millions of dollars. There is a tendency among programmers to discount the level of effort required to develop a new computer algorithm that materially extends the state-of-the-art even though most could not develop such algorithms themselves and have never been involved in such R&D. Organizations that make this investment do so looking for a return.
- Academia is already facing difficulties in computer science because much of the state-of-the-art research is being done by private companies. Much of this research is being treated as trade secrets because (ironically) patents offer flimsy practical protection. As a consequence, there are a number of areas in computer science where the leading academic papers are literally a good half decade behind the state-of-the-art that is buried in NDAs. Lack of publication means that a lot of smart people are wasting time duplicating work. Patents were originally invented precisely to avoid this outcome. One of the reasons that I stopped reading academic computer science in some areas that interest me is that I see computer science under NDA that is much more sophisticated, which is a shame.
Any practical policy will need to take into consideration all of these perspectives. It is not as convenient and simple as "all software patents are evil!" or "software patents FTW!" but it more closely reflects the real tradeoffs.
- carterschonwald 14y agoWell said points! It takes time and paying people so they can focus on solving hard problems for real innovation to happen. And its sad when it then has to become proprietary so that the operation can protect having any ROI sharing is caring, and if that means you can have some revenue still, great!
- iskander 14y ago>Academia is already facing difficulties in computer science because much of the state-of-the-art research is being done by private companies...As a consequence, there are a number of areas in computer science where the leading academic papers are literally a good half decade behind the state-of-the-art that is buried in NDAs. Can you elaborate on which areas of CS academia you think are more sophisticated in the corporate wilds? Other than systems work at Google, I haven't encountered any subtopics which aren't dominated by ideas from traditional research centers (either university labs or academic research units at MSR, IBM, etc...)
- bskap 14y agoThat's because you never hear about what's going on outside of the research centers- they're all under NDA.
- Buttons840 14y agoDo companies want to profit from this computer science research being done under a NDA? Don't they have to release these advances in the form of a product to earn a profit? Then show me some products which demonstrate this "cutting-edge" computer science research.
- anonymoushn 14y agoA company could instead profit by trading using their results, and some results could belong to governments. I'm reminded that my graph theory professor said that he could factor polynomials over finite fields in polynomial time, but that he could not tell me how to do it.
- wcarss 14y agoThey don't necessarily have to, and even if they did, it may not be obvious. Consider a financial company working to improve prediction algorithms for their in-house use, hiring smartypants PhDs and giving them free reign and great pay. The result after ten years could be way ahead (or even just a little ahead) of the academic world's work and never release a product with a sticker for a big shiny new algorithm. The firm wouldn't even have to stand out in its success; it could do reasonably well compared to others, and just attribute a lot of its modest success to its algorithmic insights. Even in externally released products, really clever ways to get around things aren't necessarily visible. Just today I was reading about Jonathan Blow's work [1] on localised kriging [2] for his upcoming game The Witness. He's pulling from advanced geostatics academia for a little feature he wanted in a game, and if he didn't blog about it (and then discuss enhancements in the comments) no one would know it existed - even once the game is released. A small example to be sure, but I think it exemplifies the point. [1] http://the-witness.net/news/2010/05/kriging-is-cool/ http://the-witness.net/news/2010/05/kriging-is-cool/ [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kriging http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kriging
- jberryman 14y agoI'm interested in a reply to iskander's question as well as some concrete examples of new "computer algorithms... frequently requiring years and millions of dollars".
- shmerl 14y agoYep, examples would be interesting. There are counter examples - like the open Opus audio codec, which was developed by collaboration of various engineers and which is state of art precisely because they weren't burdened by stupid patenting issues, and could instead concentrate on creating a beautiful technology.
- rayiner 14y agoHow is it a counter example? Open Opus is built on patented technologies that are licensed royalty free by the original inventors (Broadcom, Xiph.org, Microsoft, etc). It certainly wasn't cheap to develop--the development cost is just being subsidized so the end result can be given out freely.
- kkowalczyk 14y ago"Patented" doesn't equal "was expensive to develop". In the context of codecs we're actually seeing how it prohibits improvements of technology. Broadly speaking (i.e. I'm sure there are counter-examples, but they are not significant in the big picture), people didn't patent compiler technology, and we had great progress in compiler technology. People didn't patent database technology and we had great progress in database technologies, from both academic research and competition. People didn't patent word processing technologies so that Google can re-implement Word functionality in the browser because none of the fundamental techniques have been patented. Again, lots of progress from competition. For whatever reason, audio and video codecs are heavily patented and the technology is ludicrously outdated compared to what it could have been if we had progress from competition or academic work of free software implementations because the patents cover basic ideas in compression so no-one can build on them and patent holders have no incentive to improve the technology because it's much easier (and more profitable) to just collect royalty checks. However, developing video codecs isn't any more expensive than developing databases or compilers or word processors. See e.g. h264 encoder which is an open-source effort by few amateurs that is widely regarded as being of better quality than commercial offering costing thousands of dollars (because of patent monopolies, not because they were so expensive to develop).
- belorn 14y ago> R&D into new computer algorithms is a non-trivial investment, frequently requiring years and millions of dollars. There is a strong opinion among computer researchers that pure algorithms are indistinguishable from math, and thus should be unpatentable. The math guy doing research on sound waves might be slightly annoyed when he gets denied a patent, but the guy working "on a computer" with the exact same math, doing the exact same research, gets a patent because he described the math "on a computer". Of course, we could just start letting math also be patentable, because it too requires non-trivial investment, frequently requiring many many years and millions of dollars. That is, if the work behind something alone is enough to qualify for patentability.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- AnthonyMouse 14y ago>R&D into new computer algorithms is a non-trivial investment, frequently requiring years and millions of dollars. There is a tendency among programmers to discount the level of effort required to develop a new computer algorithm that materially extends the state-of-the-art even though most could not develop such algorithms themselves and have never been involved in such R&D. Organizations that make this investment do so looking for a return. I don't think critics of software patents are in the practice of claiming that software R&D is always quick or inexpensive. Rather, the claim is that the patent system is demonstrably incapable of improving that situation, and in the meantime has spawned enormously wasteful multi-billion dollar litigation between otherwise upstanding major companies and struck fear into the hearts of small developers who can no longer produce a successful innovative product without risking a shakedown by despicable parasites. Companies expecting a return have numerous other, less innovation-damaging alternatives to software patents. First to market advantage, copyright and trade secrets cover the field pretty well on their own, and no one can accuse any of those things of causing the average software entrepreneur to lose sleep over the prospect of totally unpredictable ruinous litigation.
- coopdog 14y agoThe litigation is very damaging, it's also true however that research is being doubled/tripled/etc as it's done in private by multiple organisations and kept as trade secrets, which is inefficient when you consider the world as a whole. It's just that we can't presently see any regulation based solution for that.
- AnthonyMouse 14y agoI understand that duplication is inefficient, but how is the patent system doing anything productive whatsoever to address it in the software industry? If something with market value can be kept as a trade secret then the incentive will be to do so notwithstanding the patent system, and then to patent various other things for legal defensive purposes which are less valuable in the market but more valuable in the courtroom. And things which can't effectively be held as trade secrets won't be wastefully duplicated anyway because the first to produce such a product is by stipulation unable to keep the secret. More than that, if we were at all concerned about the use of trade secrets causing wasteful duplication then we cannot consistently allow the law to protect them as something of value. If we are so keen on disclosure and reducing duplication then industrial espionage should be fully legal as an efficient means of distributing knowledge to other market participants, and holders of trade secrets should be directed to the Patent Office as their sole means of protection. But I think we are not so keen because the problem of duplication is not so large, and the incentive provided by the patent system would not compare well with the incentive provided by the alternative.
- mbell 14y agoI don't disagree with your premise per-say, but, I do think its pretty easy for me, personally, to dismiss some of these positions wholesale. 1) I agree with 2) Computer technology moves at such a breakneck pace and is generally so hard to reverse engineer that this point doesn't hold water for me. We know that google's search algorithm works, ok, but can we reverse engineer it from the outside? The answer seems to be no, so why protect it with patents? Even if we could, by the time we were done google would already be on to the 'next big improvement', there is no catching up in software short of a drastic stumbling in the incombent, should we really protect the incombant from messing up? 3) The entire concept of going to college for software related endeavors is in such peril straits that I don't think we should even consider the affects or impacts of academia on software development, it's well in past at this point regardless of the patent situation.
- bjustin 14y agoWe know how Google's algorithm works in no small part because Larry and Sergey came up with it as part of their graduate studies at Stanford. Stanford owns the patent(s?) on it and made hundreds of millions licensing it to Google.
- mbell 14y agoYou know how it worked ten years ago. Do you really think that has much to do with how it works today?