3 ms·
> Everyone knows someone with a story about some horrible entry into the US. Everyone knows someone who has a friend who knew the guy who tried to dry his pood
by anamax 18y ago
> Everyone knows someone with a story about some horrible entry into the US.
Everyone knows someone who has a friend who knew the guy who tried to dry his poodle in the microwave.
I'm not saying that Immigration and/or Homeland Security is great, but the rumor-mongering is unjustified.
> the problem is that it can happen at all and they're not screw-ups, it's policy.
And you know this because....
> I am an Australian citizen from birth
Ah, Australia. I know a Stanford CS PhD student who was put through hell by the Australian equivalent of US Immigration/Homeland Security because she wanted to visit a guy who she met while he was in the US. They were concerned that she might want to stay, contaminate the gene pool, or somesuch. (She's pretty and white, so they weren't applying any sort of appearance standard.)
Really. I actually know her. And, you should have paid her to emmigrate because she is seriously talented. And yes, she was seriously pissed.
Nevertheless, I don't get hysterical about it. I'm looking forward to diving the Great Barrier Reef in a couple of years.
> If I want to enter the US I face being photographed and my fingerprints taken like a common criminal.
I don't know how things are in Australia, but we can't identify criminals and the like without actually checking. (For some reason, they don't mention that in their visa application.)
Are you suggesting that we shouldn't try?
- tjmc 18y ago> I don't know how things are in Australia, but we can't identify criminals and the like without actually checking. Interesting viewpoint. Would you have a problem with having your photograph and fingerprints taken whenever you boarded a domestic flight? I'm sure they'd catch plenty of criminals that way too.
- anamax 18y ago> Interesting viewpoint. Would you have a problem with having your photograph and fingerprints taken whenever you boarded a domestic flight? I'm sure they'd catch plenty of criminals that way too. It's interesting that you think that domestic travel and crossing a national border are the same. I know that Australia is concerned about young women visiting. Does it also care about criminals? Does it have any checks? And, if it does, I'm sure that you're fighting any that aren't applied to domestic travel, right?
- sho 18y ago"It's interesting that you think that domestic travel and crossing a national border are the same." You're deliberately missing his point. His point is that if your objective is to catch criminals, and in pursuit of that goal you're willing to set up checkpoints to collect fingerprints, and you're the US authorities primarily concerned with US criminals - wouldn't it be far better to set up those checkpoints inside the country? It would be, and so obviously these fingerprint checks are not to catch criminals. And before you say it, no, I can't prove that, I am merely using deduction to make an argument for use in debate, which I believe is the point of this site. "I know that Australia is concerned about young women visiting. " Oh yes, from your personal anecdote about one (1) person. Australia is not perfect but you would be hard pressed to find much evidence, even anecdotal, that on balance it even comes close to the oppresive US border experience. And personally I am firmly in favour of as many young women visiting as possible : ) "Does it also care about criminals? Does it have any checks?" Yes, of course, and yes, it has checks. I am assuming you're a US Citizen - you'd need an ETAS visa; you apply in advance, pay some nominal fee, and the check is performed before you even get on the plane. Your visa is then automatically keyed to your personal information and passport number. Australian citizens need a similar visa from the US, which is called USVISIT. The fingerprints are then taken upon arrival regardless, making everyone wonder what the damn point of the visa was in the first place. And Australian passports are electronically encoded with biometric information, btw, and are very hard to fake. It would be much easier to simply fake the fingerprints, as Japan has discovered (one South Korean was recently arrested after entering Japan using fake fingerprints five times). "And, if it does, I'm sure that you're fighting any that aren't applied to domestic travel, right?" A spurious strawman argument which I won't respond to.
- anamax 18y ago> His point is that if your objective is to catch criminals, and in pursuit of that goal you're willing to set up checkpoints to collect fingerprints, and you're the US authorities primarily concerned with US criminals - wouldn't it be far better to set up those checkpoints inside the country? The US has no laws against criminals travelling (assuming that they're not being pursued). It has laws against people with certain characteristics entering the country. In short, the "catch criminals" premise was wrong.
- sho 18y ago"Everyone knows someone who has a friend who knew the guy who tried to dry his poodle in the microwave." I'm not sure what you mean. I'm not talking about some urban legend that gets passed through 10 generations of "friends of friends", I'm saying that many people have had bad experiences with US Immigration, and word gets around. I personally know someone who now enters the US by land via Canada because of his repeated horrendous experiences at the air border. "I'm not saying that Immigration and/or Homeland Security is great, but the rumor-mongering is unjustified." Rumours? It goes a bit beyond rumours, don't you think? It's large-scale and well-documented. Personal anecdotes alone do not make something true, but that's not the case here. The personal anecdotes just add a more of a "this could happen to me" dimension to otherwise abstract reports of it happening to someone else. "And you know this because...." Because .. it's self evident and obviously true? What are you trying to say - that the hostile suspicion of foreigners at the US Border is not policy? "I know a Stanford CS PhD student who was put through hell by the Australian equivalent of US Immigration/Homeland Security" I'm not trying to say we're much better, although at least we don't fingerprint. I have many (in some cases personally witnessed/experienced) grievances against the Australian system. No need to turn this into a "my country is better than yours" pissing match, I have a real fondness for America and wouldn't even bother having a strong opinion if I didn't care ; ) "Nevertheless, I don't get hysterical about it." Sigh. I hope I didn't come across as hysterical. I put a bit of emotion into my writing in an attempt to get the point across that it's important to me, not as a sign that I have taken leave of my senses. "I don't know how things are in Australia, but we can't identify criminals and the like without actually checking." Huh? We're talking about the US Border, specifically about foreigners trying to visit, many who have never been there before. Are you suggesting that there is a huge list of outstanding arrest warrants for foreign criminals whose faces and fingerprints are on record, and this system is an attempt to catch them? Or that US Border agents are cooperating with overseas police forces to catch escaping criminals or something? Of course not. I actually don't know why they do it. The whole thing is post-9/11 so I suppose it's part of the "war on terror", but surely the number of "terrorists" who are on the run but whose fingerprints have somehow been recorded is vanishingly small. Anyway, I hope that with the new administration in charge and the memory of 9/11 receding, this horrible system will be turned off.
- 18y ago