4 ms·
> While Android still doesn’t give you bouncing lists and scroll views It used to be in Android until Apple made it a 1 billion dollar lawsuit and banned every
by josteink 14y ago
> While Android still doesn’t give you bouncing lists and scroll views
It used to be in Android until Apple made it a 1 billion dollar lawsuit and banned everyone else in the universe from implementing it.
Those bouncing lists. 1 billion dollar. And Apple is not a patent-troll. No siree.
- dasil003 14y agoThey might be dicks, but it would still be dilution of the term "patent troll" to call them that. After all, they do actually sell a product with said feature.
- fpgeek 14y agoThis is why I prefer to say "patent ogre". It is clearly different, but also clear that there is a similar-scale problem.
- lucian1900 14y agoReally? I've never seen it in Android.
- josteink 14y agoIt may be a TouchWiz thing, but I've seen it on Samsung phones I've owned. That is until Apple decided to throw patent lawsuits around. A firmware-update later and gone it was. These days most Android-phones have a "overflow" effect when reaching the end of a list. Specifically designed to avoid lawsuits.
- driverdan 14y agoMy LG Optimus V running Android 2.1 has bouncy scrolling in the browser but not in most standard apps.
- taligent 14y agoI'm confused what part bothers you. That Apple patented it. Or that it is worth a billion dollars. Because if it's the first then it is just a hypocritical position. And if it's the second then maybe you don't understand the math. Size of lawsuit = Price per patent * Number of infringing devices. It's because the number of devices sold is so large that it ends up being such a large lawsuit.
- josteink 14y agoFor sake of clarity, both bothers me, but it's the fact that a trivial UI implementation detail can be patented and monopolized I consider fundamentally wrong. That someone can build a 1 billion dollar beast on top of that, what any decent software engineer can do in a matter of days, just makes it so much worse. Some people have a rather mellow attitude to it all and simply say "Don't hate the player, hate the game". I proclaim the right to hate the game and anyone who plays it. Apple should have some pride and a sense of dignity. Apple should be better than this. Clearly they are not.
- taligent 14y agoFirstly there is nothing trivial about it. The concept never existed before the iPhone and it is absolutely not intuitive that it is how list scrolling is supposed to work. It's unquestionably distinctive to the iPhone. Secondly what a software engineer can do in a matter of days is a ridiculous and pointless measure of anything. I could build Google's original search engine once I knew exactly how it worked. It's the "how it works" part that is novel. Thirdly you completely fail at understanding the maths here. The only reason it is a billion dollar idea is because Samsung sells so many devices.
- kbutler 14y ago> The concept never existed before the iPhone and it is absolutely not intuitive The USPTO disagrees: http://www.fosspatents.com/2012/10/patent-office-tentatively-invalidates.html http://www.fosspatents.com/2012/10/patent-office-tentatively... "In a non-final Office action the USPTO has declared all 20 claims of Apple's rubber-banding patent (U.S. Patent No, 7,469,381 invalid [for prior art and obviousness]... A finding of anticipation is a determination that there was no inventive step at all."
- eunice 14y agoare you suggesting there is a mobile os vendor that isn't a patent troll? goog spent 12bn acquiring a failing company just to patent troll
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]