4 ms·
The article seems to miss the whole point of the social network functionality. For example, it states: "Diaspora has now reached a level of basic functionality,
by PeterisP 14y ago
The article seems to miss the whole point of the social network functionality. For example, it states: "Diaspora has now reached a level of basic functionality, so that it could be used for many purposes we now rely on other services for. [...] You can post text and pictures."
In a social network, there isn't an use case "post text and pictures" - the real use case is "post a picture of my kid so that my mom can see it"; and Diaspora fails at that, as my mom isn't there, she's on facebook. An useful use case is "post a morning rant so my friends can see it" and it fails if my friends aren't on that network.
"read user posts" is a weak feature, but "read Bieber's posts" is a feature greatly valued by millions of teenagers - and Diaspora doesn't have that feature, Twitter has.
The core value of any social site or network isn't in the software, but in the community. If the interesting people aren't there, then the service is useless to me, so I won't read or post. If the facebook site was opensourced and used by Diaspora, even then it would bring orders of magnitude less value to users simply because of the smaller community.
What is Diaspora's plan for solving the user acquisition? Facebook replaced university 'facebooks' to get initial 'hot' users; Twitter got the critical mass from a few early adopter celebrities; Google+ is bootstrapping off of gmail contacts. Tech part is 1% of the resulting value, user part is 99% of it.
If Diaspora can't show a reasonable path how they will resolve the chicken-and-egg issue to get a critical mass of users, then it's not worth to invest time and emotions in posting there.
- shmerl 14y agoIn a social network, there isn't an use case "post pictures" - the real use case is "post a picture of my kid so that my mom can see it" No, you miss the point. The purpose of social network is connecting people. Posting a picture for mom to see it is just one example of social interactions, there are multiple others which can be done through social network. For example exchanging ideas. Yes, Diaspora needs to add more features to become more friendly and versatile. But it's not about making a Facebook clone. It's about giving people an option of free social network. The point of the article - start using it now if you care about freedom. The more users it will get, the more feedback and more potential developers. It's not yet about "those who post pictures just come now - it'll replace all your Facebook use cases". If Diaspora can't show a reasonable path to get a critical mass of users, then it's not worth to invest time and emotions in posting there. I'd say if one doesn't share the sentiment of the author of that article (i.e. understanding of the need for free social networks), then one won't find reasons to invest time and effort in it already now. But the article isn't addressed to such people on the other hand.
- Tloewald 14y agoIt seems like the only way to fight Facebook would be to embrace (er wait, leverage) it ... Something that simply crossposts to your account but draws anyone interested out. Whether the tool is like FB or G+ or Twitter or something else is irrelevant, it needs to integrate with all of the above while holding YOUR stuff outside.
- dllthomas 14y agoI... think you miss the parent's point, which is that the features a social network provides to an individual user aren't just technological. The point is connecting people to other people and almost always that means to specific other people, and if those specific other people aren't on the new network that's not a feature the new network provides until they migrate, and that's not something you can fix with just tech (except maybe by automating crossposts? hmm...) Edited to add: Joining a social network is, therefore, adding features (when viewed through this lens) without doing any coding.
- shmerl 14y agoYes, in such way just the mere fact of joining has a side consequence of increasing user base. But in most cases those who join and don't participate are often not reading the network as well, since they have no connections there (they aren't following tags or have contacts and etc). So real help for the network are participating users.
- dllthomas 14y agoIt's absolutely the case that participating users add more to the system than nonparticipating users (hmm, possibly moderated a bit by signal-to-noise ratio...?)
- throwaway125 14y agoThe core value of any social site or network isn't in the software, but in the community. The article recognizes this and suggests that the people who care about freedom should make the initial 'investment' by creating an account, thereby increasing the value of the network for everyone else.
- shmerl 14y agoI think it's more than just creating an account. It's about contributing with relevant content, discussions and other ways of participation which increase the value of the network itself.
- potatolicious 14y agoBut that's now how this works. If everyone on HN went and created an account and went to great pains to post relevant things to it, it would still be useless. The success of a social network hinges on a wide base of appeal. Facebook was inherently mainstream from the get-go, starting with colleges. Twitter bootstrapped off of celebrities and famous people who have an audience that transcends simple subcultural boundaries (Lady GaGa instead of Edward Tufte, for example). "People who care about software freedom" have little relevant content to anyone but themselves. Getting these people to create accounts and post will only succeed in creating yet another place from a niche, isolated demographic to hang out - and we're not really in desperate need for yet another meeting ground for free software folk. Google+ for example has seen tremendous uptake by photography enthusiasts. I enjoy using it greatly for this purpose - but break into the mainstream is certainly has not, and never will with this group.
- pyre 14y ago> Facebook was inherently mainstream from the get-go I joined Facebook in 2003, didn't get what the point was (they wanted me to fill in my school schedule, etc), and got a friend request from someone that I wasn't on good terms with in highschool. I never bothered to remove the account, but I think I've logged in < 10 times since then. I think that Facebook was only 'mainstream' within a certain set of people from the get-go. Also, Facebook 'from the get-go' wasn't just the Facebook of today with less users.
- qznc 14y agoResolve chicken-and-egg? Get some hackernewsers in for example. Let us create accounts and use the #hackernews hash tag to connect. There seems to be no group feature like the one Google+ added recently, is there? That would make it easier to create niche communities.
- pavel_lishin 14y agoHow many HackerNews members are you connected to on Facebook and Google+? I already have a social network that connects me to Hacker News readers: Hacker News.
- BUGHUNTER 14y agoFB success was based on tricking their users into giving FB access to their email accounts and spamming all their contacts. I assume this is no good way for an alternative network to find users. It is great when Diaspora becomes a network of more conscious people that use their brain before giving access to their private data + contacts to some company - one of the best "selling points" is quality, in the long run, not quantity. FB will be a "dumb-teeny-place" in a few years, decentralized and privacy-protecting networks will win, but grow much slower. No problem with that.
- Tichy 14y agoI'm pretty sure that if you told your mum "hey, mum, here is a pic of my kid on Diaspora", she would join Diaspora, too.
- philbarr 14y agoYes - this is the only reason my Mum is on Facebook.
- jschuur 14y agoOnly if it's easy enough for her to do on her own, or you do it for her and the site is at least easy enough to use on her on after she has an account. There's plenty of great sites more non tech savvy users should be using. Subtle usability touches decide if they actually do use them.
- anywherenotes 14y agoI agree. However there is something to be said about different approach to social media. Twitter isn't a Facebook clone, it has a different approach to being social. Google has a chance to compete with Facebook, because of the gmail users + android users. But next big social network can't be just a copy of facebook functionality with a GNU stamp on it, and some technical differences that make no impact on end users (centralized storage or not). I wish I knew what the next big social network needs ...
- Maro 14y agoWorks on mobile? I usually have Facebook open in a tab on my desktop/macbook. But I never check it on my iPhone, somehow the content on Facebook (mostly funny pics, articles, sometimes actual photos of friends at events) doesn't fit the context I'm in while I'm away from my desk (at home or at work). It's just not important enough to check out on that tiny screen, plus it's harder to interact with (Like, comment, see who else interacted with it). I actually deleted the Facebook app because I was annoyed by the alerts. I usually just check HN when I'm bored on public transportation, the pure textual content here (the comments) are much easier to consume on an iPhone for me. Having said that, I'm pretty old at almost 32, so maybe it's just me.
- anywherenotes 14y agoYou can completely disable facebook alerts from the facebook app. On Galaxy 3 the screen is big enough for the app, but I do turn it landscape.
- dllthomas 14y agoWell, really it doesn't miss the point - it's trying to bootstrap this way because of that point. A social network with no technical capabilities is roughly as useless as a social network with no users. Once you have the one, you need to push for the other if you want to provide value; that's what they're trying to do here.
- tanaqot 14y ago>my mom isn't there, she's on facebook the problem is that facebook does not allow to friend your mom from other social networks - Diaspora, Friendica, Google Plus, etc. If it were, you would have your info let's say on your own Diaspora node, and your mom wouldn't have to register in Diaspora network in order to see them. She only would have to friend you from her existing facebook account. Why it is not possible now? Why we assume this is normal? The problem is that we don't have good enough anti monopolistic laws that would prohibit facebook to not allow to friend fb users from other networks like Diaspora. So we could choose service provider, or set up our own, like we can do in case of email servers. Oh, I forgot - email was designed by scientists, not capitalists. If it were designed by capitalists, it would not allow you to send pics from yahoo to google. Or, big corporations would make agreemensts, like they fight with patents now, but small entrepreneurs wouldn't have the possibility to provide a service, or at list I wouldn't have my own email server. However, now I run my own Diaspora node.
- shmerl 14y agoE-mail in the early days also prevented users from communicating with users of other servers (most notorious examples were AOL and Compuserve). Eventually under pressure that wall was broken. You can compare it to IM services which use XMPP but don't allow federation, which is one of the main points of XMPP. And Facebook does exactly that with their IM service - they use XMPP but don't federate, thus not allowing their users to communicate with other XMPP networks. Kind of expectable from Facebook ;)
- tanaqot 14y agoamazing. When I was writing "e-mail" I meant SMTP based post. AOL used SMTP, which is Internet standard and defined by RFC and yet prohibited from communicating with other servers? wow. are you sure? I am in denial. (:
- shmerl 14y agoThis probably predates SMTP, but I can't find a solid review of this historic issue. I'll look around. UPDATE: It's mentioned here for example: http://www.michaelrobertson.com/archive.php?minute_id=192 http://www.michaelrobertson.com/archive.php?minute_id=192