11 ms·
> You can use private litigation (sue someone for poisoning you) but that is wholly impractical. I'll never understand how people can suppose that a government
by baddox 14y ago
> You can use private litigation (sue someone for poisoning you) but that is wholly impractical.
I'll never understand how people can suppose that a government solution, which consists of a massive nation-wide bureaucracy as well as an immense violent army of what I endearingly call "the conflict resolvers" (law enforcement, courts, etc.) funded mostly by compulsory financial levies on working residents, is by any definition or stretch of the imagination "more efficient" than private litigation.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago> I'll never understand how ... And if, after looking at the example of lead, you still don't understand the role of regulation, it's likely that you never will.
- Camillo 14y agoI wouldn't blame him, though. He might have breathed in a lot of lead as a child.
- vbuterin 14y agoPrivate litigation ALSO has a nation-wide bureaucracy with an immense army of "conflict resolvers", and is often so inefficient that the litigation itself if often used by powerful corporations as a means of harassing their enemies. We need massive legal simplification, I agree, but that doesn't necessarily mean just moving to private litigation and being done with it.
- baddox 14y agoSome private litigation firms will probably always be bloated and inefficient, but that's just great news to their competitors. It's no different than private retail stores: some are inefficient, but the more efficient ones tend to do better (or pressure the inefficient ones to improve).
- sophacles 14y agoOr more likely just result in the inefficient one (almost always an indicator of having more resources) buying the efficient one or simply undercutting them out of business, in order to maintain their status. It is cheaper to just get rid of the competition than to actually improve your own practices.
- baddox 14y agoAnd how, pray tell, is a government solution (which is not only monopolistic, but uses violence rather than shady business tactics to maintain its monopoly) any better?
- sophacles 14y agoHow is me depriving you of your ability to live (you know, get food, etc) via economic harm any different in violence than a government depriving you of your ability to live (via guns)? Is it because slow painful deaths by starvation, caused by a guy with a grudge are what you want for the world? Is it because that threat isn't really different other than the totemic difference of the removal of the word govermment (aka your magic symbol for evil)?
- baddox 14y agoYou need to define "depriving you of your ability to live." If you mean stealing someone's food or annexing their farm land, then I'm absolutely against that. If you mean choosing to not give someone some of your food, or causing someone's business to fail because your competing business is more successful, or choosing to not employ the, because they are unqualified or underperforming, then I find no blame. I do not believe that I have a moral, legal, or societal obligation to provide for anyone or everyone, but more importantly, I do not believe that a society where people are forced to do so under threat of violence (i.e. every government in history) will have less poverty.
- onetwothreefour 14y agoPlease direct me to these efficient lawyers. I think everyone in the world would like to become their customer. It's pretty clear to me that you have never been involved with "private litigation".
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- bane 14y agoYou've obviously never been involved in private litigation before.
- clavalle 14y ago'Private litigation' is my new favorite oxymoron. Litigation cannot exist without your so-called 'conflict resolvers'.
- rayiner 14y agoI love how lawyers suddenly become libertarian heroes in this particular debate.
- baddox 14y agoThat is false, and I don't understand why you think conflict resolution works better when it is violent and compulsory.
- clavalle 14y agoDeclaring it false does not make it so. Violence is always a specter (a potential action) in any conflict between people. The question is; How do we minimize the role of violence in coming to resolutions to conflicts? I think the rules we've evolved to answer that question of the course of human history have done a decent job. Do you have a different set of rules that you think would better optimize this minimization problem? I'd love to hear it.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago> I'd love to hear it. And sadly you are dealing with a Libertarian and you will.
- baddox 14y agoYes, because "Libertarians" (improperly capitalized) are the only people who express their ideas to other people. Good point.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago> because libertarians are the only people who express their ideas to other people. Express them like this? yeah. Well, libertarians and Jehovah's witnesses.
- jpdoctor 14y ago> I'll never understand how people can suppose that a government solution,... is by any definition or stretch of the imagination "more efficient" than private litigation. You mean private litigation which employs gov't judges to adjudicate and the gov't police to enforce? If so, you have a confusing definition of private. The only private litigation I'm aware of is the mob, which has a self-contained judgement and enforcement arm. I would agree with you: They're damn efficient.
- baddox 14y ago> You mean private litigation which employs gov't judges to adjudicate and the gov't police to enforce? No, I mean private litigation and conflict mediation that is private. There is a lot of that already.
- kolinko 14y agoHow would that work?
- baddox 14y agoThe same way any private industry works. People or organizations offer services, and individuals choose which services to pay for.
- kolinko 14y agoSo, I'd pay a private company to arbitrage between me and the company which caused my lead poisoning? And what happens when the private company doesn't agree with the arbitrage result?
- rayiner 14y agoAnd it blows because the conflict mediators side with the people who have the deepest pockets and can offer repeat business.
- 14y ago