2 ms·
I generally don't plumb people's comment histories. Your post fit the half-decent troll template perfectly. Controversial topic: check. Used inflammatory lan
by jacques_chester 14y ago
I generally don't plumb people's comment histories.
Your post fit the half-decent troll template perfectly.
Controversial topic: check.
Used inflammatory language: check.
Had some half-reasonable-sounding stuff too: check.
Mentioned high-profile participant by name: check.
I'm glad to learn that you were a false positive. But, given the same prima facie facts again, I'd make the same judgement again.
- rpm4321 14y agoHey jacques_chester, fair enough. It obviously wasn't only you who assumed that, because unfortunately the post was flagged. In retrospect it was obviously the S word that did me in, but it really didn't seem out of line compared to the dozens of very popular, slightly-NSFW titles I've seen on HN over the years. Anyway, I've reposted it with a safer title in case you want to chime in on the debate. Hopefully it takes off again because I really would love to hear PG's take on the whole thing: news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5006328 Boy, I don't remember ever seeing a comment war escalate and de-escalate so quickly. Maybe there's hope for the Middle East after all. ;)