2 ms·
If you have a daughter this is a good example to use to explain why it's not a good idea to get black-out drunk with a bunch of guys. No I'm not blaming the vi
by ams6110 14y ago
If you have a daughter this is a good example to use to explain why it's not a good idea to get black-out drunk with a bunch of guys.
No I'm not blaming the victim. But reality is what it is.
If you have a son this is a good example to use to explain how he should react if he finds himself in a situation where his "friends" are about to do something absolutely abhorrent.
- rdtsc 14y agoThere is actually a perverse side of the coin here in respect to drunk driving laws in some states. Some states basically do not diminish the guilt and the punishment of someone who was driving drunk by arguing they should be completely responsible for what they did while drunk. That has been applied in cases of rape/sex while drunk at parties. Crime victims sometimes face an uphill battle in court if they had consented to sex while drunk.
- xyzzyz 14y agoCrime victims sometimes face an uphill battle in court if they had consented to sex while drunk. I don't know how it works in the US, but in my country, when a person consents to sex while drunk, even though they wouldn't consent while sober, it's not considered to be a rape. The justification is that adult people know how alcohol works and may decide not to drink it, and the amount of alcohol needed to get someone drunk enough is too big to make someone intoxicated without them realizing. Of course, it also means that having sex with someone who passed out is rape, and so is getting someone to consent after giving them rape pills, for you can make someone ingest them without them realizing.
- rdtsc 14y agoI think in some instances (in some states) the claim brought by the victim as "I was drunk so even though I consented I didn't mean to really since I was impaired" carries more weight than in others. This happens for young college students for example who go to parties with people don't know, drink and then have to deal with the consequences. So we want to protect the victims of sexual abuse but also be very harsh on drunk drives except that the two are at odds. Now there is nothing stopping laws to passed that are logically inconsistent but of course we need to preserve at least a superficial objectivity so people keep believing in the legal system.
- Maxious 14y agoI'm not blaming the victim except when I am.
- rfrey 14y agoThat doesn't seem fair to me in this case, Maxious. Telling a daughter that certain circumstances makes her more likely to be a victim of crime is not the same as blaming her. Even advising her to avoid those circumstances is not blaming her. It's perfectly consistent to counsel a daughter to avoid getting too drunk with hormone-and-mysogyny driven teenage boys, for fear of her safety, AND to love her and support her completely were she to ignore your advice and the worst happened.
- socialist_coder 14y agoSupposedly she was drugged after being tricked into going on a date with one of the rapists, who just happened to be friends with her ex-boyfriend, whom said she "would be sorry for breaking up with him".
- illuminate 14y ago"No I'm not blaming the victim. But reality is what it is." I'm not X, but X. "it is what it is" does not make it sound any less stupid and vulgar.