5 ms·
It's very distressing (as at least one other poster has noted) that we have this sort of "Aha, but now they are treated the same as the poor people!" thing even
by angersock 14y ago
It's very distressing (as at least one other poster has noted) that we have this sort of "Aha, but now they are treated the same as the poor people!" thing even possible in our system. It is troubling that there is this obvious built-in bias towards justice-as-a-function-of-wealth.
A somewhat longer-term issue is this: If it becomes common knowledge that the Feds don't fight fair, and that my resources can be used against me and mine via seizure and what not--why do I want to stay in the US and play the game? Even more cynically, why do I want to play a game I can't win according to their rules--wouldn't my money be better spent on dead drops for harassment, assassins, or something against public officials?
I mean, that's the very real risk of this sort of thing, right? That we undermine the values of our society and provide incentives for extralegal defense? And that these measures in turn spur further degradation to "fight the terrorists/crime lords/etc." in one big swooping downwards spiral?
(Edit: The use of first-person is writing style, not intended as "I want to do X to the gubberment" lunacy, etc. etc.)
- pekk 14y agoIf you want to engage in criminal activities that will raise the interest of the FBI, is it really a problem that you wouldn't want to "stay in the US and play the game"? I don't think most people would want you playing those kinds of games here.
- angersock 14y agoWere it only that clear cut. Which activities, precisely, are criminal? What if I don't know? What if I do something else, the FBI doesn't care, but I happened to have accidentally banged DA's car door or something? Or cursed at a TSA agent? There are very bad people out there, and we certainly don't want them--I wouldn't argue that anyway. But there are a lot of technical criminals who probably don't even know it.
- swalkergibson 14y agoIgnorance of the law is no excuse. Never has been, never will be.
- pdonis 14y agoThat rule assumes that it is possible for a reasonable person to know what actions are within the law and what actions are not. Many laws, particularly those dealing with corporations, the tax code, etc., are so complicated that an ordinary citizen can't possibly know whether they are in compliance or not.
- jzwinck 14y agoWhat about people who do intend to work within the law, but are uncomfortable building wealth in a country which may deprive them of that wealth when they need it most? Not only guilty people get indicted. I think the previous commenter was right: this could become an incentive for people to take their business elsewhere, or at least keep more capital offshore.
- angersock 14y agoTo put a more useful spin on it, how to solve the following problems: 1. How do we decouple material wealth from a justice system? Can we? 2. How do we prevent ratcheting effects as mentioned in the final paragraph? 3. How do we structure laws so that (1) may be, for example automated?
- podperson 14y agoThe Federal government in the US can pretty much screw people it wants to screw. I think that's fairly well established. The same is true in every other country I can think of -- at least in the US the fact remains that if you're genuinely innocent you can have your day in court. If anything characters like Conrad Black get away with -- figuratively -- murder. The question is -- do we have someone more sympathetic than a guy who looted his own companies and a serial killer to serve as an example of this kind of thing being done to genuinely innocent victims? Forbes may regard Conrad Black as a sympathetic victim, but I don't think most reasonable people would. What the writer of this article doesn't like is that the Federal government will do some very nasty things -- in court -- to people it knows are guilty but hard to convict of their actual crimes. In most other countries if the government hates you that much you'll have much worse to worry about.
- gyardley 14y agoSee, this is the problem - thanks to a decade's worth of state-sponsored smear campaigns, you think Conrad Black 'looted his own companies', when that's just not borne by the facts at all. I wish you luck finding someone who looks more sympathetic after the government finishes up with them. And while I agree with your statement about 'most other countries', Americans should hold their government to a higher standard.
- foobarqux 14y agoCan you set the record straight with respect to the Black case?
- gyardley 14y agoI'd have to write a book, it's a long and complex case. (If you do want to read a book, Conrad Black's own book on it is very good.) Perhaps start with some of Mark Steyn's writing for the Canadian news magazine Macleans? http://www.macleans.ca/columnists/article.jsp?content=20070730_107322_107322&id=7&page=1 http://www.macleans.ca/columnists/article.jsp?content=200707...