4 ms·
I think the idea is that it's very rare for the indigent to be plausibly charged with an exceedingly complicated crime which is expensive to defend against. Jo
by jessriedel 14y ago
I think the idea is that it's very rare for the indigent to be plausibly charged with an exceedingly complicated crime which is expensive to defend against. Joe-the-common-pickpocket is not at risk of being convicted of a massively technical financial fraud scheme. Public defenders are arguably sufficient to defend against what he might plausibly be charged with: burglary, assault, etc.
- fatbird 14y agoAny felony is expensive to defend against for the poor. If you're under the poverty line, $50k for a lawyer is just as out of reach as $5 million. And if death is involved, as it often is in the case of poverty crimes, then you're definitely talking an expensive trial where the defense is easily overwhelmed by the greater resources of the prosecution.
- checker 14y ago$50k for a laywer is out of reach for plenty of people above the poverty line.
- lilsunnybee 14y agoEven if they mortgage / sell their property, their vehicles. Use all family resources? You gotta do what you gotta do if you're facing felony charges.
- shardling 14y agoI like how your example leads by assuming that Joe is a criminal. Nice touch. In reality innocent people get charged with crimes that carry the death penalty, and suffer because they lack proper representation.
- jlgreco 14y agoIt doesn't matter if Joe did it or not. What matters is if Joe is charged and prosecuted for it.
- wpietri 14y agoDo you have any facts to back up the theory? It's not clear to me that a public defender's office is any less able to defend one case over the other. Public prosecutors allocate resources based on the case, and I'd presume that public defenders do the same.
- pekk 14y agoThe reason Joe the pickpocket isn't at risk of being convicted of a massively technical financial fraud scheme is that he isn't at risk of carrying one out.
- pdonis 14y agoJoe-the-common-pickpocket (or more likely, Joe-the-common-drug-user-caught-in-possession) is very likely to be offered a complicated plea bargain the implications of which are not clear to him and which are not well explained by his court-appointed public defender, and then pressured to accept it in order to save time by everyone involved, including his court-appointed public defender.