7 ms·
How to Gain or Lose 30 Minutes of Life Every Day
- boothead 14y agoAgain with the red meat?! Is there actually a real study that has established a causal relationship between eating meat and living shorter?
- Delenda 14y agoIt's also odd they they didn't seem to consider sugar intake. Unless perhaps I missed it....?
- mikle 14y agoI know at least of The China Study supporting the claim: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_China_Study_(book) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_China_Study_(book)
- debacle 14y agoThe China study has been debunked, on numerous occasions. My personal favorite: http://rawfoodsos.com/2010/07/07/the-china-study-fact-or-fallac/ http://rawfoodsos.com/2010/07/07/the-china-study-fact-or-fal...
- hachiya 14y agoYou may want to read this before trusting Denise Minger's response to the China study. http://www.plantpositive.com/blog/2012/3/21/a-reply-to-denise-mingers-latest-comments.html http://www.plantpositive.com/blog/2012/3/21/a-reply-to-denis...
- boothead 14y agoRead the criticisms and controversies section of the wikipedia article, it's a widely criticised study (perhaps not as much as Ancel Keys' study but close) Also see here for a very thorough refutation: http://rawfoodsos.com/2010/08/03/the-china-study-a-formal-analysis-and-response/ http://rawfoodsos.com/2010/08/03/the-china-study-a-formal-an...
- mikle 14y agoYou asked for a study. I gave you one. I guess that any study worth its time has criticisms and some that don't. Evolution is also criticized. I'm not comparing or equating them, just reminding you a criticism doesn't mean something is not right. Now I did read that wiki section and it is pretty short for such a "controversial" study. First let me just say that my opinion is that I don't think there is anyone on this earth who knows for sure exactly what red meat does to humans and whether it is good or bad. I choose to believe the study for now. Now I can start rationalizing why, and reputing Denise's reputings. Unfortunately I don't have time for this. I wish I could spend all my time talking about red meat (I don't) but I can't. As a side note/joke - Denise is 25. I'm 25. I don't recommend anyone take any health advice from 25 year olds :)
- hachiya 14y agoThe truth about Ancel Keys can be seen in the following video. Primitive Nutrition 36: The Infamous Ancel Keys? Part I http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NDwjkv1FW5g http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NDwjkv1FW5g Also, Denise Minger's "refutation" is hardly to be trusted. She even plagiarized this man's work on Ancel Keys. http://www.plantpositive.com/blog/2012/3/21/a-reply-to-denise-mingers-latest-comments.html http://www.plantpositive.com/blog/2012/3/21/a-reply-to-denis...
- Zimahl 14y agoI'm not a big fan of the overweight argument either. If I can find it, I read an article just the other day[1] that said there was no expectation of untimely death from being in a BMI that is considered 'overweight'. So there is no lost time there. And a couple drinks a night isn't going to cost you any time either. [1] http://www.latimes.com/news/science/la-sci-overweight-survival-20130102,0,7418358.story http://www.latimes.com/news/science/la-sci-overweight-surviv...
- sliverstorm 14y agoIn regards to drinks, it's probably indirect. E.g., the sort of person who has several drinks every night is probably the sort of person to have alcohol abuse issues at some point in their life. Alternatively, the data was averaged, and you are seeing the negative impact of binge drinking on weekends.
- dredmorbius 14y agoBMI is an absolute crap metric. It's vaguely useful for populations (and even there serious objections have been raised). It's utterly inappropriate for individuals, particularly when ready alternatives exist (waist size, for example, is a more robust predictor, despite its own vagaries). For individuals, BMI suffers in that it generally understates obesity in unfit, but "BMI-compliant" individuals, while overstating obesity in fit, BMI-noncompliant individuals. Which means that interventions are not indicated for those who would benefit and are indicated for those who would not. Generally, there's also the issue that there are large natural variations in healthy human weights, and no single target or designator will be appropriate for all. Fitness is multidimensional, and any attempt to reduce it to a single metric will likely fail. My lay recollection is that slightly higher-than-prescribed BMI is positively associated with greater life expectancy. Rationales vary, but among them, sick or ill individuals typically have lower-than-average bodyweights (skewing life expectancy down for low BMI scores), and athletes typically have elevated BMIs. Studies of Scandinavian Olympic athletes shows a pronounced lifetime mortality benefit to having competed in games (which tends to balance out the notoriously poor life expectancies of US professional athletes, particularly football, many associated with cumulative injuries sustained).
- ReadEvalPost 14y agoRed meat is definitely correlated with shorter lifespans, see e.g. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2803089/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2803089/. Causes appear to include increased risk of certain types of cancer and cardiovascular disease. The causal links are obviously much harder to tease out, but the correlation between eating red meat and a shorter lifespan is strong enough that it shouldn't be a controversial statement.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- jonstjohn 14y agoI used to be vegetarian and am eating modified paleo which means red meat and eggs (among other things, including lots of veggies, very little sugar and alcohol, fish, etc). Long-term health consequences worry me a bit but it seems like there is so much that we really don't understand about diet.
- skylan_q 14y agoIt's hard to defeat dogma. Those who aren't willing to suspend disbelief and take on a reasonably skeptical mindset on these matters will get what they deserve. Believe the stuff is good? Believe it's bad? Either way, best of luck to ya. ;)
- dredmorbius 14y agoI would like to see a study that controls for meat production methods, particularly prophylactic antibiotic and hormone treated CAFO raised beef and pork, vs. grass-fed / free range animals raised without antibiotics and hormones, under organic certification. One set of studies specifically noted precursors of colon cancer conditions immediately following ingestion of red meat, with seems like a bad thing. That said, I'm cautious but not convinced by these studies. I eat beef, though not daily.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- csmeder 14y agoI have a hard time believing I could start smoking 1 cigarette per an hour if I stood at my desk instead of sat, and the bad (smoking) would be balanced out with the good (standing)? Is sitting really that bad? Or is smoking really not that bad?
- Someone 14y agoOn the one hand, isn't that bad. People have survived 50+ years of smoking multiple cigarettes a day (some of them will have smoked 200,000+ cigarettes) On the other hand, smoking not only shortens your life, it also makes (part of it) less enjoyable. Statistically, smokers are ill more often and get chronic health problems earlier. Also, I bet the 'sitting is bad' meme will see some nuance added to it in due time. Even ignoring that, this message talks of sitting for two hours, without break. That, IMO, is very rare. Lunch, coffee, toilet breaks?
- clauretano 14y agoI found myself sometimes sitting for 4 hours without realizing it. When you get sucked into what you're working on, don't have meetings in the morning, and are sitting on an Aeron like any proper tech worker, it's not so hard to imagine. Here's a tip: keep yourself very well hydrated. My goal is always 1L water before lunch, 1L after. No software tricks needed!
- Dirlewanger 14y agoSitting for the prolonged periods of time that's expected in today's desk jobs with no intermittent stretching/getting up for a few minutes every hour or so is what's most dangerous.
- RyanMcGreal 14y agoSitting really is that bad. I have a script on my work computer that runs once every hour, reminding me to get up and making suggestions on things I can do: make some tea, do some situps, do some pushups, do some leg lifts, go up and down the stairs, take a walk around the block, and so on. I lack self-discipline but am very obedient, so it has been extremely successful for me.
- casca 14y agoThis is might be a helpful way to get people to care about making small, incremental improvements but the scientific basis is suspect. There is no evidence that 20 minutes of exercise adds an hour to your life. Taking the aggregate information around years and dividing it into days is not a meaningful operation and I'm sure that Spiegelhalter knows that as he says that this method of displaying the data "seems to resonate with people". As an aside, I've heard Dr Spiegelhalter regularly contributing to More or Less[1] and he seems to be a well informed scientist. [1] http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b006qshd http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b006qshd
- ProblemFactory 14y agoHaving seen some of Dr Spiegelhalter's talks in person, he most certainly knows that the units are not based on a meaningful operation. He is extremely passionate about explaining uncertainty and risk to ordinary people. As an example, plenty of people think that "you either get cancer or not, so it's 50-50, and might as well leave it to chance". In other cases, politicians ask scientists for the "worst possible outcome" of an event, and then react as if it was a certainty or at least 10% probability, while in reality the risk might be extremely small. Most people have trouble with the very concept of uncertainty. Microlives, and their opposite, micromorts (1-in-1M chance of dying while doing something) are helpful in comparing improbable-but-terrible events in terms of certain-but-insignificant, easier to understand concepts.
- thyrsus 14y agoI'll assume these figures apply to only established daily patterns. I find exercising lonely, painful, boring, and stupidity inducing - although I completely believe others obtain opposite results. If I had a choice for myself between exercising for 20 minutes, then dying, or dying immediately, I'd choose the latter. The non-exercising part of my life is spent pleasantly or sleeping, so I see a net gain of 27 minutes ((60 minutes life extension - 20 minutes exercising) * 2/3(awake factor)) for the first 20 minutes/day of exercising, but a net 7 minute loss for the next 40 minutes ((30 minutes life extension - 40 minutes exercising) * 2/3(awake factor)). Am I using these numbers correctly?
- 14y ago
- notsosmart 14y agoSpiegelhalter's TED talk about this subject is quite good. http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=4LSbnEgvmG8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_embedded&v=4...
- wheelerwj 14y agoIts the comments that are the best part of that article. Wow.
- ricardobeat 14y agoScientific American's website is riddled with ads. Can AdBlock get rid of those full-page intermissions? I might finally install it.
- tolos 14y agoYes, except for the tweet/+1/reddit/others floating bar.
- sliverstorm 14y agoNoScript will take care of that, but it is a pretty big hammer.
- ZoFreX 14y agoAdblock can do them too! You can either add them manually or subscribe to a filter that has them all already - I use "Fanboy's Annoyance List".
- dredmorbius 14y agoRIP (Remove it Permanently) typically nukes those just fine, though you may have to re-nuke it as the page is redesigned and xpaths change.
- lostlogin 14y agoPrior to reading the article I thought it was going to be about the way smokers get an hourly break of 5 mins at work while non-smokers don't. That's always an interesting subject.
- clauretano 14y agoWould your employer prevent you from going outside for 5 minutes every hour? That actually sounds like a great idea. Once an hour, head down to the street and walk a couple blocks.
- lostlogin 14y agoI'm sure they wouldn't mind - the timing would obviously be dependent upon business but that isn't a consideration for the smokers I work with, they just leave their colleagues to take up the slack.
- kscaldef 14y agoI run AntiRSI and take a 5 minute break every hour. Never had an employer complain about me not staying chained to my desk for 8 hours.
- mwsherman 14y agoKeep in mind that life expectancy is a statistical notion. Something specific is going to kill you. You won’t die or live 30 minutes longer or shorter as a result of a cigarette or a meal many years in the past. Rather, these behaviors are correlated with outcomes, and average to 20 or 30 minutes or whatever. This sort of daily accounting is misleading. Similarly, the notion that we are living longer largely has to do with less infant mortality. Specific people are not dying at birth that otherwise would have, pushing up the expectancy. Someone else’s not-dying-at-birth hasn’t made you healthier. Now, is the “20 minutes a day” thing a noble lie, to encourage good behavior? Perhaps. But that should be put to scientific scrutiny too: to what degree have people changed their behavior due to these notions, and what’s the outcome? Can I add two years to my life by regularly reading pop-sci recommendations?
- pc86 14y agoOne would think quite the opposite, since presumably you'd be sitting at a desk while reading them.
- mwsherman 14y agoGots me a standing desk. :)
- danielweber 14y agoExercising for 20 minutes a day to add 60 minutes to my life sounds like a good plan. I wonder if other things are reproducible. Is the "1 alcoholic drink" thing been replicated when correcting for income? Lots of rich people may have 1 drink a day, and so this pushes up the average of the "1 drink a day people", but it doesn't mean you can replicate it.
- aes256 14y agoI've always hypothesised alcohol consumption is largely independent of income. At both ends of the wealth spectrum you find people drinking far more alcohol than is healthy, just in different forms.
- arctangent 14y agoThese articles always seem to ignore quality of life - they assume that more life is necessarily a better thing. I'm sure I'm not alone in thinking that an extra ten years of life isn't much to look forward to if your mental and physical faculties are degraded to the point that you're a shadow of your former self. Better to burn out than fade away...?
- sliverstorm 14y agoWhy are you concerned? Things we have always known are healthy- vegetables, moderate activity levels, etc- tend to improve your quality of life too. It isn't like all humans, upon hitting 80, automatically have low quality of life. My grandparents are not as spry as me, but they are always cheerful and probably get out more than I do.
- kscaldef 14y agoYou're assumption is that you get a fixed amount of functional life, followed by a variable amount of less- or non-functional life. OTOH, you might get a variable amount of functional life, followed by a more-or-less fixed amount of non-functional life. In general, I think the second option more closely matches how we understand aging and disease. (Also, watch the TED talk by the referenced professor. He doesn't ignore quality of life.)
- drucken 14y agoSilly system. Takes very broad and multivariable dependent statistics and tries to parse them down to micro lifestyle criteria. Red meat is a perfect example. There are no convincing studies that demonstrate that it as an independent factor reduces life expectancy. If anything, quite the opposite is true, based on previous generations or the health of populations where red meat is very heavily consumed but suffer few other adverse major health factors.
- mmanfrin 14y agoTakes very broad and multivariable dependent statistics and tries to parse them down to micro lifestyle criteria. That's the point.