3 ms·
"if you chose to be born twenty thousand years ago, there's a good chance you would be born in a tribe with a reasonably stable social and cultural structure th
by raverbashing 14y ago
"if you chose to be born twenty thousand years ago, there's a good chance you would be born in a tribe with a reasonably stable social and cultural structure that rarely lacked for any major needs"
If you survived your first year of life, then your first 5 years of life, etc
Then you would have to hunt or do dangerous stuff with precarious tools, no health care in case of accident, etc
Oh and you would probably die by your 30s.
Makes the chinese factory kind of look good.
- netcan 14y agoprobably die by your 30s Average life expectancy at birth is heavily influenced by infant mortality. Most people didn't really die in their 30s.
- raverbashing 14y agoYes, or as some people say "if you survived past 5 years old your expectancy is higher" Not sure about the actual figures for that time period, though.
- Shorel 14y agoAbout half died at 1 year. The other half died at 60 years. A few died in between because of wars or whatever. Average: 30 years. I oversimplified a bit, but you can see the overview of the statistics misinterpretation.
- rndmize 14y agoThat you would speak of doing dangerous stuff with tools and a lack of healthcare and follow that with a mention of the Chinese factory... I find ironic. Further, while infant mortality was a problem (and has continued to be up until the last hundred years), you would probably not die by your thirties (life expectancy calculations are throw off precisely by infant mortality rates - the life expectancy for a person in almost any society goes up to at least 50 if you discount deaths of those under a year of age or so.) Is there something wrong with hunting, or difficult about it? I'm fairly sure we were good enough to wipe out a few species before the rise of agriculture. As for "dangerous stuff with precarious tools"... by all means, enlighten me. I'm having a hard time thinking of anything more dangerous than a sharp edge in any non-technologically advanced society. The number of dangers we have today from our tools (heard about a car crash on the radio recently?) and the lethality of them (how many people die from gun accidents? from mixing bleach and ammonia? electrocution? power tools? industrial machinery?) Do I even need to cover healthcare? Or how the vast majority of the world doesn't have it? Or how the majority of medications we develop don't demonstrate a greater effect than a placebo?
- raverbashing 14y agoYou are really comparing apples with oranges. Here's something you should do: go visit a farm. " Or how the vast majority of the world doesn't have it? " You are very removed from reality. The majority of people, even in very poor countries have access to aspirin, antibiotics. As tragic and cruel and "modern", kids that lost limbs to landmines are, they would have died without 20th century medical care, and they are alive today.
- rndmize 14y agoAspirin has been known since antiquity. Health care generally refers to reasonably complete care with practicing physicians, not a few varieties of antibiotics and painkillers. I don't see your point about visiting a farm, or your point about landmines; there's no lack of people around the world that die from things as simple as lack of drinking water and malnutrition, which I would consider the absolute minimum any kind of health care could provide.
- intended 14y agoNature HATES you. It is beautiful, magnificent and utterly capricious - inured to cries of mercy, fairness or justice. If you have ever been camping or in a forest or walked through shrubland this fact will be made abundantly clear to you. Immobile things like plants have edged leaves, burrs and seeds to sink deep into furs, thorns to prevent casual damage, let alone poisons and allergens. Forget mention of the thousands of insects and their colonies. The environment is inimical to today's civilized primates we call man. Hunting IS difficult, as is building tools without things like muscle force multipliers. Sharp edges? Want to beat stones together to get edges? Or do you want to move up to the Iron age? Now you have the option of living long enough to die of dysentery. What you further ignore is that even accrued tribal knowledge is slowly lost if populations don't achieve a certain concentration. Imagine rediscovering the "art" of smithing, only to lose it by the third generation. Whats dangerous in that society isn't the sharp edges, its the lack of anything else. Sick? Can't hunt? Good luck. Artery sliced open? Sepsis? Need antibiotics? Lets hope the witch doctor has good juju.
- michaelgrafl 14y agoWow. Really? Wow. No. It doesn't make the Chinese factory look good. [edit: removed because it sounded too mean to me] I suggest watching some documentaries about Asian nomads or other indigenous peoples. They live a primitive life, sure. But they seem pretty content and stress free. I'm not even sure if I prefer my own pampered life to theirs. I'd rather kill myself than work in a Chinese factory. From what I hear on the news, I'm not the only one who thinks that way.
- raverbashing 14y ago"I suggest watching some documentaries..." And you heard about the Chinese factories on the same documentaries right? But the Chinese workers have a choice, most of them came from the Chinese countryside willingly. Now, why did they choose that instead of having a simple, stress free life in the Chinese countryside? It's probably "easier" than being an Asian nomad, and some may have that exact background.
- gbog 14y agore Chinese factory: you must be aware that millions of people migrate to coastal cities in China in order to work in these factories, have some heating in winter, buy a phone and avoid being farmer? Do you think they all stupid? You must be aware that half of the world (Vietnam, Brazil, India, ...) is trying very hard to get a little piece of the "Chinese factories" cake?