6 ms·
Nor would you confuse "App Store" if it was on Apple or if it was on Amazon. It's short for Application Store, which it always has been - whether Apple would ad
by loceng 14y ago
Nor would you confuse "App Store" if it was on Apple or if it was on Amazon. It's short for Application Store, which it always has been - whether Apple would admit that or not.
I don't think "Candy Store" was ever copyrightable ...
- jfoster 14y agoYou're right, but just want to point out that it is typically trademarks that apply to names, not copyright.
- 6ren 14y agoWhen I first heard about java applets many years ago, I had an irresistible intuition that they were somehow related to Apple.
- biot 14y agoThat's a rather poor argument as you present no reason justifying when a shortened name cannot be protected by trademark law. What about these Fortune 500 companies? Tech Data (short for technical data) Computer Sciences Waste Management Genuine Parts Health Net (short for health network) Applied Materials Whole Foods ... and so on? Those are all pretty generic names. Some are short for something else; others are self-descriptive. Which of those should not exist as a trademark and why?
- precisioncoder 14y agoAll of them. If you start protecting words in the English language it requires us to expand the language thus diminishing it's usefulness in future. Personally I would say any word that is in a dictionary should not be possible for a trademarked name. Words that are added after the company for instance Skyping as a term for making a VOIP call or Kleenex as a term for tissue should be allowed to keep the name but as soon as it is entered in the dictionary all other companies should be forbidden to use it.
- drcube 14y agoWhat about phrases?
- precisioncoder 14y agoIf they contain English words I would say no. Otherwise we get into the same argument about similar phrases etc.
- bdcravens 14y agoI wonder if the discussion changes if we use the same argument against HN-beloved companies, like Buffer or Stripe. A company named Stripe Processing that processes credit cards would be safe, as I'm referring to the "stripe" on every credit card, not a specific company.
- micampe 14y agoWhich dictionary? Who defines it? Who decides when Kleenex or App are to be included? Are words ever removed from that dictionary? What about foreign language dictionaries? What about foreign words transliterations to a different alphabet? What about made-up words that sound like an existing word with different spelling? Acronyms?
- colanderman 14y agoThese questions are are pretty well answered by trademark law. Most of it boils down to a judge's decision, who, by the way, can decide that a hereforeto novel term has become generic (much as Xerox, Kleenex, and Photoshop are in danger of becoming), hence why you see ridiculous efforts by companies with household names to prevent verbification of their names.
- micampe 14y agoI know, I was challenging the idea that it should not be allowed to trademark words in “the dictionary”. It’s a judge decision, there is no formal list of disallowed words, and my point is that there can’t be one, in the real world.
- colanderman 14y agoIIRC, the test for non-trademarkability is not whether it's "generic" but whether it's descriptive. "App Store" perfectly describes what it labels -- it's a store where you can buy apps. "Whole Foods" on the other hand does not describe what it labels -- it's not a set of foods which are whole, it is a store which sells such things. The name "Whole Foods Store" on the other hand, would be non-trademarkable.