5 ms·
A random note for those who might be inclined to think that gerrymandering does not have a significant political impact. In the 2012 elections, Republicans car
by btilly 14y ago
A random note for those who might be inclined to think that gerrymandering does not have a significant political impact. In the 2012 elections, Republicans carried Congress by 233 to 200 seats. Yet across all Congressional elections they lost the popular vote by about 1.35 million. (http://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/14315/did-the-democrats-win-the-popular-vote-in-the-2012-us-congressional-elections http://skeptics.stackexchange.com/questions/14315/did-the-de... is where I ran across this.)
The cause of the discrepancy is largely gerrymandering.
Unfortunately lots of states have laws about trying to draw boundaries that put ethnic groups together, etc in non-trivial ways. There are algorithms that can produce maps satisfying those restrictions, but they are more complicated. And, for obvious reasons, they often have the goal is producing such maps with a definite electoral bias...
- danso 14y agoSo is the 1.35 million number just the absolute difference between all votes cast nationally? Doesn't there have to be so e adjustment for districts in which many D voters elected an easy winner but in which excess votes don't really do much since it is an easy win? And of course, there's other explanations besides gerrymandering...it could be that the RNC and its financial allies spent more savvily in tight races and pulled through. The problem of money is of course its own discussion
- chimeracoder 14y ago> And of course, there's other explanations besides gerrymandering...it could be that the RNC and its financial allies spent more savvily in tight races and pulled through. Yes, this issue is incredibly complicated to analyze - for example, in the House, contentious bills like the ACA are oftentimes passed with ~220 votes (usually ~217 defines a majority). That doesn't mean that only 220 people would have been been willing to support the bill; just that the winning party didn't need to waste any resources whipping another ten votes in excess of what was needed to secure a victory. Just looking at the final vote tally is misleading, because if the threshold for passage were higher, it's very likely that the actual vote tallies would miraculously adjust accordingly.
- JoshTriplett 14y ago> That doesn't mean that only 220 people would have been been willing to support the bill; just that the winning party didn't need to waste any resources whipping another ten votes in excess of what was needed to secure a victory. If they had votes to spare, they'd make the bill worse and lose those votes. Contentious bills have close vote totals because they do as much damage as possible while still passing.
- gizmo686 14y agoOnly if their goal is to pass as the worst bill they possible could.
- btilly 14y agoContentious bills have close vote totals because they do as much damage as possible while still passing. I think it often works the other way in practice. To secure votes on contentious bills they have to slip in riders (ie pork) to secure specific votes. Therefore the fact that it is contentious means that they have to make it worse.
- seabee 14y agoThe corollary (and parent's point) is that securing excess votes will worsen your bill with no benefit to you, so you avoid this.
- chimeracoder 14y agoThis would only be the case if policy were linear, which it isn't. ACA is a good example of this. I forget what the exact count when it passed in the House in March 2010 was, but Pelosi had several "backup" votes to spare. Kucinich, for example, voted against the bill in protest, but if they had known that the bill had less support, she could have counted on his vote towards passage. Whipping votes takes resources - you don't want to use up any more favors than you have to, because that means one less favor you can call on for the next bill. It's better to call in exactly as many favors as you need to guarantee passage, and then let the rest slide so you can maintain leverage against them next time.
- btilly 14y agoThe 1.35 million is just the absolute difference between all votes cast nationally. The result of all of the adjustments you could try to make, taken to the limit, is the 233/200 margin of Republican control of Congress. Incidentally I credit the win in the popular vote for Democrats to a very good get out the vote operation for Obama. I am sure that future incarnations will specifically target every marginal Congress seat as well.
- waterlesscloud 14y agoYou had districts in California that were Democrat vs Democrat, meaning Republicans couldn't pick up any popular votes in those districts. That alone makes for a mighty skew in the popular vote totals.
- btilly 14y agoNot as big as you might think. Looking nation wide for districts that only voted Democrat or only voted Republican, I saw 1041261 Democratic votes and 775970 Republican ones. (I could have missed a district.) If you eliminate those from the tally, we're still around a million excess Democratic votes. And those districts are all going to be very safe for their party, so even if they did have the opposite party as an option, it is likely that most of the votes would have been for the party that won that district. So that source of skew does not explain much of the difference.
- thethimble 14y agoInteresting question: Isn't having laws that prohibit putting ethnic groups together in an algorithmically generated way discrimination in itself? For example, if the algorithm generates a predominantly black district (that's algorithmically generated and thus unbiased), breaking it up because it is predominantly black is an act of discrimination.
- btilly 14y agoIsn't having laws that prohibit putting ethnic groups together in an algorithmically generated way discrimination in itself? Sorry I was unclear, it was the other way around. If you can, you have to keep ethnic groups together. So, for instance, if you can put all of Chinatown together, you have to. The political effect is kind of complicated. On the one hand it gives members of those ethnic groups a chance to win office. On the other hand it creates very safe districts. Given the way the math works, creating very safe districts for your side leads to improving the odds that the other side will win more seats than their share of the popular vote. Activists are very focused on the first effect and tend to ignore the second. Furthermore politicians encourage this because they like safe seats. But the math is inescapable - an effective electoral gerrymander is created by creating a modest number of ultra-safe seats for the other side, and many more safe but less extreme seats for your side. So all black seats that guarantee black representation in Congress leads to seats that vote 80%+ for the Democrat which in turn leads to Republicans electing more than their share of the popular vote.
- alexqgb 14y agoThat's exactly correct. A successful gerrymander is a product of packing AND cracking. A mathematically perfect gerrymander, which optimizes both, will allow a party to hold a state with a mere 26% of the vote. I don't know know how close any state has gotten to this theoretical limit, but the fact that the practice can skew results this dramatically only underscores how toxic it really is. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerrymandering#Packing_and_cracking http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gerrymandering#Packing_and_crac... As an aside, gerrymandering has been a personal point of obsession for at least five years now. I've got a long-running familiarity with the Wikipedia entry, and am just thrilled by how clear and comprehensive it's become within the last year. The issue may not have gone mainstream yet, but it's starting snowball, with the lopsided results from the last election accelerating progress dramatically. When gerrymandering in the House is considered in tandem with Senate filibuster rules that effectively require a supermajority to do anything, the issue of a sharply unrepresentative Congress comes into crisp focus. Put simply, our system of Government was never designed to work under minority rule. Indeed, the whole thing is predicated on straight majority rule in both the House and Senate. I'd love to see a popular campaign that restores majority rule to both chambers by refusing to elect or re-elect any representative who won't support a restoration of this basic condition, and pronto.
- kbutler 14y ago> The cause of the discrepancy is largely gerrymandering. Proof needed. The discrepancy simply means that democratic candidates won by wider margins than republican candidates, which can easily happen without gerrymandering.