4 ms·
That is exactly what the drug companies say. That's funny at is as if you are just reciting back their propaganda. It turns out a lot more money is spent on ma
by rdtsc 14y ago
That is exactly what the drug companies say. That's funny at is as if you are just reciting back their propaganda.
It turns out a lot more money is spent on marketing and lobbying that is spent on research. Also a lot of cutting edge research is actually performed by public universities by professors on that state's (or NIH's) dime.
> Patents are good/needed to promote the quality of medicine. There they're good.
Well that really is the crux of the argument. I would argue that patents make the medicine worse. Medicine I also consider to be the health and well-being of citizens not profitability of drug companies. I can be convinced that the current patent system help the profitability of drug companies I am not sure if it help the sick people.
- dhimes 14y agoThat is exactly what the drug companies say Yeah, there's a reason for that. It turns out a lot more money is spent on marketing and lobbying that is spent on research. Don't confuse pharmaceutical companies with biotech companies. Also a lot of cutting edge research is actually performed by public universities by professors on that state's (or NIH's) dime. Often, the same researcher then spins out the company that tries to commercialize the research. I can be convinced that the current patent system help the profitability of drug companies I am not sure if it help the sick people. Without them you wouldn't have the medicine. Then that won't help the sick people. As it stands, there is a difference between the medicine that rich people can afford and that poor people can afford. That may be morally objectionable- and maybe we should fix it. But at least the medicine exists, and eventually it gets cheaper on average for everybody. I am very much for patent reform, but we have to do it intelligently. Where patents help- keep them. Modify them maybe. Where they are despicable destroy them. At least in some cases in medicine-- as in other high barrier-to-entry endeavors-- I am convinced they are useful. In other cases they are infuriating.
- linuxhansl 14y agoWithout them you wouldn't have the medicine. How do you prove that? I disagree. Here my statement: Without patents you would have cheaper medicine (but I cannot prove that either)
- dhimes 14y agoNot only would you not have the medicine, but you wouldn't have delivery vehicles (devices, forms) either. It's because USA and Europe require such substantial testing, at various stages, to prove (1) efficacy, and (2) safety. These are not binary-outcome experiments. They are expensive (gotta pay people to take your dope and you gotta pay - and train - docs to keep an eye on them. Remember- the outcomes are not binary). Some percentage of your population aren't going to feel well while in the trial. Is is the fault of your medicine? You better be absolutely sure. Oh wait, you can't. Can you find anybody who might be able to help you decide? So before VCs will give you $5M, they are going to be sure that Walmart can't knock off a copy once you have the proof. That's where the money goes, and why you won't get any unless you can arrange some exclusive sales. And, like everything else, you have to make sure that there is a paying market (meaning docs will use it and insurers will pay for it).
- belorn 14y ago>Often, the same researcher then spins out the company that tries to commercialize the research. It seems to me that you imply that there is some added value from the commercialization. But commercialization does not cause added value in itself. Sometimes, commercialization just mean marketing and profit center. However the real question is, what does commercialization of an already founded and paid invention has to do with patents. Why should research which is paid with tax money (through NIH) be patentable, and how does that benefit society?
- dhimes 14y agoThere is often substantial risk turning a research result (molecule X inhibits virus Y) into a safe medicine. You have to do significant, expensive testing. That is where the money is spent because that is where commercialization fails.
- sageikosa 14y agoAlso, pharmaceutical drugs don't just pop out of Wonka-like machines in a manner similar to the Everlasting Gobstopper. The production process has to be efficient. Efficiency is a function of the cost to research, design, construct and operate the production facilities and QA, and the expected returns.
- belorn 14y agoWell, if you want efficiency, thats were all the factories with generics lives. They use capitalism, that is competition to produce the best product for the lowest price. As for testing (the above comment), thats where FDA approved monopolies comes in. FDA want to incentivize testing and producing of products, even once they fall out of patent protection, so FDA themselves gives out limited timed monopolies after a drug gone through all the testing. Thats a monopoly on top of regular patents for most drugs. FDA don't assume patents to cover the cost beyond the initial research. They consider that more incentives are needed, targeted for testing and producing of products.
- 14y ago
- DougBTX 14y agoand eventually it gets cheaper on average for everybody. Sometimes cheap drugs get more expensive, so that's at least not a universal truth. http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/30/business/questcor-finds-profit-for-acthar-drug-at-28000-a-vial.html?pagewanted=all&_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2012/12/30/business/questcor-finds-pr...
- Daniel_Newby 14y ago> It turns out a lot more money is spent on marketing ... The cost structure of marketing has diminishing returns with a very long tail. The first $100M might give $1B in revenue, the next $100M might give $400M, then $100M/$150M, then $100M/$105M, then $100M/$101M, and so forth. The last $100M of the markeing budget only has a miniscule percentage profit, but a miniscule percentage is $1M. So it gets spent. So marketing budgets appear to be gigantic, but is is because most of the customers are marginal and barely need the product, not because R&D is being short-changed. In fact, this approach maximizes absolute R&D funding. Yes, R&D becomes a smaller slice of the pie, but this only matters to people who cannot do math.
- DomreiRoam 14y agoI think you explain why it is smart to spend money on marketing. But really for medical use, I find that marketing can be dangerous. I mean creating a need for a drug? really?
- suchire 14y agoMarketing + lobbying expenses are not mutually exclusive with research expenses. Companies maximize revenue, and to do that you need both marketing and research expenses. As it happens, throwing more money at research doesn't work (see Pfizer), and throwing more money at market often does.
- AUmrysh 14y agoMost of the money is spent on passing FDA approval and testing. Research is a small portion of the cost, you are correct there. The real problem with patents is that they don't protect the idea, they put it in public and try to give a monopoly to a certain person or 'legal person'(corporation). The medical patents are designed to encourage disclosure so that the medicine can become widely available later. That is the real reason medical patents are beneficial to society. It's a deal that has to be made where both sides give a little and both sides gain a little. I know we haven't seen a lot of this in America lately, but it's compromise. If you really want to keep something a secret, you don't patent it. I think the law should allow non-profits and things like universities and hospitals to violate patents and copyright for the public good. That would get rid of the "they aren't helping sick people" problem and still keep the profits for the drug companies.