8 ms·
The TSA wants to be everywhere in 2013 - here's why we shouldn't let it
- nazgulnarsil 14y agoNewly created government institution uses resources to secure expansion of power, reach, number of employees, news at 11.
- nacker 14y agoMother, should I trust the government? http://www.theburningplatform.com/?p=45633 http://www.theburningplatform.com/?p=45633
- greenyoda 14y agoIt would seem that if a sporting event is held on private property (e.g., Madison Square Garden), the TSA would need to be invited by the property owners before it could operate there.
- kelnos 14y agoAren't many airports privately-owned as well?
- colbyaley 14y agoAfter an event I was at was targeted to be blown up, (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010_Portland_car_bomb_plot http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010_Portland_car_bomb_plot) I have changed my views on anti-terrorist teams at events and mass-gatherings. I do find it silly, however, that these teams are supposedly a devision of the "Transit Security Administration".
- ta234234 14y agotargeted to be blown up Mainly by the FBI, based on that wikipedia article. FBI: Hey, do you want to blow something up? Terrorist: OK FBI: Here's a bomb, go blow something up. Terrorist: OK [click] FBI: You're under arrest! Sure, the guy committed a crime, but was I wouldn't say the event was "targeted to be blown up". It was a sting operation. A small probability threat was amplified by the FBI for the purpose of making a case. Does that justify TSA goons everywhere? The same ones that won't let you bring your bottle of Coke on an airplane? Governments love to use "larger than life" enemies to justify a disproportionate invasion of liberty. It used to be Communists, now it's Terrorists.
- Aco- 14y agothis happens way more than people (care to?) notice
- anigbrowl 14y agoWhen you read the actual indictments and court transcripts in cases like this, the would-be terrorists turn out to be nothing like the passive actor you hypothesize here, but rather display a fair degree of initiative; they have typically come to the FBI's attention because people around them are alarmed by their aspirations and report them to law enforcement. There are tough legal questions about where the borderline between facilitation and encouragement lies. But someone who willingly goes through the steps required t detonate what they believe to be a fully armed truck bomb is not a mere innocent victim. The correct answer to 'Hey, do you want to blow something up?' is 'No, because that would be crazy and horrible.'
- smutticus 14y agoGoogle for 'operation flex' if you want to see how the FBI uses your tax dollars to fight terrorism.
- anigbrowl 14y agoI think that's a faulty generalization. Since I read criminal indictments for fun I'm quite familiar with the FBI's methods. Please don't take this to mean I think they're always ethical, legal, or effective.
- ta234234 14y agoI didn't say the man was innocent. What I said was that the event the parent poster referred to was not really targeted by terrorists, but rather by an FBI sting operation. This means that the event was never in any real danger, and using it to justify expanding TSA security theater is not valid.
- mikeash 14y agoYou shouldn't change your assessment of the risks just because you almost got unlucky. It's like suddenly deciding that lottery tickets are a good investment just because you know someone who won.
- killermonkeys 14y agoWithout belittling the realization of ones own mortality which is a very healthy thing, the question here isn't whether a police state "makes us safer" (it probably does) but what level of trade off between civil liberties and privacy we are willing to make to be safer. Since being safer is infinitely possible and impossible to measure, we should start and end the conversation with civil liberty, not with safety. Do you want the government to try to perform stings on would-be terrorists, potentially entrapping otherwise innocent people? I'm ok with that. Do you want a government agency to have sweeping search and detention rights with cause or warrant? I do not. As others have noted, anecdotal evidence is the enemy of reason when cases of actual terrorist attack are so infrequent versus the frequent antiterrorist measures taken "at" you.
- mikeash 14y agoPolice states are notoriously unsafe. While they may keep you safe from independent criminals, your risk of being victimized by the government itself goes way up.
- gosub 14y agoA fool and his liberties are soon parted?
- GFischer 14y agoEven if your premise is valid, do you believe the people at U.S. airports are "anti-terrorist teams"? Dozens of articles refute the usefulness of the TSA, some referring to real anti-terrorist teams like Israeli ones (see some below, I can't find the best one). http://www.nypost.com/p/news/opinion/opedcolumnists/forget_the_porn_machines_NQAJ5DOzf187gdRQnLURlO http://www.nypost.com/p/news/opinion/opedcolumnists/forget_t... http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2012/03/on-political-correctness-at-ben-gurion-airport/254600/ http://www.theatlantic.com/international/archive/2012/03/on-... Even if, like yourself, you want real security, you shouldn't like the TSA. I'm not an U.S. citizen nor do I live there, but from the outside (plus some experiences by relatives and being shoe-searched on American Airlines) it doesn't look good at all.
- slavak 14y agoInterestingly, the Israeli authorities were at one point reportedly considering installing back-scatter scanners at airports. For catching customs violations. Thankfully the plan seems to have been scrapped, as that instant years ago was the first and last time I heard anything about it.
- astrodust 14y agoThe FBI made sure nothing happened here, they seem to know what they're doing. They should be commended for keeping this situation well in hand. The TSA is not the same thing. Their security theater would've done nothing to prevent someone from driving up a truck bomb and setting it off.
- darkarmani 14y agoSo do you also never fly because it is "safer?"
- ck2 14y agoThe only way to stop them is to stop funding them and that requires both parties to agree. Good luck with that. Get used to the new TSA overlords. High school dropouts will now be groping you since it's the only job they will be able to get.
- pyre 14y agoBoth parties already agree. They agree that de-funding the TSA is political suicide. Especially if any sort of terrorist attack happens. Even if the public doesn't attempt to point fingers, political opponents will (during the next re-election campaign most likely).
- city41 14y agoThe broad and vague ruling that enables the TSA to do anything they want in airports[0] can (and will) be applied to just about any public event. It's probably just a matter of a few years or so before the TSA is searching us at virtually all public gatherings. And there isn't a damn thing we can do about it. [0] http://boardingarea.com/blogs/flyingwithfish/2010/11/20/how-the-tsa-legally-circumvents-the-fourth-amendment/ http://boardingarea.com/blogs/flyingwithfish/2010/11/20/how-...
- jmspring 14y agoA public that is passive and follows "the rules" enables this, unfortunately.
- gasull 14y agoIn 2011 and 2012 we had Occupy Wall Street and Anonymous. Probably the broadest protest movement online and offline in a long time, if not ever. And the politicians won. Wall Street won. The TSA won. They all have more power than 2 years ago. If the broadest peaceful protest couldn't make it, what possibly can?
- eru 14y agoPerhaps a more narrow and focussed protest can?
- cgag 14y agoViolent protest.
- sneak 14y agoYou really, really don't want to be resident there ifwhen it actually comes to that, brother. Consider emigrating. It's much better, safer, and more effective than violence.
- sneak 14y agoYou could not be more correct. I took this photo yesterday: http://i.imgur.com/ilLp1.jpg http://i.imgur.com/ilLp1.jpg
- ams6110 14y agoThat the TSA is expanding its scope should surprise nobody. It's what bureaucracies do. Also it wasn't named the ASA (Airport Security Administration) it was named something much less specific. Probably won't be long before they're patrolling interstate highways in stealth-black Dodge Chargers with officious logos on the sides.
- narag 14y agoI wonder what private contractors in Irak will do when their assignment there is over. IIRC there was many of them. Trained men with real OT experience, that used to be well-paid...
- n3rdy 14y agoEvery time I hear about the TSA trying to expand to other places such as this, I can't help but think they are like the Westboro Baptist Church of the government agencies.. and I believe that's really saying something. That's right TSA, congratulations on accomplishing the impossible and becoming more hated than the I.R.S. If you only would use your power for good and not evil.
- pyre 14y ago> and passengers may avoid the search by electing > not to fly Tell that to the people that were threatened with fines when they backed out of the screenings once they got to the front of the line and didn't want to be groped or subjected to backscatter x-rays... The idea being that once you entered the line for the security checkpoint, that you were not allowed to leave.
- gasull 14y agoI'm already thinking it's too late to prevent the US (and most of the Western World) from becoming an Orwellian dystopia. The US is already more corrupt than Singapore, a country with no democracy: http://www.transparency.org/cpi2012/results http://www.transparency.org/cpi2012/results So every year we have more corruption, less freedom, more taxes and more IP trolling. Can someone convince me that the pendulum is going to swing back?
- beedogs 14y agoNot without an overwhelming amount of capital (both human and financial) losses, I'm afraid.
- saraid216 14y agoI doubt it. American cynicism pretty much makes it impossible. If you can't bring hope to the table, you put a double burden on someone else. Not sure why you think Singapore is not a democracy, though.
- jmspring 14y agoCall me a pessimist, but the lemming nature to following the reactionary rules of the TSA makes me believe the person you responded to is correct.
- saraid216 14y agoWell, yeah. It's exactly the lemming nature that is unwilling to try for something better. You're following it; I'm following it. The difference between us isn't that one's a cynic and one's not. The difference is that I know how much of a complete failure I am for not pushing back hard enough. You guys are my justification for saying, "Stop trying. It's not worth it." So thanks. I've been thinking I'll try out the whole happiness thing for a bit this year. See how that goes.
- gasull 14y ago> Not sure why you think Singapore is not a democracy, though. It's a an "hybrid regime", "partly free": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singapore#Government_and_politics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Singapore#Government_and_polit... Maybe that's what the US is too already.
- smutticus 14y agoHow many people here are willing to get arrested? Because that's what it's going to take to reverse this trend. We need hundreds/thousands of non-violent protesters politely and professionally refusing these intrusions and getting arrested for it. Until that happens these intrusions will continue.
- sneak 14y agoNone, as the ionizing radiation and sexual assault at airports has clearly and unambiguously illustrated. Your notion of vast public dissent is a fantasy.
- smutticus 14y agoI hold no such fantasy. I'm simply pointing out that until mass non-violent protest and the accompanying mass arrests civil liberties will continue to degrade. I never said it was going to happen. I just said it's what needs to happen.
- polyfractal 14y agoI'm not condoning the TSA in any way (I also think it is a deplorable organization), but as a biologist I feel compelled to state that you receive vastly more ionizing radiation looking out the window of your plane than you do in the one of the TSA scanners. Again, not condoning the invasion of privacy for security theater, but the "threat" of ionizing radiation is almost always over-stated.
- epoxyhockey 14y agoHow about with this model scanner? http://www.mikrondigital.com/uploads/media/RadPRO_SECURPASS.pdf http://www.mikrondigital.com/uploads/media/RadPRO_SECURPASS.... High Penetration Model: (500/y/subject) < 2.0 uSv (0.2 mR) / per scan
- polyfractal 14y agoI feel a little silly linking an XKCD image, but it's accurate and relevant: http://xkcd.com/radiation/ http://xkcd.com/radiation/ An average human receives 10 uSv during an average day from background radiation, and 40 uSv on a cross-country flight. Living in Denver, CO for a year will expose you to 1800 uSv. Some more dosages for various routine living situations and medical procedures (note, they are in mSv, not uSv): http://users.rcn.com/jkimball.ma.ultranet/BiologyPages/R/Radiation.html http://users.rcn.com/jkimball.ma.ultranet/BiologyPages/R/Rad...
- WettowelReactor 14y agoA very small percentage of Americans ever enter an airport. If the TSA presence expands beyond that their tactics will be felt by a far greater percentage of voting americans. It may be that expanding beyond airports will be very detrimental to the TSA's longevity.