5 ms·
People Freak Out About Privacy On Facebook, But Ignore Government Surveillance
- kapnobatairza 14y agoI think the reason for this is quite simple: Facebook can only sell you on privacy changes by trying to convince you of a better service/more convenience. The U.S. Intelligence Community and Congress can sell you on surveillance by trying to convince you that such measures are essential in preventing American deaths. It isn't that people don't care the government is spying on us, it is that the government has a much more compelling argument to do so.
- bcoates 14y agoThis is hard for me to say as I'm pretty much the real world version of Dale Gribble, but being more worried about Facebook than the Government is a reasonable position. The upside of government surveillance is that the government gains power by keeping your secrets secret, and when it comes down to it, the vast majority of people are simply uninteresting to the spooks and both parties know it. The odds of being extra-judicially executed for being a YouTube troll are nonzero, but statistically close enough that it's not worth worrying about unless you meet a very narrow profile. Facebook, on the other hand, seems to have as a primary business model finding out everything about everyone, and then telling everyone else. It's this latter part that people worry about. They don't want their life broadcast to every potential employer, client, lender, local xenophobe, landlord, insurance company, lover, violent ex-lover, nosy neighbor, obsessive stalker etc. that they deal with in their life. The odds there are a lot more grim--You're about 1000 times more likely to be killed by your ex or soon to be ex than the President.
- nuclear_eclipse 14y agoOnly a 1000x difference?
- bcoates 14y agoIt's a back of the envelope estimate: the US has about a 10,000/year murder rate, about half of those are in the family. The targeted killings program doesn't exactly advertise but it's known to be well more than one so I'm guessing it's in the tens per year of people who could be described as westerners. YMMV.
- rayiner 14y agoWhere on earth do you get the idea that the drone strikes are killing a non-zero number of westerners?!
- Hello71 14y agoWhere on earth do you get the idea that he was talking about drone strikes?!
- rayiner 14y agoWhat other "targeted killing" program is there?
- olefoo 14y agoWell, the US government has said that it doesn't have to tell you that because it's a national security matter. However the existence of at least one government associated plan to kill US Citizens on US territory was surfaced in the media last week http://news.firedoglake.com/2012/12/31/fbi-report-mentions-plot-to-kill-occupy-protesters/ http://news.firedoglake.com/2012/12/31/fbi-report-mentions-p... And while I cannot provide evidence that there have been others; it is a fact that the US government has been training death squads at Fort Benning and elsewhere for more than 40 years (vide: Guatemala, Nicaragua, Paraguay and many other countries whose paramilitary/police were trained by the US and went on targeted campaigns of killing civilians); although most of the openly acknowledged trainees were not US citizens, but Police and Military from client governments, mostly in South and Central America. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Hemisphere_Institute_for_Security_Cooperation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Western_Hemisphere_Institute_fo... And given that Obama's Attorney General Eric Holder is on the record as saying """ “Due process” and “judicial process” are not one and the same, particularly when it comes to national security. """ It's not impossible that everyone who reads this thread is being assessed for their suitability to be judged a "threat to national security" and thus worth the cost of elimination.
- ams6110 14y agothe vast majority of people are simply uninteresting to the spooks Today.
- yafujifide 14y agoIf you don't like Facebook surveillance then you can opt out by not using it. But you can't opt out of government surveillance. You didn't address this important fact.
- codex 14y agoSome reasons: - The government is accountable to the people, but who is Facebook accountable to? Shareholders. - Government surveillance has at least some oversight, with a long history of regulation. - Allowing government spooks to note your alcoholism is less worrysome, to most, than having drunk pics appear on the public Internet, for mom+boss to see.
- ahallock 14y agoGovernment is accountable to "the people"? That's just a platitude. The government is beholden to many special interests. The bailouts, the wars--home & abroad--, the TSA, etc. are all egregious examples. Facebook is accountable to shareholders, true, but no one is holding you hostage, making you share information on Facebook. You could change your privacy settings, go to another social network(s), or stop sharing altogether.
- readme 14y agoThe kicker is that the government is using Facebook to surveil you.
- GHFigs 14y agoThis is a false dichotomy. Plenty of people ignore privacy issues on Facebook, and there are plenty of "silly and exaggerated stories" about government surveillance that get people freaking out.
- jiggy2011 14y agoFacebook has a profit motive and are answerable only to their own management and shareholders. If their board decided they could increase profit by x% by deleting all privacy controls tomorrow then all privacy controls could be removed tomorrow. In theory at least a democratic government has no particular interest in sharing your data with anybody apart from maybe a few intelligence and law enforcement officials who want to check that you're not actually trying to kill anyone. They also have to vote on any major legislation changes, enough unfavourable bills and they risk getting thrown out at the next election.
- ahallock 14y agoIf Facebook removed all privacy controls, people would leave the social network in droves, and FB would be forced change their policy. Consumers are fickle, and FB is not an unstoppable juggernaut; I'm not sure why people have this idea.
- saraid216 14y agoReally? http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4982462 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4982462 You're submitting the same story twice?
- cwkoss 14y agoFacebook IS Government Surveillance.
- zaidrahman 14y agoPrivacy is what is going to define this generation. However, no matter what you think, Government Surveillance is better than private surveillance. It's a democracy for crying out loud. But the preamble, is that the breach of privacy is bad in any use case scenario. Realistically however, surveillance is always going to exist. Either covertly or legally. Nothing much can be done.
- enoch_r 14y agoHowever, no matter what you think, Government Surveillance is better than private surveillance. It's a democracy for crying out loud. There are two types of power within a group: exit and voice. The power to change a community, and the power to leave it. I am not at all confident in the power of my voice to affect the policies of the US government on surveillance/privacy issues. In fact, although my voice has almost no impact on Facebook's policies on privacy, I'd say that I'm almost as likely to influence Facebook's privacy policies by complaining as to influence US Government policies by voting. Meanwhile, leaving the US is impractical or difficult, and even (especially!) non-US-citizens are subject to the US government's intrusions on privacy, surveillance, as well as the possibility of being killed or abducted without trial. Opting out of Facebook is relatively easy.
- paul 14y agoThis reminds me of the time that Facebook rounded up all of the Japanese-Americans and put them in internment camps.
- saraid216 14y agoMy internment camp is named the Seattle, Washington Area network. There is snow falling on the cedars here.