3 ms·
Yes, and one person can have multiple phone numbers. That was just an example of another data which can be used for identity which is far less ambiguous than th
by BerislavLopac 14y ago
Yes, and one person can have multiple phone numbers. That was just an example of another data which can be used for identity which is far less ambiguous than the proper name. The point with identities is that, if you need to be able to identify someone with a single piece of information, it can't be defined by the person being identified; instead it has to be appointed by a globally central authority, since it's the only way to ensure uniqueness. So in any case, names are completely irrelevant when it comes to identity.
- pdonis 14y agoif you need to be able to identify someone with a single piece of information, it can't be defined by the person being identified; instead it has to be appointed by a globally central authority Not necessarily; for example, people could generate their own UUIDs as identity tokens.
- BerislavLopac 14y agoThat's a fair point. However, identification is not only about uniqueness, it's also about proving that you are who you say you are, which still requires a central authority -- or maybe another un-fakeable certificate, although I'm not sure how it would be implemented without depending on another type of identity (such as email).
- pdonis 14y agoit's also about proving that you are who you say you are, which still requires a central authority I disagree with this too, because "who you say you are" is not a single thing; it depends on the context, and you ought to be able to control what connections people can make between different contexts. For example: I might want to give one ID to my doctor, to connect it with my medical records, and another to the DMV to identify me for a driver's license. There is no reason why these two IDs need to be the same: in other words, there is no reason why the DMV needs to verify that "who I say I am" to them is the same as "who I say I am" to my doctor. Or again, if I have to prove "who I say I am" to Social Security in order to receive benefits, that doesn't necessarily mean I have to use the same ID as I use for other purposes. Of course, some of the reasons I would need an ID are to prove that I have a certain set of rights, as in the Social Security and DMV examples, so whoever I give the ID to has to be able to connect that ID with the appropriate evidence that I have those rights. So my "Social Security ID" would have to be connected to my employment history, or at least to my history of paying into the system, and my "DMV ID" would have to be connected to my passing of a driver's test. But that still doesn't require any single central authority to dispense or verify IDs; I could still generate my own UUIDs for each of these entities and then allow them to link those IDs to the appropriate information. The fact that we allow the government to create one central "ID" for us does not mean that's the only way to meet those needs.