5 ms·
> "Redmond spends more on R&D than Google and Apple combined. Think about that the next time someone tells you Microsoft doesn’t have a future." More like Micr
by mtgx 14y ago
> "Redmond spends more on R&D than Google and Apple combined. Think about that the next time someone tells you Microsoft doesn’t have a future."
More like Microsoft wastes more money on R&D that doesn't convert in revolutionary products more than both Apple and Google combined.
We've always known Microsoft spends a lot on R&D and they like to make those "20 years from now" videos, but I haven't seen much come out of it. Last year they even bragged about how they had the idea for the iPhone 20 years ago. But so what? How did that help them? At best it helped them create Windows Mobile and the PDA's 10 years later, but that was a niche market, and Microsoft never had much market share with Windows Mobile in the smartphone market, which was a lot smaller than the current smartphone market back then.
So I guess the moral of the story is that "lab inventions" don't mean much, and you could waste a lot of money on them, and with very little to show for it in the market. I'm pretty sure the $2 billion dollar Kin project was part of that R&D spending, too.
- pron 14y agoLab inventions aren't meant to be successful in the market, and I'm not sure Microsoft is doing all that research just for financial gain, but even if it is, and it's not succesful -- so what? It is actually quite known in the tech industry (among those who really care about technology and not just business) that after the slow decline of Bell Labs and Sun Labs, the two most innovative tech companies are IBM and Microsoft. Actually, I've always assumed everybody knows this. I don't know if it means Microsoft (or IBM) "has a future", but who cares? There's so much good stuff coming from those two companies (or their research divisions to be exact), so why not just enjoy it? Also, I don't know how it works at Microsoft, but at IBM Research, the company is responsible for only half the funding. The researchers have to secure the rest themselves from grants and such, just like in any academic institution.
- DanBC 14y ago> More like Microsoft wastes more money on R&D that doesn't convert in revolutionary products [...] This sentence is weird to read here. We have a big company spending money on science that is not tied to what they can sell. That is a good thing. I am disappointed that anyone on HN can say anything different. Of course, we could have a discussion about the difficulties of running pure research alongside a commercial arm. But that's not what your comment is doing.
- enraged_camel 14y agoI don't think research whose results do not see the light of day is valuable in any shape or form. This is especially true for corporate-sponsored research, where the results are either kept as trade secrets or patented by the corporate lawyers, which means scientists elsewhere cannot build on top of that research later.
- pron 14y agoBut you're completely wrong here. All research done by Microsoft and IBM is published as academic papers. That's what the people there are paid to do: publish papers. Many of them are postdoctoral researchers and need this for their academic careers. Just like Bell Labs, Sun Labs, and IBM Research, this is more of an academic institution backed by a corporation than a corporate R&D division.
- genwin 14y agoMS Research's stated mission is to "take our best ideas and push them into our products as rapidly as we possibly can".
- Locke1689 14y agoYou are being extremely disingenuous. This is the rest of the quote: “It embodies what we believe in and our sense of values,” Rashid said. “It states, first and foremost, that our goal as an institution is to move the state of the art forward. It doesn't matter what part of the state of the art we're moving forward, and it doesn't say anything in that first part of the mission statement about Microsoft. It simply says our goal is to further research in the fields in which we work. “The second part is equally simple: When we have really good ideas, our goal is to make sure we get them into use, that we change the world with our ideas and with our technology. We take our best ideas and push them into our products as rapidly as we possibly can. That's important.”
- liftthatback 14y agoYou are very, very mistaken. Microsoft sponsors many top people in computer science and allows them to spend time on pure research and to publish academic papers. Ever heard of Simon Peyton Jones or Sir Tony Hoare? How can that be bad? For example, Microsoft pays most of the top Haskell developers to research and develop Haskell. There's no patents on that, and the source code and papers are all freely available. Microsoft isn't turning it into a product, it's just doing it to better computer science, to increase their standing, and to inform their other products such as C#. And you say that's bad? Fuck you.
- fiatmoney 14y agoA lot of their R&D goes into things like improvements to database architecture or compiler technology that gets rolled into new releases, but doesn't constitute a "product". Research doesn't have to be sexy to be useful.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoI'm a compilers guy, and I approve this message. Research spending by both Microsoft and Apple has produced massive advances that then got packaged into Visual Studio and XCode, generating quite a whole lot of value and even capturing a fair portion of it as revenue.
- brudgers 14y ago"I haven't seen much come out of it." While designers have spent a decade gushing over skueomorphism, rounded rectangles and gradients, Microsoft has made two steps forward in the WIMPy UI development - the ribbon and Metro. Furthermore, while Google and Apple are trying to partition the world into walled gardens; via TouchDevelop, Microsoft is the only major company pursuing mobile devices for general computing.
- pnathan 14y agolab inventions can look so far ahead of the industry that they are ignored and considered useless toys. see plan 9.
- liftthatback 14y ago"I haven't seen much come out of it" Are you mad?! In fields such as machine learning and languages, papers by Microsoft Research _dominate_ top conference proceedings.
- tellarin 14y agoQuite the same in Computer Graphics and Systems/Networking.
- tlogan 14y agoActually, the problem with Microsoft is not their R&D. If they stop spending on R&D, Microsoft will still have the same set of problems. It seems like their problem is that actually that they are not bold enough to push some of their research things to the market. Why do they need to copy Apple or Google in order to succeed in mobile market? Why not to do something bold and push it?
- Uhhrrr 14y agoOne thing you (and the other replies so far) are forgetting is the patent portfolio. Industry research groups generate IP which can be used as a cudgel up to 17 years down the line.
- r0s 14y agoR&D is almost entirely tax deductible from what I remember.
- cunac 14y agoRemember first you have to earn 10B and then spend. If you just paid taxes on 10B you will still have a lot of net gain couple of B at least. I guess haters will hate regardless.