4 ms·
I've been a zipcar user for several years. I hope they have some more affordable rates coming up after this. I don't have a car, and so I rely on zipcar when I
by samstave 14y ago
I've been a zipcar user for several years. I hope they have some more affordable rates coming up after this.
I don't have a car, and so I rely on zipcar when I do need one. The problem is that if I need it a few times a month it's rediculous compared to the cost of having a car.
One month I needed a car a lot, and wound up spending $850 on zipcars! That sucked.
- philwelch 14y agoWhere I live, owning a car would cost $150/mo for parking, another $100/mo for insurance, maybe $50/mo for gas, and maybe $300-400/mo for the car itself. That's $600-700/mo TCO, and that's before maintenance and repair, and I only get one type of car at a time rather than being able to upsize and downsize as required. If you only go over that by $150 in one peak month, and you're usually under it, you're getting fantastic value. For me, I break even compared to parking and insurance alone
- albedoa 14y agomaybe $300-400/mo for the car itself. This is true only if you ever own a car white it is under financing and it loses its full value over the course of the loan. Edit: unless you were simply dividing the cost of the car over the number of months you'd be driving it and you already factored value retention into that number, in which case either you don't need to worry about money anyway because you are rich or there are much better ways for you to better manage your money!
- philwelch 14y agoSo buy it cash, $12,000 figuring a 10 year depreciation. That's still $100/mo, and probably a lower end car than you'll drive with Zipcar. I'm breaking even assuming even a free car, though.
- unreal37 14y agoA car is going to lose some value every month no matter how you finance it or pay cash. So it's safe to assume a few hundred a month for depreciation for a newer model car like Zipcar provides.
- albedoa 14y agoOf course, see my edit. The $300–400/mo is more than a tad on the high side though.
- muzz 14y agoRule of thumb is on average 15% of the value per year, or roughly 1.2% each month. $300/mo would be depreciation on a car worth $25000, which is in line with the value of a new-ish Honda Accord
- albedoa 14y agoThat's not how depreciation works. If the rule of thumb is 15% per year, then it is 15% off of the remaining value, meaning a new-ish Honda Accord would be worth about $9,400 after six years (about $216/mo). Whereas if you take 15% of $25k off every year, the car would be worth nothing after about six and a half years. We know that's not true.
- hhw 14y agoIt depends on whether you are using the straight line or declining balance method. In this particular context, the 15-20% rule of thumb for cars does refer to declining balance, which does reflect the market value of cars more closely. If it were straight line though, you could just have a predetermined residual value for a specific useful life of the asset, and then depreciate the percentage of the difference from the original value and the residual value each year. You can also easily have depreciation where the residual value is less than the fair market value at the end of the asset's useful life or stated period though. You can never perfectly predict the residual value after all, but that's what capital recovery, or gain on disposal are used to describe.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- elteto 14y agoI agree with most of your estimates but $300-$400 per month will put you in the luxury sedan category. If that is your kind of thing perfect, but is definitely outside of range of what most people pay for a car. Perhaps it depends on where you live, but I have seen a fully loaded Accord (without navigation) go for $250-$300 per month, and that is a very nice car.
- elteto 14y agoI agree with most of your estimates but $300-$400 per month will put you in the luxury sedan category. If that is your kind of thing perfect, but is definitely outside of range of what most people pay for a car. Perhaps it depends on where you live, but I have seen a fully loaded Accord (without navigation) go for $250-$300 per month, and that is a very nice car.
- derda 14y agoWhy didn't you rent from a conventional rental company that month?
- samstave 14y agoTwo reasons: I didn't know I was going to need it that much and I pay cash for everything and thus do not have a credit card. You cannot rent a car without a credit card. Period. They do not accept a visa debit card at all.
- mseebach 14y agoIn that case you've voluntarily constrained yourself from using the full range of options available. I don't know what your rationale for not having a credit card is, but if it's control, you should know that ZipCar still holds you liable in much the same way a regular rental do, they just trust you enough to not require "collateral" in form of a credit card.
- alexkus 14y agoDon't know if the US is the same but with UK Zipcar over 21's can pay a small amount (£15/month or £99/year) to reduce the damage fee waiver to £0. That way there's no liability except if you use the car for things that Zipcar prohibit. We do this for each rental after being stung for damage done to the vehicle after we'd returned it[1]. It's an annoying flaw in their rental model; I now take photos/video of the car after I've returned it to hopefully prevent getting the blame in a future similar scenario. 1. You're essentially liable for any damage up until the time that it is next booked out. We had to pay as there was nothing we could do to prove it wasn't us. That damage even includes things like "damage caused by unavoidable events such as floods, hail, wind, trees falling, etc."
- samstave 14y agoI have impulse control issues coupled with procrastination :) This makes credit cards a bad thing for me personally. So, several years ago - I decided I would live completely within my means and not do anything on credit. If I cant pay cash for it, I dont need it. This personal choice has its issues, sure, but I have been happy for 7+ years this way, and aside from the one time I tried to rent a car at SFO to take for a weekend getaway, it has never been a detriment to my lifestyle.
- bonzoesc 14y ago> I've been a zipcar user for several years. I hope they have some more affordable rates coming up after this. Why would they lower their rates? Avis isn't a charity; they're in the business of making money. They know how much people are willing to pay for flexible car rental: at least $850 per month. No reason to lower the prices as long as people are still willing to pay.
- 3minus1 14y agoThere actually is a reason to lower the price if it results in more people who are willing to pay more often. I see your comment as the kneejerk libertarian response to anyone complaining about a price (without actually knowing any details about whatever market is being talked about), and it annoys me.
- unreal37 14y agoThey just bought out a competitor. Less competitors means rates go up on average. Don't expect lower Zipcar rates from this...
- jonursenbach 14y agoYou might've spent $850 on cars that month, but what about the rest of the year? I tallied up my Zipcar usage for 2012 the other day, and I spent $1750 on Zipcars. Most I'd rent a car was 3-4 times a month for 2-4 hours. Compare $1750 to the $100/mo and $250/mo, plus maintenance and gas for the car I used to own and Zipcar is still incredibly affordable.
- jellicle 14y agoWhen competitors get bought out, rates go up, not down. Avis is buying Zipcar at least in part to raise their rates and reduce competition with the rest of Avis.