10 ms·
Before we start with the standard junk about "imperial measures are better because they are easier to understand / better suited to human scale / etc." can I sa
by SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago
Before we start with the standard junk about "imperial measures are better because they are easier to understand / better suited to human scale / etc." can I say nope.
The only advantage that imperial measures have (for some) is that they are familiar. That's the sum total of it. People where were raised metric find these apologies for imperial measures to be pure gibberish.
- rjdagost 14y agoThese "apologies" are not gibberish. Measurements units are like words in that they are conventions that enough people agree with to make them useful as a way of communicating. Measurement units exist to help us quantify our world and if two systems do this equally well then there is no recompelling reason to switch. Besides which, what problem would be solved in the process? People will use whatever units they prefer anyways at the end of the day. As a negative, forcing top-down change would irritate people.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago> Measurement units exist to help us quantify our world and if two systems do this equally well then there is no recompelling reason to switch. The world is already nine-tens of the way through the switch. This is a compelling reason to finish the job.
- brudgers 14y ago"Familiar" is a bit off target because it implies that use is a matter of individual choice. The system is embedded in standards, such as SAE. It is embedded in industries such as construction. It is embedded into statutes, regulations, and deeds for real property. Yes, the system is familiar, but wiping the slate clean and starting anew is not a feature of stable democracies.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago> (The Imperial system) is embedded in industries such as construction. It is embedded into statutes, regulations, and deeds for real property. So is the metric system now in most of the world. And where the non-metric world has to interact with the rest of us, metric is embedded in their processes too. E.g. science done in the U.S. and engineering goods made for export in the US. This comment http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4996646 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4996646 discusses some of the same issues.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoThe system is embedded in standards, such as SAE. It is embedded in industries such as construction. It is embedded into statutes, regulations, and deeds for real property. I knew a civil engineer who first worked in the private industry and later got a job at the DOT. At the construction company, they did everything in metric internally. Once a design was finalized, they would convert everything to imperial and submit to the DOT. DOT is behind the times, she thought. When she got to the DOT, she learned their procedure. Before engineers got started reading the plans, a secretary would translate units from imperial to metric for internal use. The fact that an old contract specifies units of rods and farthings is not an argument for anything other than defining official conversion factors between the old way and the new way.
- curiousdannii 14y agoYes, the system is familiar, but wiping the slate clean and starting anew is not a feature of stable democracies. What about those that already went through the metric conversion?
- ArchD 14y agoWhy can't the existing code be modified by simply replacing old units with metric ones denoting the same quantity? If necessary, use a high level of precision in the expressions, and over time, have an initiative to slowly and gradually normalize those quantities to simpler numbers.
- randomdata 14y agoI was raised metric, but still find utility in the imperial system under some circumstances. I use my anatomy to measure things all the time while out on the farm, for instance. You could say step off 914cms, but I think 30 feet makes more sense in the context since you are literally counting your steps. If you have precise measuring tools at your disposal, then I'm inclined to agree though.
- BasDirks 14y agoHow about 10 meters?
- rohern 14y agoThis doesn't make any sense. 1ft is ~30cm. Just measure in units of 30cm. Doing the math in your head is trivial.
- randomdata 14y agoBut why needlessly introduce the math, no matter how trivial it may actually be?
- rohern 14y agoWe are constantly needlessly introducing math across all of our industries that have international partners by keeping our current system. Your point to which I was responding was that you feel it is more natural to measure in units of feet. I was pointing out to you that you can make the same measurement in a convenient unit in the metric system. We can have ease of use in both cases with the metric system. But it doesn't matter anyway. You could sit and invent an infinite number of cases when using the imperial system "feels" easier. None of these invalidate the conveniences of the metric system, nor do they remove the compelling motivation to setup our system in line with that of the rest of the world to stop the waste of money, material, and time the is now spent on conversion, dual labeling, and confusion.
- randomdata 14y ago
- rplnt 14y agoAren't their much easier to use? Conversion between units is straight-forward, there is connection between length and volume units, and probably much more common-senses-ness. I mean, the ft+inch system for human height is absolutely horrible.
- oneandoneis2 14y agoActually, I think metric could be improved with a few imperial equivalents - A "metric foot" as 30cm, for instance - because they are convenient measurements. e.g. If somebody asks me "How tall is that person?" it's easier to say "About five foot" rather than "I dunno, about 155cm?" (I'm British, btw)
- Tichy 14y agoHow does that even work - do you actually draw a mental image of yourself walking up that person's length foot by foot? And what if your feet are not 30cm, but longer or shorter? If you say "about x" you might as well estimate to 10cm precision and say "about 180cm" or "about 190cm".
- Adirael 14y agoOn Spain we just say "one fifty five", not much longer and it's still easy.
- rplnt 14y agoThen you would end up: "Not about, how exactly tall he is?", "Oh, five foot and 5 cm." The 30cm unit would improve absolutely nothing, it would only complicate things. If you want to use approximate measurement, just round it to tens of centimeters. Or you can use meters with one decimal place, whatever comes more natural.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago> If you want to use approximate measurement, just round it to tens of centimeters I totally agree. Rounding to powers of ten works comes for free in metric measurements using base ten numbers. This is by design.
- sirn 14y agoI only live in Metric-using country and I have no slightest idea how tall is five foot, whereas 155cm instantly comes to my mind as, ah, at around my eye level. It's all about familiarity.
- danielbarla 14y agoPeople complain about the usual issues: multiple definitions of a mile, the odd ratios between inches, feet, yards, etc. It gets even more fun in agriculture, where the bushel is a frequently used unit. Now, the bushel is a unit of volume, whereas much of the world prefer to measure their crops by weight. To convert between the two, you essentially need to use conversion ratio (or table) for the crop type, along with an estimate of the moisture content of your product. To be fair, this is more to do with a difference in measuring methodology, rather than a failure of the imperial system, but it still highlights the kind of issues that come up between the systems. More info: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bushel http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bushel
- Tichy 14y agoWhy not use metric volumes instead of bushel? You'd have the same conversion issues converting bushel to imperial weights.
- danielbarla 14y agoWell, at some point, that part of the world decided that they'd use weight to measure produce, as opposed to volume. So now, if you read a scientific paper from Europe, you will get numbers in KG, likely with no indication of moisture content (since they don't particularly care). So, you're left with an inaccurate conversion to bushels, or more likely, you simply don't use the paper. The same goes for the other way around; there's probably a whole lot of rework that happens due to this incompatibility.
- Tichy 14y agoI get the problem, my point was just that it is unrelated to the issue of imperial vs metric system.
- rmccue 14y agoThis is fairly similar to fuel mileage, where some places use miles per gallon (distance per volume) while others use litres per 100km (volume per distance). Changing systems is fairly irrelevant though, since you can still measure your mileage in kilometres per litre if you want.
- xefer 14y agoTo be honest, although I know the obvious benefits of metric, I still prefer imperial simply because of its messiness. I realize the system is archaic, etc., but I still like that connection, as attenuated as it may be, to our ancient past. Use metric for all scientific purposes, etc., but keep that connection to the natural world. I suppose I like it in the same way I prefer natural languages to some artificial languages like Esperanto, etc. - or our base-60 time units as opposed to some other decimal-based system. :)
- harshreality 14y agoSentiment is not a good justification in the science/engineering world.
- frogpelt 14y agoIs there a large contingency of people in the science and engineering world not using metric? Like a previous commenter said, all my science labs in high school and college used metric. I imagine legitimate research and engineering labs in America are also using metric.
- xxpor 14y agoCivil and a lot of Mechanical still use standard. Especially for machining and such. We also used kips (kilopounds) in my Statics class.
- Gmo 14y agoWell, it seems that NASA, at least a few years ago, did not consistently use metric ...
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y agoNASA may have learned a hard lesson that time.
- coenhyde 14y ago
- micampe 14y agoI didn't think there were people that really tried to defend the imperial system on anything but familiarity. not very happy of having been proved wrong.
- HCIdivision17 14y agoFrom what I've experienced, we use the imperial units for the same reason we use degrees over radians: the units allow for common use of integer multiples of simple fractions. For some people, a simple fraction of a relatable unit really is easier to deal with than a base ten decimal, and a lot of labor out there simply doesn't need higher precision. Of course, once you enter any sort of engineering work, well, simple fractions often won't cut it and it's far, far easier to simply use a decimal number. And then there's no reason not to use metric measurements.
- reycharles 14y agoFirst of all, I think it's a poor example. A full circle in degrees is an integer while in radians it's not even a fractional number (it's an irrational number)! Also, I don't get the thing about fractions. Decimal numbers are fractions as well.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago> the units allow for common use of integer multiples of simple fractions. What does that mean? Isn't "use of multiples of fractions" a property of numbers in general? > For some people, a simple fraction of a relatable unit really is easier to deal with than a base ten decimal What's easier is what you're used to. That's the whole point.
- cicero 14y ago12 can be evenly divided into thirds and quarters, but 10 cannot. It is more likely that something will need to be divided 2 or 3 ways than 5 ways.
- TomAnthony 14y agoTrue, yet most of the rest of the world seem to be suffering any from this 'deficiency'.
- benbataille 14y ago10 can be divided in third and quarter fine. It does 10/3 and 10/4=2.5. Well, 10/3 isn't round so people don't like it but neither is 1/3 of an inch. It's not because a lot of operations suddenly become doable with numbers that you magically lose the usage of fractions.
- RyanMcGreal 14y agoBut, but - thumbs! Elbows! Feet!
- oddthink 14y agoReasonably scaled measurements are very useful, though. Everything in astronomy is measured in scaled units. Mass is in solar masses, interstellar distances are in parsecs (well kiloparsecs) or light years, planetary orbits are in astronomical units. Similar, a lot of atomic physics uses angstroms. Of course, that doesn't apply much when the difference is only a factor of 2, like the pound/kilogram difference, but even there people cheat a bit by just saying "kilo."
- ubernostrum 14y agoBefore we start in... let's remember that in most contexts, the units don't matter. What matters is picking a system and sticking to it. (and that there still is no such thing as a "one size fits all" system of units)
- geon 14y ago> the units don't matter. What matters is picking a system and sticking to it That is exactly the problem with the imperial system. You have multiple units for the same thing, and when they are multiples of each other, it is in base 12. You could settle on feet and have kilofeet and millifeet, and you'd have a sensible system (apart from being incompatible with the rest of the world).
- ubernostrum 14y agoIt's easy to get dismissive about having multiple units, until you run into the contexts where they really are useful. Following up the example in one of my other comments: adopt the meter and the kilometer, or the foot and the kilofoot, and it won't matter to navigators, because they'll still use the nautical mile unless you literally put a gun to their heads, and if you do put a gun to their heads they'll show you why it's a much more practical unit for what they do.
- Permit 14y ago>they'll show you why it's a much more practical unit for what they do. Why? Why is it more practical? How is it better other than being more familiar? It blows me away that people can make the argument as it being "better".
- gshubert17 14y agoOne nautical mile is very nearly the length of one minute of arc at the earth's surface.
- 14y ago
- DanBC 14y agoYou think there are no advantages to easy divisibility? 16 is divisible by 1, 2, 4, 8, and 16. 24 is divisible by 1, 2, 3, 4, 6, 8, 12, 24 10 just has 1, 2, 5, 10
- ArchD 14y agoSo what if the old units are easily divisible? If you have 1024 g of something, you can divide that by 2 ten times.
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y agoThat's an argument against counting in base 10, and it's a fair one. However, while we do count in base 10, metric is the way forward. If you wanted, you could always count in 2 times, 12 times or 16 times the basic SI units.
- masklinn 14y agoAnd then people invented decimals.
- DanBC 14y agoIt's frustrating that the same people who push weird systems (ounces, the old money in UK) instead of metric units and decimal money are comfortable doing all kinds of mental arithmetic, but freeze when as soon as you involve a decimal point. People who have no trouble with the concept of "half of a third for four people taken out of this bag of potatoes" get stuck on "0.25". For all the people who answered my post - I agree that metric and SI are the sensible way forward. I'm kind of relieved that some sections of US[1] industry are choosing to ignore the international market or to lumber themselves with extra costs for both systems. [1] Because I'm not in the US; I'm European and I want our industry to do well.
- reycharles 14y agoConverting between m and km is dead simple, it's just a "decimal shift" / textual operation (move the comma).
- kriro 14y ago
- BashiBazouk 14y agoIt's not really "standard junk" though. Imperial measures are standardized human units. I have a foot that is about a foot, a knuckle that is about an inch, a stride that is about a yard. One day carrying a gallon of water a decent distance I realized that this was about the max amount the average person could carry comfortably over distance. That is what kills me about the metric system. It seems to intentionally ignore the human scale. Why is 10 centimeters not a standard unit of measurement, and this is the important part, that is marked on every ruler and tape measure? The same for 10 Milliliters, 10 grams and 100 grams. Over the entire metric system the base 10 increments that are human scale are always ignored. The liter is the only one that comes close. Why is this? Until the human scale is taken in to account I'm perfectly happy using more than one measurement system...
- SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago> Imperial measures are standardized human units As someone raised metric, Imperial measures are just weird, pointless and baroque. It is nothing more than a question of what you are used to.