3 ms·
According to the IEEE, another geomagnetic storm like the ones that happened in 1921 and 1859 would take out power grids continent-wide, for years: http://spect
by DennisP 14y ago
According to the IEEE, another geomagnetic storm like the ones that happened in 1921 and 1859 would take out power grids continent-wide, for years: http://spectrum.ieee.org/energy/the-smarter-grid/a-perfect-storm-of-planetary-proportions/0 http://spectrum.ieee.org/energy/the-smarter-grid/a-perfect-s...
The main problem is high-voltage transformers, which are built mostly by hand by highly-skilled labor. There's a fairly simple way to protect them, but no utility does it.
- ky3 14y agoThere's a fairly simple way to protect them, but no utility does it. You mean a faraday cage? Will wrapping it with foil work?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- pavel_lishin 14y ago> First, the intense magnetic field variations in the magnetosphere induce electric fields and currents over large areas of Earth's surface. In turn, this geoelectric field creates what are known as geomagnetically induced currents, or GICs, which flow in any available conductor, including high-voltage transmission lines, oil and gas pipelines, railways, and undersea communications cables. These interconnecting networks essentially act as giant antennas that channel the induced currents from the ground. Hit with a 300-ampere GIC, a high-voltage transformer's paper tape insulation will burn, its copper winding will melt, and the transformer will fail, either right then and there or in the future. > There is a quick and relatively cheap fix to help protect these transformers from geomagnetically induced currents: They can be retrofitted to block the inflow of GICs. But no utilities anywhere routinely protect their multimillion-dollar transformers in this way.
- mseebach 14y agoSo this is basically just fusing the transformer, right? The grid will still be down?
- PeterisP 14y agoWell, if both the transformers and actual long distance wires survive the event, then the grid can be brought back up. Most of grid 'defenses' involve some temporary disconnection of components; the robustness question is how quickly you can reconnect again - is it an automatic switch after half a second, or does it require sending repair squads to thousand remote locations.
- ars 14y agoIt'll go down, but at least it won't be destroyed. Storms last less than a day, so you can get power back on then, rather than months later.
- ars 14y agoPeople suggest faraday cages all the time, but they will not work for things like this! Faraday cages only work for high frequencies, but geomagnetic storms and EMP's are low frequency, and will pass right through a faraday cage. (Unless you made an incredibly thick one.) You need Mu-metal for this kind of shielding. (Not that it would work here anyway - the currents are induced in the long powerlines, not in the transformer.) Also, foil it very thin, so it only works for frequencies above 50Mhz or so.
- tomjen3 14y agoWell then maybe they better get their asses over and fix this -- rather than go around invading small countries.
- knowaveragejoe 14y agoBecause those are totally the same groups of people.
- dclusin 14y agoI've actually worried about this one a lot after reading about the solar storm of 1859. For those of you who haven't read about it (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_storm_of_1859 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_storm_of_1859) I highly recommend reading up on it. The TL;DR version is that one of the largest solar flares ever recorded was produced on the surface of the sun and the ensuing geomagnetic storm that passed by earth was so strong it was able to power telegraph machines that were not plugged in. My laymen speculation is that this would be much worse than just transformers, given how computers are penetrating every aspect of our lives. Imagine the impact to our society if transportation and electricity failed simultaneously.
- DennisP 14y agoIf the grid goes down continent-wide and stays down, we're not running computers or pumping liquid fuels anymore. We're not delivering fertilizer and other chemicals to farms, either, not that it matters much since if we could produce our normal crop we couldn't deliver it.