4 ms·
My lesson is slightly different - regulation really does matter. I know many (myself included) subscribe to a small (ish) government - but infrastructure is on
by lifeisstillgood 14y ago
My lesson is slightly different - regulation really does matter. I know many (myself included) subscribe to a small (ish) government - but infrastructure is one of those areas that has to be regulated.
The markets did not correct the situation (jacques gas station is not now the preferred suppliers for all Ontario)
So a simple regulation (you must be designed to keep your service flowing) seems to deal with a huge amount of this - power companies that don't have rolling brown outs get to be in business the next day etc
- jacquesm 14y agoJacques' gas station actually went out of business: http://www.jacquesmattheij.com/stick-to-what-you-know-a-tale-of-an-investment-gone-wrong http://www.jacquesmattheij.com/stick-to-what-you-know-a-tale...
- wisty 14y agoDue to lax accounting, it seems. (There's a more proximate reason, but the story's too good to spoil with a tl;dr).
- e40 14y agoDue to lax accounting, it seems. Uh, not even close. His employees embezzled more than $150,000.
- jacquesm 14y agoMore due to a lack of oversight and an excess of trust. I'm pretty sure my Canadian accountant would be quite upset at your conclusion. Cash disappearing has nothing at all to do with accounting.
- wisty 14y agoMaybe I'm using the term "accounting" a bit loosely. It's not the accountants job to monitor day-to-day cashflow, that's more a bookkeeper's or manager's job. If they're crooked, it's a bit harder to catch (especially if they are able to offset cash losses with by opening secret a line of credit with a supplier).
- newbie12 14y agoThe bigger issue is that power appears to be over-regulated-- there is a single government monopoly provider, so when that provider went offline all was lost.
- yk 14y agoThe power grid ( as the fiber grid) is a natural monopoly. The reason is, that it costs $x to get to n costumers. The second guy needs also $x to build his grid, but can only expect n/2 customers. ( Or he has some great trick to get all of the customers, but then one monopoly is just replaced by another.) Additionally infrastructure has the strong tendency to externalize costs. In the example of the posting, the power company has somewhat lower income ( and needs to repair its grid), but actually damages are spread all over the place, like the guy who has to firesale his pizza before the ingredients are bad. So for the utility company it makes sense to just go for 99% reliability and insure some downtime, but on a larger level the total damages incurred for the economy will not be insured. Infrastructure is therefore a case, where the problem is not over regulation, since we deal with a monopoly anyhow. The problem is that at best wrong regulation. ( Assuming the power outage was not caused by some freak accident.)
- joshuahedlund 14y agoPower grids tend to have the properties of a natural monopoly, but note that power itself does not (ex. solar panels). The challenge is to regulate the existing monopoly in ways that do not discourage innovation in providing the more general end service that is not a monopoly.
- crusso 14y agoI'm with you on the need to regulate critical infrastructure. The tricky part is having a government powerful enough to be able to create smart regulations without allowing established interests to "help" write those regulations at the expense of their upstart competitors.
- mseebach 14y agoActually, I think this is a great example of how you can get ahead of yourself regulating - I'm assuming you think the lesson should be that all gas stations should have generators? In some communities the gas station probably is a life and death concern, but in most it isn't - so requiring all gas station owners to invest in and maintain a generator is an expense (passed on to consumers, like all regulation) with a very low return. And we haven't even considered unintended consequences: When gas stations are critical infrastructure, having a generator in your garage (but no fuel stored) makes more sense, so you risk overloading the gasoline supply by shifting all energy consumption to it, thus causing it to become unavailable anyway. Also, I'm not sure why making Jacques' gas station the preferred supplier would be a meaningful expected market response. He already stated that they turned over a month's fuel in two days, that should have made him a pretty good profit.