5 ms·
> After the first week, which is always the hardest, I'd lost 10 pounds. Dropping carbohydrates from the diet causes a drop in retained water. For instance, so
by jacques_chester 14y ago
> After the first week, which is always the hardest, I'd lost 10 pounds.
Dropping carbohydrates from the diet causes a drop in retained water. For instance, some energy is stored in the muscles as glycogen, which binds with water on an approximately 1-to-3 basis. Each gram of glycogen binds ~3g of water; so when you cut carb intake and begin to break down stored glycogen, you unsurprisingly lose weight quickly.
Paleo and keto types call this a "signing bonus". It's generally not an indicator of the long term trend because there's not much of your body mass tied up this way. When people are overweight, it's usually fat. And fat is a stupidly dense store of energy compared to the glycogen/water mechanism.
Athletes in weight-class sports (boxing, powerlifting, wrestling, weightlifting etc) have known about carbohydrate and sodium tricks for manipulating water weight for a long time.
All the matters is: can you impose a long term deficit? Whether by paleo, keto or any other dietary method, the sole long term determinant of average body mass is net caloric balance.
I wrote about this simple physical fact last year [1], which prompted what one friend called "the diet riot". It was good for lulz then. I bet it will be again.
In the past year I've followed a diet called "Eating Less" (Intermittent Fasting, to be all trendy about it[2]). So far this has put me down about 30kg from my peak weight -- approximately 65lb.
[1] http://chester.id.au/2012/05/26/fat-and-simple/ http://chester.id.au/2012/05/26/fat-and-simple/
[2] http://chester.id.au/2012/04/17/my-diet/ http://chester.id.au/2012/04/17/my-diet/
- angersock 14y agoRead The Hacker's Diet a while ago, and it seemed reasonable to my old control-systems training. What's the current sort of counter-argument to the abstraction presented there?
- jacques_chester 14y agoThe counter argument seems to be that ketosis is somehow magically exempt from the laws of physics. One of those blog posts sparked exactly such a discussion -- that the body was "too complex" to be governed by mere physics.
- forgottenpaswrd 14y ago"that the body was "too complex" to be governed by mere physics." The body is too complex to be governed by "mere physics", because it uses control systems that regulate the intake process. I can eat three times more than a friend of mine, and incorporate to my body way less than my friend, because bacteria and virus in my intestines are completely different from hers. Also my body is different. A calorie of fat has nothing to do with a calorie of sucrose or glucose. "Mere physics" of burning something at 1000C and measuring the thermal output is completely different from the "real physics"of metabolizing substances in a 20 different steps chain process, where every step could be inhibited or excited by cell control systems.
- jacques_chester 14y agoAs I say elsewhere, all this is by the by; all that matters is net calorie balance and all that's needed is to compare inputs (diet, exercise) with outputs (weight, appearance). Your friend no more needs to know about your gut flora than you need to know about my insulin sensitivity.
- kyberias 14y agoI doubt that you can eat three times more than your friend. In fact, that is impossible. Please provide us with some real numbers and data.
- jacques_chester 14y agoIf I may generalise most offensively, people in prosperous societies have basically no freaking idea how much they are eating (or not eating, as the case may be). Eg: http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7869932 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7869932 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/2082216 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/2082216 I remember talking to a (rake-thin) cousin of mine about this when we went to dinner one night. "I eat as much as anyone", he protested. Later in the evening, noticed that while I had finished the chips that came with our dinners, he had not.
- jiffyjeff 14y agoThe Hacker's Diet hinges on: ((calories in) - (calories out)) / 3500 = (l lb of weight loss) The Hacker's Diet holds as an axiom that calories from fat, carbohydrate and protein are equivalent in this formula. This assumption neglects the powerful influence of the hormone insulin, which plays a key role in regulating fat metabolism. Insulin release is very highly correlated with carbohydrate consumption, and a diet that restricts carbohydrate will often lead to weight loss.
- jacques_chester 14y agoThis sounds awfully ... Taubesy. Problems with the Taubes' it's-all-carbs-and-insulin hypothesis: * Protein consumption causes insulin spikes too. * Insulin is not the only hormone involved in weight control system and energy system behaviour. Also involved: leptin, ghrelin, glucagon, cortisol and probably dozens of others neither of us will hear of in our entire lifetimes. * Population obesity closely tracks calories-per-capita, apparently regardless of macronutrient breakdown (http://wholehealthsource.blogspot.com.au/2012/06/calories-still-matter.html http://wholehealthsource.blogspot.com.au/2012/06/calories-st...).
- wlievens 14y agoHow about the argument that higher sugar intake causes you to be more hungry, therefore making it easier to eat less calories on a low suger (high-fat) diet. I know it's an entirely different argument from the "keto magic" argument you are ranting against, but do you object to it?
- jacques_chester 14y agoFirstly, it doesn't come up in proper trials (eg http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17413101 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17413101). That's part of the general Taubes carbs-insulin hypothesis; that insulin affects satiety (the feeling of fullness, or no longer wanting to eat). As I said above, there are more hormones involved than insulin. For example, one very influential hormone is leptin. It has a profound affect on appetite and satiety; but we still only understand it poorly. And leptin can be affected by all sorts of factors. Sleep deprivation, even small amounts, really play merry hell with it. Next time you're running on fumes, you may notice both that a) you're starving and b) your ability to resist the temptation to eat anything is greatly diminished. And so on. The body is more complex than the thermodynamic equation, but ultimately that is enough to control your mass. The additional details are worth introducing as and when they are necessary (and a good dietitian will do that), but not before. People are very good at giving themselves excuses and, of course, analysis paralysis allows them to forestall any real change.
- eof 14y agoI am not a dietician by any stretch, but this 'net calorie' business seems really unlikely to me. Cars have different gas mileage; i doubt I am shitting out 0 calories, etc. Ketosis is a real thing and people do shed a shit ton of weight getting into that state; all of these things basically invalidate 'long term deficit' as the sole coeffecient into what is likely an incredibly complex equation only barely understood.
- jacques_chester 14y agoRead my longer blog post. I go over the whole matter. The tl;dr is that ketosis is not exempt from the laws of physics.
- eof 14y agoNo offence but your post is overly simplistic and not in anyway convincing that your actual thesis is a complete picture of what is going on. It is undeniably true that calories in vs calories out is a driving factor, it is not however the only factor. Your article shows how you think about diet/weight, and is not really reflective of any strong scientific understanding, and, in my opinion, needlessly disregards "… insulin! Starvation mode! Carbs! Zones! That study I saw written up in the New York Times!", when there is actually something here, or atleast potentially here that is also a driving force in weight. edited for politeness/accuracy
- jacques_chester 14y agoCare to elaborate? I can only suspect that, as usual, this will turn out to be a dispute over the boundaries of the system we're discussing (single-human-body-mass-system vs economy-society-and-single-human-body-system). If you genuinely believe that net calorie balance isn't the sole determinant of long term average mass, then I'd like to know what else it could be. Saying "oh it must be more complex than that!" isn't such an explanation.
- eof 14y ago
- stickdick 14y ago> Then I went to Kauai for a week and gained 10 pounds Is probably ~8lbs water. I'd be amazed if someone could gain 10lbs of fat in a week. That clocks in at about 50k total calories?
- jacques_chester 14y agoThe rule of thumb is 3500 kcals / lb. So 10lbs of fat would be nearly 35,000 kcals, a daily net caloric surplus (not caloric intake, surplus) of 5,000 kcals.
- fingerprinter 14y agoIt was water and glycogen. When I'm running low carb (for whatever reason) and have a carb refeed, I routinely gain 8-10 pounds in a 24 hour period. Same for people making a weight for powerlifting/boxing/wrestling. They manipulate their water/salt, getting all the glycogen out of their system before reintroducing them to "pump" them back up etc etc
- fingerprinter 14y agoI can't reply to your comment below b/c it is too many deep. I'll do that here and add some comments. Net calories is fine if your only goal is "don't be a fatass". If, however, you are an athlete, lift weights or want something more, net calories don't tell you much. There are some easy experiments. ===================================== Let's assume 2000 cals daily is a supposed 300 cal deficit for someone. Let's assume sedentary lifestyle. A. 2000 protein B. 2000 fat C. 2000 simple sugar carbs D. 2000 complex carbs What is going to happen? A and B will loose weight. C will likely gain weight, quite a bit of it fat. D will most likely gain weight as well, but probably less so. D in particular would depend on how "sensitive" they are to insulin spikes. ===================================== Same setup. New items. A. 2000 cals prot+fat B. 2000 cals prot+carbs C. 2000 cals carbs+fat D. 2000 cals prot+fat+carbs (35/25/40%). A will lose/maintain weight. B would be tough. Probably lose/maintain. C would gain weight (carbs and fat together do bad things, particularly in sedentary individuals). D. This is you. Would lose weight, but suboptimally. A would be better for weight lose. ===================================== For some context, I guess. I'm an amateur bodybuilder and powerlifter. I used to play competitive basketball. I have a (rather time consuming hobby) of writing fitness books. When people say "net calories are all that matter" it is clear they don't understand the problem domain nearly enough. Nor do they understand that one must manipulate the macronutrients to achieve certain goals. I hope we one day STOP talking about calories completely and only talk about macronutrient ratios and grams. This is much more important. For instance, I have a photoshoot coming up for a book. I'm cutting bodyfat right now to get as lean as possible. I'm running 6.5 days of near zero carbs, .5g fat/lb of desired bodyweight and 1-2g protein/lb of desired bodyweight (leg day I take in more protein for instance) and a singular non-carb insulin spike after my workout (whey protein, leucine and creatine shake to spike insulin and spare my muscle). On the 7th day, I "carb up", or refeed. I basically go nuts and eat simple carbs (icecream, rice, cereal) to replenish my glycogen stores and, WAY MORE IMPORTANTLY, recalibrate my hormones. When I'm trying to gain muscle, I do this: only protein and fat before a workout. Only carbs and protein after a workout. My macronutrients are about 20/25/55 (fat, protein and carbs). If net calories were the only thing that mattered, I could eat 1000 cals of pure sugar and get ready for my photo shoot. I can't. That is stupid. If net calorie surplus were the only thing that mattered to gain muscle I could eat 5000 cals of pure sugar or 5000 cals of pure fat to put on muscle. I can't. That is stupid. You have to understand what they are doing. However, there are some VERY simple rules. It just isn't nearly as simple as you think. And it is foolish to perpetuate this decades old bunk science. EDITED: tried to fix up the formatting a bit.