3 ms·
> It amazes me at how far to the political left is Silicon Valley. Speaking as a foreign onlooker (I'm in Australia), I see more libertarians than any other st
by jacques_chester 14y ago
> It amazes me at how far to the political left is Silicon Valley.
Speaking as a foreign onlooker (I'm in Australia), I see more libertarians than any other stripe, tbqh.
> Yet Silicon Valley regularly supports candidates and policies that would place large burdens on the entrepreneurial ecosystem.
The Bay Area is home to San Francisco, a traditional hotbed of leftist activism. It's also home to UCB, a traditional hotbed of leftist activism. Some of the outlying suburbs are ... yes, traditional hotbeds of leftist activism.
Mix in:
1. The relatively lower presence of traditional / conservative / "silent majority" voters who are motivated voters
2. That leftists are motivated voters
3. That libertarians are often not motivated voters
4. That voting in the USA is voluntary and not compulsory
and the electoral calculus suggests that libertarians will be out-numbered by leftists at the ballot box.
- smsm42 14y agoLibertarians are very active on the internet, but are practically non-existant as a political force on national scale. Fortunately, in some places (not in California) some Republican representatives hold views which are close to what libertarians can identify with. But this has very little to do with motivation and a lot to do with the fact that very small minority of people have libertarian views. Libertarian views are not natural. It is very hard to arrive at the idea that "there should be a law against that" is not the right answer for any problem and stay there. Most people think freedom is overrated.
- shitlord 14y ago> Most people think freedom is overrated Or maybe it's just that other people disagree with libertarians' notion of absolute freedom. Perhaps they define freedom differently. I'm sure most of us want the same things in life (like a decent standard of living), but we just can't seem to agree on the best ways to achieve them.
- cookiecaper 14y agoIt's about self-restraint. Libertarians believe government has very specific purposes and boundaries within which it must stay, and that other matters are totally irrelevant to governance. Non-libertarians want the classic "2 wolves and a sheep voting on dinner", libertarians say that dinner isn't even on the ballot. Of course, it's much easier to coerce people into doing the things you want them to do by making the desired behavior a matter of law than to convince each individual to cooperate and use his own free will to obtain the same result, so an undisciplined and unrestrained populace is going to disregard the "no voting on dinner" rule and use the force of the government to get what they want.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoNo, it's not about self-restraint. It's about basic definitional arguments. Libertarians define freedom as the absolute, unbridled exercise of private property titles. Non-libertarians take exception to both the extent (the "absolute, unbridled" part) and the core matter ("private property titles") for various reasons. Among these reasons: * Any value legislated into absolute supremacy becomes steadily more and more totalitarian. People want some moderation. * An archipelago of private dictatorships is called "feudalism", and is no better than a single public dictatorship. * "Property is theft!", as Bakunin put it. Private property titles are themselves a form of government-enforced coercion. Taxes you only have to pay once a year, land-rent you pay once a month, exploitative wage-labor you perform every weekday. * Even the most proprietarian society has some kind of public space, and it must be managed somehow. Example: you can't run naked through the streets. * Some people genuinely believe that "freedom" in the sense libertarians define it is unimportant or unworthy. See: religious conservatives. * Private capitalist markets are provably incapable of handling public goods (National Science Foundation, NASA) and commons goods (scarce fisheries, national forests, etc).
- cookiecaper 14y agoI consider myself libertarian and don't define freedom as "absolute, unbridled exercise of private property titles". I don't believe many libertarians hold that philosophy -- you're painting an extremist. While I appreciate your contribution of more detailed points of disagreement with some semblances of libertarian philosophy, I will refrain from refuting them because a) I don't have the time to get into it and b) it deviates into too much of a tangent to remain apropos of the original post.
- jacoblyles 14y ago>Speaking as a foreign onlooker (I'm in Australia), I see more libertarians than any other stripe, tbqh. Paul Graham's informal poll of investors had two-thirds voting for Obama. That's a stronger lean than the US as a whole. They might be libertarians, but they're libertarians voting for the unionist/leftist/regulatory party.
- jacques_chester 14y agoIt might be indicative, or it might not. Plurality voting systems lead to "least worst" strategies dominating.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoThey're capitalists voting for a managerial conservative capitalist party. America's "left-wing" Democrats would be right-wing Christian Democrats or right-wing Liberals in the entire rest of the First World and large portions of the developing world, too.
- MordinSolus 14y agoDoes is matter what the rest of the world would call it? No. In America, Obama is certainly to the left.
- eli_gottlieb 14y agoDoes is matter what the rest of the world would call it? In the sense that I expect a larger sample size to give more accurate results, yes.
- mathieuh 14y agoIf Obama is what leftist means in the USA (I still don't believe this), then what would you call a communist? I don't know if there is anywhere else where the political compass is so skewed. To most people I talked to when the US elections were going on, Obama is considered the left of the right.