3 ms·
Government taxes things (cigarettes, gasoline, high incomes) to discourage them.
by prostoalex 14y ago
Government taxes things (cigarettes, gasoline, high incomes) to discourage them.
- turing 14y agoGovernment taxes things to raise income.
- anigbrowl 14y agoBoth statements are true. Taxing as a method of altering spending patterns is very well understood by economists. In the case of cigarettes, it seem sot have been quite effective since smoking rates in the Us have fallen to historic lows.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- tommorris 14y agoI'd suggest that education campaigns and the natural human desire to not get lung cancer may have also played a part.
- anigbrowl 14y agoSurely, though it's worth noting that education campaigns and research are financed with both tax dollars and cigarette company settlement money (from a large lawsuit many years back).
- MartinCron 14y agoAnd as a result, people decide that being rich isn't worth it and become welfare queens instead. Tragic, really.
- prostoalex 14y agoThey still pursue wealth, just not through the income venue.
- suresk 14y agoThe "Welfare Queen" exists largely in the imagination of the right. Even in areas of the US with relatively generous public assistance, the difference in standard of living for someone who relies solely on welfare versus someone with even a moderate income (much less "rich") is so large, no rational person would choose to live on welfare just to avoid the taxation that resulted from having a high income. I certainly don't agree with tax policies designed to punish or discourage high incomes, but this is pure hyperbole.
- fpgeek 14y agoI suspect the grandparent comment is pure sarcasm.
- suresk 14y agoIf that is the case, I apologize and feel a bit sheepish. In my defense, I live an incredibly conservative area in the US, and many of my neighbors honestly believe this exact thing, so it isn't obvious sarcasm to me.
- MartinCron 14y agoI really thought that saying something so obviously false would be easy to detect as sarcasm/satire.
- robotresearcher 14y ago> this is pure hyperbole. I'm pretty sure it was satirical.
- jacoblyles 14y agoThere certainly do exist people that face a negative return to marginal work, due to the phase out of public assistance with income. I'm not really sure what "welfare queen" means, but there are plenty of people that face strong incentives to stay on public assistance and little help to get off of it. I wouldn't necessarily place all the blame on them, though.
- smsm42 14y agoThe whole marginal thing must be really confusing. The problem is not that rich people would stop generating income - they won't. The problem is that marginal rates modify behavior, including changing how income is generated, where it is generated, etc. And the rich are exactly the people that have ample tools and opportunities to do that. If you earn nearly-minimal wage in some shop, you don't have many other options. If your taxes are raised, there's not much you can do other than spit and curse. If you're an investor, you have wide array of options where to invest, how to invest, etc. I know it sucks that it is always sunny in the rich man's world, but it's a reality. If whoever designs tax policy ignores it, he'd be unpleasantly surprised when projected tax income falls short of the target, and would have to slash the benefits programs or get deeper in debt.
- aqme28 14y agoThere is no tax rate < 100% that discourages a higher income.
- jacques_chester 14y agoFor some people there is. It's a marginal effect. Every time you alter the tax rate, some fraction of earners will change their behaviour.
- smsm42 14y agoThere is. Living in California, marginal rates for a well-paid engineer can be 50% and more. Given that you give up half of the money, one's incentive to look for a side gigs and other supplemental income is significantly reduced. Of course, nobody turned down a raise saying "oh, taxes are high so I don't need it", but if additional income involves substantial marginal effort and risk, given high marginal tax it's just not worth it.
- prostoalex 14y agoYep. And if your investment portfolio generates reasonable before-tax return (it should, if you've been working for the past 5+ years and saving diligently), then you get to the marginal rate even quicker.
- smsm42 14y agoNot to mention increase in paperwork once you go beyond simple salary...
- baddox 14y agoHow do you figure? If I have the choice of increasing my labor by 20% (by some arbitrary metric, like labor hours per week) to increase my post-tax income by 20%, I might decide that is worth it and go for the higher income. If, on the other hand, I am currently at the top end of my current tax bracket, and the next highest bracket means that my 20% increase in labor will only increase my post-tax income by 10%, I might decide that isn't worth it and thus not go for the higher income.