5 ms·
"I live in the UK. We've had a variety of different disability benefits over the years. Unfortunately those benefits have not kept current with modern treatment
by mgkimsal 14y ago
"I live in the UK. We've had a variety of different disability benefits over the years. Unfortunately those benefits have not kept current with modern treatment; nor with modern political directions; and now we're in the unpleasant situation of needing to cut our massive welfare bill, but not having any suitable alternatives for people yet, and not having adequate support for disabled people."
One thing that is being tried is more direct scrutiny of people on various disability benefits who are certainly capable of working and caring for themselves, but got 'in' under a more permissive system when the bills weren't as high.
I know this because of some acquaintances I know in the UK who have been on various disability benefits for some years, and they update us on the hoops they're having to jump through to requalify every so often. Keep this up and weed out the people who are capable, so there's more resources to go to those who truly need it.
- DanBC 14y agoThe costs of weeding out the capable are high. Not just financially; you have to interview and assess people who might have severe and enduring mental illness and who might be very anxious about that interview and assessment process. Unfortunately at the moment the assessment, while with a real doctor, is merely a box ticking assessment. You turn up in a clean shirt and tie (because you have a crippling OCD)? You don't get points. You turn up unshaved, unshowered, in an unclean t-shirt? You get points. At the end someone adds up all the points you get. If you get more than X (for physical problems) or more than Y (for MH problems) you get the money, otherwise you're fit to work. Very many people who are deemed fit to work go on to win their appeals. And that's the fundamental problem. Is a wheelchair user able to work? Obviously, yes, there are many jobs someone in a wheelchair can do. Is a person who is totally blind able to work? Again, yes, there are many jobs that person could do. It's the same for people with mental illness; they might be able to work in a quiet office but not do anything customer-facing. The might be able to do many jobs, but need a bit of help to get those jobs. Moving people off disability (disabled and not working; (we also have "cover extra costs of living because you're disabled benefits which get paid if you're in work or not)) benefits probably just moves them onto different benefits. They might still qualify for housing benefit and tax credits; the person caring for them might qualify for carer's benefit; etc. Benefits and Tax in the UK is a mess. :-(
- mgkimsal 14y agoI don't think the situation is as bad in the US, but the fundamental issue of "getting paid benefits to not work" has rarely been balanced on any useful scale with a system that says "are you working already? here are some useful support services?" (child care, medical, extra cash, etc). We seem to only have systems that provide benefits/services to people who don't work at all. Going back 20+ years, I worked (at a burger king!) with someone who ended up quitting because it was 'better' for her to be on our state's welfare program. Why? If she worked, and earned more than (IIRC $120/week or something) then she would lose all her benefits, which added up to far more than she could buy on the $120/week she might earn working at BK. What struck me then that would make far more sense is to offer a sliding scale of benefits, but phase them out if you didn't work at all. She could have stayed working at BK at, say, $120/week, and in return received another $100 in benefits, have been far better off, but instead, the system deemed it better to have her earning nothing, and living off the state for $150/week. My numbers are probably off some - it's been 20 years since we had that conversation, but it was one of the first times it struck me how backwards our regulations and policies are. It's not gotten any better in those intervening 20 years.
- Retric 14y agoIt's a problem of perverse incentives. Intelligent single people without heath issues can live vary cheaply most of the US. But, covering your basis when things go wrong is expensive and many people will intelligently avoid that if there is any sort of a safety net. Especially when just heath insurance costs you more than rent or food. On the other hand, if you want to be self sufficient both now and in retirement you need to make around 50% more. So, where is the break even point?
- atsaloli 14y agoDiagnosis of mental illness is done by interview. There is no objective lab test demonstrating a "biochemical imbalance" in the brain. Diagnosis is subjective.
- DanBC 14y ago