7 ms·
"This is not to say that we should disobey all constitutional commands. Freedom of speech and religion, equal protection of the laws and protections against gov
by greenyoda 14y ago
"This is not to say that we should disobey all constitutional commands. Freedom of speech and religion, equal protection of the laws and protections against governmental deprivation of life, liberty or property are important, whether or not they are in the Constitution. We should continue to follow those requirements out of respect, not obligation.
Nor should we have a debate about, for instance, how long the president's term should last or whether Congress should consist of two houses. Some matters are better left settled, even if not in exactly the way we favor."
So the author is advocating for an arbitrary system in which we decide in ad-hoc ways which parts of the Constitution we want to follow. Unfortunately, this already seems to be happening, as our government sees fit to disregard various provisions of the Bill of Rights, e.g., warrantless wiretapping, or the President's assertion that he can dispatch drones to kill even US citizens without due process.[1] It seems that the government proves to us every day that it needs the Constitution to keep it on a short leash.
Since the Constitution contains a process by which it can be amended, why don't we just follow that? Over the years, amendments have given us some very fundamental changes: the abolition of slavery, the right of women to vote, presidential term limits, etc. Granted, it's a slow process that the author may be impatient with, but it's probably preferable to having a government that can arbitrarily dispose of people's rights.
[1] https://ssl1.washingtonpost.com/opinions/obamas-kill-list-is-unchecked-presidential-power/2012/06/11/gJQAHw05WV_story.html https://ssl1.washingtonpost.com/opinions/obamas-kill-list-is...
- w1ntermute 14y agoIt's not like the president violating the Constitution is a new thing. Didn't Lincoln limit freedom of speech and disregard habeaus corpus for Confederate sympathizers?
- hakaaak 14y agoThe more laws are bent and disregarded, the less any law (not just those laws) will be followed. Ask any parent. I think that we may be better off if those that are willing to give up all power to the government to disregard the constitution would just run their own country, and leave the rest of us out of it. For someone that writes for an organization that makes its living off of the 1st amendment to advocate throwing out that which provides it that 1st amendment is moronic at best, and suicidal and murderous of a free press and a free people at worst.
- learc83 14y agoExactly. How many times has the supreme court struck down laws because they violated the first amendment? I'm not OK with giving congress unlimited authority to do whatever they please. Edit: A quick search shows a total of 1,315 laws have been declared unconstitutional by the supreme court. And countless laws weren't passed in the first place because legislators were aware that they would eventually be overturned.
- mtgx 14y agoThat sounds like a lot. Shouldn't US have the Supreme Court verify laws for constitutionality as soon as they pass Congress, like it happens in other countries?
- ProCynic 14y agoFirst someone who is affected by the law has to challenge it, then the challenge has to make its way through the appeals process until it reaches the level below the supreme court, and then finally the supreme court must decide to take up the case. It's a fairly involved process that only ever gets applied to a small fraction of laws. But the filtering process tends to select laws of questionable constitutionality, so it's fairly inevitable for something like the ACA to end up there. Though it helps to have a powerful interested party pushing a case through the process.
- legutierr 14y ago"The privilege of the Writ of Habeas Corpus shall not be suspended, unless when in Cases of Rebellion or Invasion the public Safety may require it." What Lincoln did was constitutional.
- rmc 14y agoMany constitutions allow suspension of many rights in times of war or things like that. You just have to be careful though, cause that's how Germany became a totalitarian dictatorship.
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoThat was exactly my thought. Who gets to decide which pieces get ignored? A pundit who has his favorite pieces? I agree the laws of the land, and, by extension, the Constitution, need to be altered to reflect the times; but an ad hoc method is not the right way. An ad hoc method simply means the people with the most power get to decide, something the Founders were decidedly trying to prevent. One of the greatest accomplishments of the Founders was the recognized the need to change with the times and laid a foundation for it. As a country, we just seem to be too (lazy?) to follow the guidance.
- hakaaak 14y agoIt isn't laziness. Change is disruptive. Disruption during instability (such as the economic condition of our country, political instability due to polarized nearly 50/50 political split of the people) is dangerous. But more importantly, estabilished lobbying powers inherently tend to equalize change unless one or more become significantly stronger and change the balance of power. And if those lobbying powers are not in favor of the change, it won't happen. Finally, change can lead to a great deal of uncertainty. Uncertainty is risk, and risk is typically bad when it comes to politics. Amendments to the constitution could happen of course, but this would be an unlikely time for them. It is more likely that the interpretation of the constitution would change. And that has changed very much over time.
- lucian303 14y agoIt's not laziness, it's willful ignorance. Much worse.
- lucian303 14y agoSeriously. Ad hoc methods are for querying RDBMSs not for governing people.
- csense 14y ago> As a country, we just seem to be too (lazy?) to [amend the Constitution] The problem with passing Constitutional amendments right now is the highly partisan political climate of the last decade or two: The parties divide nearly fifty-fifty and often define themselves by their opposition to the other party. Many of the most commonly raised ideas for amendments -- getting rid of the death penalty, legalizing gay marriage, abolishing the Second Amendment -- are deeply divisive issues among the people. These factors make it very difficult for anyone to get the big majority necessary for a Constitutional amendment. Changes in US party politics will ultimately be forced by demographics. Minorities are increasing due to higher birth rates and immigration. The baby boomers will eventually start dying. Society as a whole is becoming more secular, especially among the young. Either the Republican party will redefine itself in order to steal some categories of currently Democratic voters, a new party will rise to prominence, or (IMHO the most likely scenario) when the Republican party ceases to be a threat to Democrats' political agendas in ~10-40 years, the Democrats will themselves collapse. The fault lines are already there: Liberals like Obama favor massive spending on ambitious social programs. Civil libertarians -- there seem to be quite a few here on HN -- want a reduced government presence and an expansion of individual rights. Centrists like Bill Clinton aren't opposed to overseas military intervention and support balanced budgets and the reform of social programs. It's easy to see this coalition disintegrating without the pressure presented by their current common political foe, the Republican party.