3 ms·
>So on an airplane, if there are tens or hundreds of devices, you get a real mass of interfering signals. I'd wager large and ridiculous amounts of cash that m
by Karunamon 14y ago
>So on an airplane, if there are tens or hundreds of devices, you get a real mass of interfering signals.
I'd wager large and ridiculous amounts of cash that many people just stash their devices without actually turning them "off" or into any kind of "airplane mode".
So where's this danger?
What about devices that don't have an "off"? I've gotten into more than one argument (and nearly ejected from a plane) over a Kindle, since even when "off" there's still text on the screen. It took the words of about 4 other passengers to convince the FA she needs to educate herself about e-ink.
The ire here is because the FAA's rules have no intelligence behind them.
"Electromagnetic interference"
Science doesn't add up. Try again.
"Distraction"
You don't stop people from reading books.
"Danger in case of turbulence or sudden movement"
Again you don't stop people from reading books.
I, and a great deal more air travellers, would have more respect for the rules if they showed the slightest inkling of having any kind of common sense or conistency to them. When a five year old can point out something wrong with your rule, you are doing it wrong.
- dalore 14y agoOk books are now banned. Are you happy?
- Karunamon 14y agoAt least then they'd be consistent. If the rule were something like "Your hands must be empty during taxi, takeoff, and landing", that could be defended as ensuring attentiveness and reducing the chance of random crap being thrown about the cabin in case of sudden movement. Not gonna happen, though. The FAA's constant waffling on the reasons has completely annihilated any respect anyone might have ever had for the rule.
- wglb 14y ago>The ire here is because the FAA's rules have no intelligence behind them. Well, I suggest that the ire is more that "I think the rule is ridiculous and I want to use my device anyway." They do have intelligence behind them in the form of raw physics. >Science doesn't add up. Try again. Sorry, but science does in fact add up. Radio signals are important for an airplane to navigate. iPads and other PEDs can cause interference. How do you explain that to the typical passenger? Perhaps they take a different tack to get the different behavior.
- Karunamon 14y ago>Radio signals are important for an airplane to navigate. iPads and other PEDs can cause interference. Science does not work that way. Where is the proof of any such interference being caused on an average plane? You mean the FAA couldn't organize some kind of test of cellphones given 10+ years to do so? Why aren't the devices that already exist and are already transmitting not causing harmful interference? (And if you don't think they exist, I've got this bridge...)
- DanBC 14y ago> How do you explain that to the typical passenger? You get some video cameras and start filming. You take some avionic displays. You take a bunch of cell phones and iPads. You turn the cell phones on, do some normal activities, and record the distortions to the avionics devices. You then show that video to passengers. I believe that pre-GSM analogue phones probably caused considerable interference. And, because they are not close to cell towers modern GSM phones will switch to highest-power mode to get a better signal. Having a couple of hundred of those phones bunched up together in a plane might cause problems. Listen to the burbling noise you get with a phone near any radio. (And the electronics are not all in the pilot's cabin - there's stuff all over aircraft.) But it's obviously controversial, and causes confrontation between bolshy passengers and staff who have no option but to enforce the rule; so if they're going to continue to have the rule they should justify it with science and research and evidence. Do the studies. Show the harm. Publish the results. And if it's not harmful, well, great. Change the regulations and concentrate on all the other stuff that can cause death and destruction.
- DanBC 14y ago> What about devices that don't have an "off"? I've gotten into more than one argument (and nearly ejected from a plane) over a Kindle, since even when "off" there's still text on the screen. Push and hold the button for at least 4 (6?) seconds. > It took the words of about 4 other passengers to convince the FA she needs to educate herself about e-ink. What's the equivalent to Skitt's Law when it's not about grammar? (Skitt's Law: "Any post pointing out a mistake in grammar will have an error" (but he wrote it much more elegantly than I have here.)
- Karunamon 14y agoAll that does on mine is cause it to reboot. Might be because it's jailbroken and running funky code.
- DanBC 14y agoThe Kindle has 3 modes. "On"; "asleep"; and "off". It can receives stuff wirelessly while "on" or "asleep". It also has an airplane mode. > Power switch — puts your Kindle to sleep, wakes it up, and turns your Kindle on or off. The power switch is located just to the right of the micro-USB/power port. To put your Kindle to sleep, slide and release the power switch; the screensaver appears on the display. While your Kindle is asleep, other keys and buttons are locked so that you don’t accidentally change the place in your reading. For Kindle with Special Offers, the center of the 5-way controller is not locked while your Kindle is asleep. To turn your Kindle off, slide and hold the power switch for seven seconds until the screen goes blank and then release. To wake up or turn on your Kindle, slide and release the power switch again. If you have set up a device password, you will be prompted to enter the password after turning on your Kindle or waking it from sleep. > If your Kindle does not power on or is unresponsive during use, try resetting the device by sliding and holding the power switch for 15 seconds before releasing. > Might be because it's jailbroken and running funky code Well, that's awkward. The FA must enforce the regulations; you don't want to say anything like "modified electronic device" or you risk being taken off the plane at gunpoint and detained in a room while big men with rubber gloves search every orifice. I do agree that the rules are annoying as heck.