4 ms·
the traditional corporate model is dictatorship Huh? The traditional corporate model is representative democracy. Shareholders elect a board of directors who t
by yummyfajitas 14y ago
the traditional corporate model is dictatorship
Huh? The traditional corporate model is representative democracy. Shareholders elect a board of directors who then elect upper management, who then appoint lower level positions.
Whereas a worker who comes in afterward has no access, and even though they also put in a lot of work, they won't get any ownership.
This is false for any publicly traded corporation. Any worker can open up an ETrade account and trade their salary for part of the corporation.
As far as I know, most workers choose not to. Why do you feel these workers (myself included) are making the wrong choice?
- steveklabnik 14y agoPlease see my statement about broad strokes. That said.... > Shareholders elect There's your error. Shareholders elect. Not workers. Maybe "oligarchy" is a better word than dictatorship, but as I said, trying to keep it simple to get the concept across. Workers do not have a vote. Traditional corporate structures are not a democracy. > This is false for any publicly traded corporation. Any worker can open up an ETrade account and trade their salary for part of the corporation. Only if that company is publicly traded. Even then, if it is, acquiring ownership comes through spending capital, not by virtue of having control over yourself and what you do. > As far as I know, most workers choose not to. Why do you feel these workers (myself included) are making the wrong choice? Most people do not have the ability to work in a place that's run cooperatively because there aren't enough places that are cooperative. Even GitHub and Valve are socialist in social structure only: Both are private companies, but I'm pretty sure that everyone does not own a portion of the company. I could be wrong on this. Secondly, post-Cold War, 'socialism' became such a scare term that people would shy away from it even if it were a rationally better choice for them. The notion of 'ideology' is useful here.
- codewright 14y agoYou don't need the word socialism to make me skeptical, I'm skeptical that democracy would produce better results in a business context. Also, I have a hard time believing you've read any Marx. You're not doing his work very much justice. I don't even trust democracy in politics all that much, my state (California) is a complete and utter failure as an exercise in democracy.
- rdtsc 14y ago> I don't even trust democracy in politics all that much Alright, but what do you trust then? A dictatorship is much better as long as the dictator happens to share the values and vision as you personally.
- codewright 14y ago>Alright, but what do you trust then? Federalized constitutional republics seem to work well. True meritocracy in governance would interest me.
- barry-cotter 14y ago* Federalized constitutional republics seem to work well.* Pfft, you can't generalise that much from just Switzerland.
- codewright 14y agoSwitzerland is not the only nation with this model.
- gruseom 14y agoAlso, I have a hard time believing you've read any Marx. You're not doing his work very much justice. I call foul. That's personal, and it's unsubstantiated, which makes it unfair not only to the GP but to the rest of us reading the thread. If you're going to make a comment like this, instead of being mean why don't you share with us some of what you've learned about (in this case) Marx? I for one would be interested to hear it.
- codewright 14y ago>And the victorious party” (in a revolution) “must maintain its rule by means of the terror which its arms inspire in the reactionaries. Would the Paris Commune have lasted more than a day if it had not used the authority of the armed people against the bourgeoisie? Cannot we, on the contrary, blame it for having made too little use of that authority?. - Engels >As, therefore, the state is only a transitional institution which is used in the struggle, in the revolution, to hold down one’s adversaries by force, it is sheer nonsense to talk of a ‘free people’s state’; so long as the proletariat still needs the state, it does not need it in the interests of freedom but in order to hold down its adversaries, and as soon as it becomes possible to speak of freedom the state as such ceases to exist - Engels Democracy is a threat to the midwife State and the final state of what Marxism aims to achieve.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoOnly if that company is publicly traded. Even then, if it is, acquiring ownership comes through spending capital, not by virtue of having control over yourself and what you do. Would you prefer it if instead workers were paid in equity, and needed to use the public markets if they want to convert equity to cash? (The difference between this scenario and the current status quo is only $8/trade and a few mouse clicks, so I'd love to hear why you think this distinction matters.)
- steveklabnik 14y ago> Would you prefer it if instead workers were paid in equity, and needed to use the public markets if they want to convert equity to cash? No, I would not. > The difference between this scenario and the current status quo is only $8/trade and a few mouse clicks, No, it is not. Again, not all companies are publicly owned. > so I'd love to hear why you think this distinction matters. Cash does not equal control. Equity equals control. Seriously, we're on Hacker News: how much discussion goes into equity splits between founders? Why do you never give your initial employees very much equity? Why do we discuss term sheets so much? You're being silly, you comment here way too much not to know this. (oh, and for an answer: I prefer that the workers are paid however the workers want to be paid. For me, personally, cash as well as an equity stake of some kind. As one real-life example, please see http://www.redandblackcafe.com/the-red-black-cafe-is-hiring/ http://www.redandblackcafe.com/the-red-black-cafe-is-hiring/ which lays out one possible situation and has been going for the last 12 years. Also, of course, http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondragon_Corporation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mondragon_Corporation which has 14b euro in revenue and employs 84,000 people.)
- pretoriusB 14y ago>Would you prefer it if instead workers were paid in equity, and needed to use the public markets if they want to convert equity to cash? No, I would prefer it is instead workers had a say in the workings of the company. Equal say divided between them.
- yummyfajitas 14y agoIf workers were paid in equity, they would have say in the company proportional to the value of their contribution to the company (modulo politics, etc). But what if some workers are willing to give up "say" in the in return for cash? Should they be prevented from doing so? Should employees be paid in restricted stock, receiving cash only when their company issues dividends? Note that as an employee of a public company who doesn't buy any shares, I've revealed that I prefer cash to voice. Why do you feel you know better about how I should handle my finances and working arrangements?