3 ms·
> I think you mean equality trickling down? Yes. You know what I mean, nit-picking ill becomes you. > But absolute wealth certainly does trickle down Not alw
by SideburnsOfDoom 14y ago
> I think you mean equality trickling down?
Yes. You know what I mean, nit-picking ill becomes you.
> But absolute wealth certainly does trickle down
Not always true. There are many counterexamples in the last 100 years, outside of the west.
> I have not talked about innovation being driven by the wealthy
No, but you've talked around it a lot and failed to say something definite. You've said that it is as good as money in the rest of the system; it is not. Resources available to those who might become rich is much better – and this includes schools and hospitals for poor children at the expense of tax.
> Do you dispute my general summary of how the airplane evolved
I don't dispute that you cling to the airplane example as though it was a general law.
> pg makes this point
Pg is not always right. The extreme case of "take away the potential reward" entirely is of course not a good thing. However this straw man argument is much abused in the US at present.
> even though relative inequality of wealth is an effect of innovation, not a cause of it
Nope. What if it's got nothing to do with innovation at all? You see innovation everywhere; but the richest people are mostly not innovators at all, you say as much in the next paragraph. Which I agree with.
- pdonis 14y agoNot always true. Agreed. I didn't mean to imply that it was always true. But the fact is that it does happen, therefore it can happen. There are many counterexamples in the last 100 years, outside of the west. And what makes those cases different from the cases in which it did happen? That seems to me to be a question worth investigating. One hypothesis: "outside of the west", people who aren't wealthy can't become wealthy by innovating, so they don't bother. In "the west", it's not easy to become wealthy by innovating, but it is at least possible. you've talked around it a lot and failed to say something definite I disagree; I've said a number of definite things. I think you are reading some things into my posts that I have not said, and failing to see some things that I have said. I give examples of both below. You've said that it is as good as money in the rest of the system Where did I say that? All I said was that innovation creates new sources of supply, which in turn enables new demand to exist that couldn't exist before. How does that equate to innovation being "as good as money"? Resources available to those who might become rich is much better Agreed; I haven't said anything that contradicts this. you cling to the airplane example as though it was a general law. It's not a general law, because, as I said above, innovation increasing absolute wealth doesn't always happen, and I didn't mean to imply that it did. But the example shows that it can happen. Again, you appear to be reading things into my posts that I didn't actually say. this straw man argument is much abused in the US at present. True, but I wasn't making the straw man argument. In fact I explicitly gave a case in which reducing inequality of wealth does not harm innovation: when the inequality in wealth is due to people gaming the system instead of doing productive work. What if it's got nothing to do with innovation at all? You agreed that "take away the potential reward entirely" is not a good thing; that means you agree that inequality of wealth has something to do with innovation.
- jrs235 14y agoI think it would be safe to say that most people that buy/bought into Reaganomics would say they are Capitalists. Isn't it competition that makes capitalism (and innovation) flourish? So how does reducing competition (via allocating most/more of the resources to those that already have "the most") benefit a capitalist society? Look what happens when a few large companies control an industry. Look at cable/internet companies. Look at wireless carriers. Look at monitor manufacturers. We see collusion to keep prices higher than they "ought" to be and sluggish innovation and growth. The large entities tend to favor more regulations that increase the barriers of entry to competitors (but vocally saying they dislike regulations... bs.) Comfortable people tend to favor the status quo, dislike shake ups, and don't want to have "work" to maintain their condition.
- pdonis 14y agoIsn't it competition that makes capitalism (and innovation) flourish? I would agree that competition helps innovation to flourish. I'm not so sure about capitalism, because the word "capitalism" can mean different things. Concentrating resources in the hands of a few large corporations can be viewed as "capitalism"; that's how the robber barons in the late 19th century in the US viewed it. There is also government interference involved (as you imply with your comment about regulations). For example, those same robber barons did not make their money through fair competition; they made it by getting the government to outlaw fair competition, for example by handing out exclusive rights to run railroads through various parts of the country. Similar remarks apply to some of the other examples you give--cable/internet companies, for example, are largely local government-granted monopolies. (Wireless carriers are too, to an extent--for example, Verizon has an exclusive deal to put repeaters in the Washington, DC Metro tunnels, so their phones can get a signal but nobody else's can. Result: lots more commuters have Verizon phones.)