3 ms·
"On average 200 people lose their lives on the New York City subway, a year. Surely the cost of erecting these barriers is worth less than those souls lost." T
by greenyoda 14y ago
"On average 200 people lose their lives on the New York City subway, a year. Surely the cost of erecting these barriers is worth less than those souls lost."
This doesn't sound right. I live in NYC, and people getting killed by trains is generally a newsworthy event. It's not something that one hears about every couple of days, as would be the case if it happened to 200 people every year. Also, for the fraction of these deaths that are suicides (which probably far exceed the number of people being deliberately pushed), building barriers on the platforms will not save these people's lives, since there are many alternate ways of committing suicide.
The NYC subway has 468 stations[1], with the larger ones (e.g., Times Square) having a dozen or more platforms. Add to that the commuter rail lines (e.g., LIRR, PATH, Metro North) and you have even more (Penn Station and Grand Central are huge). It would probably cost billions of dollars to build gates on every platform. These billions of dollars could probably save many more than 200 lives a year if, for example, they were spent on improving the health of poor children in NYC. (But in any case, the city doesn't have billions of extra dollars lying around.)
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_City_Subway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_City_Subway