3 ms·
Oh, it's "Oversimplify as a form of argument"! I love this game!
by sliverstorm 14y ago
Oh, it's "Oversimplify as a form of argument"! I love this game!
- baddox 14y agoPlease, reveal to me the hidden complexity that makes all of those government actions okay.
- tedunangst 14y agoThe government hasn't killed tens of thousands of civilians with nuclear weapons since the founding of Facebook, so I think they're tied in that regard.
- sliverstorm 14y agoI'm not even bothering with "justified or not" yet, I'm noting things like this: used the money TO kill children "To" in this context implies "for the express purpose of". It may not have been your intention to do this, but it is a great example of why simplification of arguments is problematic- intentional or not, in the process of simplifying the issue you completely misrepresented the character of the issue. (Unless it is in fact your stance that the government's express purpose w/ the "War on Terror" was the killing of children)
- baddox 14y agoI did not mean that money is used for the express purpose of killing children. I only meant that money is used to buy weapons which are used in a manner that accepts a certain level of collateral damage, which can and has included children.