3 ms·
How is paying $2/hr for the cleaning of the room harming no one? It is more complicated than direct and immediate harm, but (if you subscribe to modern economic
by sliverstorm 14y ago
How is paying $2/hr for the cleaning of the room harming no one? It is more complicated than direct and immediate harm, but (if you subscribe to modern economic models) it does indeed result in economic harm.
- natrius 14y agoThere are jobs that are illegal because the highest price people are willing to pay for them is lower than the minimum wage. The potential buyers and sellers of those services would not be harmed if they were legal—they would benefit.
- sliverstorm 14y agoWho benefits when you establish a class of people working for $2/hr? Last I checked that's $4,000/year, which puts you solidly in poverty.
- natrius 14y agoThis argument isn't going to go anywhere novel. The point is that such policies help some impoverished people make more, but they make other impoverished people make less.
- tedunangst 14y agoPeople currently making $0/hr?
- spindritf 14y agoThis argument can easily be extended to people's actions in the bedroom when no money is being exchanged. They can lead to pregnancy, spread of STDs, violence... and yet, I imagine, almost everyone supporting the minimal wage would vehemently oppose regulation of sexual activities by, for example, only allowing married couples to engage in them. Right? No one here thinks that we should limit single motherhood by banning extramarital sexual relationships? Or the spread of HIV through anti-sodomy laws? EDIT: OK, maybe I didn't write that clearly but both low wages and sex can lead to negative externalities. Why one should be strictly regulated and the other protected from any regulation?
- sliverstorm 14y agoWait, I thought the reference to "bedroom activities" was about homosexuality and/or general deviancy.
- Karunamon 14y agoBecause the attempts to regulate sex are not based on some desire to reduce pregnancy and the spread of STDs, but are rather religious control over private life dressed up in friendlier colors. Nobody has ever seriously attempted legislating away sex.