3 ms·
When's the last time Facebook took 30% of your paycheck and used the money to kill children on the other side of the globe with remotely controlled airplanes? W
by baddox 14y ago
When's the last time Facebook took 30% of your paycheck and used the money to kill children on the other side of the globe with remotely controlled airplanes? When's the last time Facebook broke down someone's door and shot them and/or their dog because they had reportedly been burning the wrong type of plant? When's the last time Facebook used its clandestine paramilitary force to overthrow a democratically elected government and install a puppet dictator? When's the last time Facebook targeted and killed tens if thousands of civilians with conventional or nuclear weapons?
- sliverstorm 14y agoOh, it's "Oversimplify as a form of argument"! I love this game!
- baddox 14y agoPlease, reveal to me the hidden complexity that makes all of those government actions okay.
- tedunangst 14y agoThe government hasn't killed tens of thousands of civilians with nuclear weapons since the founding of Facebook, so I think they're tied in that regard.
- sliverstorm 14y agoI'm not even bothering with "justified or not" yet, I'm noting things like this: used the money TO kill children "To" in this context implies "for the express purpose of". It may not have been your intention to do this, but it is a great example of why simplification of arguments is problematic- intentional or not, in the process of simplifying the issue you completely misrepresented the character of the issue. (Unless it is in fact your stance that the government's express purpose w/ the "War on Terror" was the killing of children)
- baddox 14y agoI did not mean that money is used for the express purpose of killing children. I only meant that money is used to buy weapons which are used in a manner that accepts a certain level of collateral damage, which can and has included children.
- loceng 14y agoI'll engage with you if you make a reply stating the opposite, the good things that government can/do provide, even if could be done better - just to make sure I'm not wasting time.
- baddox 14y agoIt would be ridiculous to deny that government does solve some problems in society. My issue is with using violence to solve those problems, and I believe nonviolent solutions are just as ample and strictly more effective.