4 ms·
> Your protections against your government really have never been stronger. Assuming you're talking about the USA, that is one of the more ludicrous claims I h
by baddox 14y ago
> Your protections against your government really have never been stronger.
Assuming you're talking about the USA, that is one of the more ludicrous claims I have read in a long time.
- rayiner 14y agoYes, in the U.S. your protections against your government have never been stronger. The idea that we've seen a "chipping away" of liberties over time is an uneducated trope. In the 1940s, we indefinitely detained, without review, American citizens of Japanese descent on U.S. soil, and the Supreme Court upheld the action. In the 2000's, we tried to detain non-U.S. citizens captured in Afghanistan on a military base that wasn't even on U.S. soil, and the Supreme Court smacked down the administration three different times and the detainees all got lawyers. The habeas jurisdiction of federal courts, which is the safeguard we have against the detention of American citizens, has never been stronger in the history of the country than it is today.
- tptacek 14y agoNote well that you do not have to be O.K. with what happened in Guantanamo Bay or with how the civil courts are used by the RIAA or how the CFAA is used against hackers to maintain the perspective that your rights in 2012 are stronger than they've ever been in recent memory. I tend to assume that people with alarmist stances about online rights aren't old enough to remember that the Clinton administration attempted to criminalize encryption.
- pretoriusB 14y ago>In the 2000's, we tried to detain non-U.S. citizens captured in Afghanistan on a military base that wasn't even on U.S. soil, and the Supreme Court smacked down the administration three different times and the detainees all got lawyers. Meanwhile, despite all the theatre, the same prison still operates and the same kind of things keep happening there. So on top of the very same things we had in 1940s, we also have a "theatre show" about right nowadays. So, the same, plus hypocrisy. This is supposed to be good? You also forgot tons of other ways people are not protected against the government (from the Patriot Act, to warantless wiretaps, to mass electronic surveillance of mail and web activity, etc) that didn't exist in the past. Oh, and as for that 40's example? That was at a time of OPEN WAR, with hundreds of thousands of American _common_ citizens fighting, and big domestic consequences to the USA. Nowadays Iraq and co are run like private wars, with the professional army and private contractors, that have little impact on the country (except the expense and some casualties of professional troops), which people only ever care about for ethical reasons. What would have happened to civil rights if the US was actually involved in a war of the WWII scale and impact is not something anybody can describe.