3 ms·
Ahh, we're getting somewhere. Slowly. Not much progress on the ad-hominems, but so be it. Now that we've debunked the claim that Krugman's assertion is "lite
by mpweiher 14y ago
Ahh, we're getting somewhere. Slowly. Not much progress on the ad-hominems, but so be it.
Now that we've debunked the claim that Krugman's assertion is "literally" false, we can concentrate on whether it ("government debt is not like family debt") is BS.
(By the way, thanks for filling me in on taxes being a derivative of earnings; there I was using "debt-to-GDP ratios" all this time without a clue as to what those strange words meant!)
First, of course, is the question of what Krugman is advocating. Is it simply defaulting on the debt? No. In fact: "So yes, debt matters. But right now, other things matter more".
What are those other matters? Exactly the "underlying asset class" you mention. Governments can spend money on either the numerator (debt) or denominator (GDP) to improve the debt-to-GDP ratio, families rarely have that option (spending money tends to not lead to raises, unless you live in Baku).
Greece for example has tried reducing their debt by cutting spending (so far with limited success), with the side-effect of putting the economy into deep recession (+free street entertainment) and actually making the debt-to-gdp ratio much, much worse, now at 170% of GDP:
http://www.tradingeconomics.com/greece/government-debt-to-gdp http://www.tradingeconomics.com/greece/government-debt-to-gd...
The other possibly immediate problem with debt is interest rates, but so far that just doesn't seem to be a problem, with rates sub 1%. In fact, with rates this low one might consider it negligent to not use those rates for investments with even modest ROI.
- 001sky 14y agoNow that we've debunked the claim that Krugman's assertion is "literally" false No, its literally false. You haven't "debunked" anything. Honestly, if you don't understand any of this I cannot help you, further.
- mpweiher 14y ago"it is" -> "it's" ("its" is the possessive) What Krugman said is literally true (he gives examples in the article, I have given others). And the actual point that he makes about the relative nature of the debt and thus the question for governments as to wether to work on the numerator or the denominator is one that you yourself brought up, unprompted. Finally, his biggest point (AFAICT) is that this is debt that is largely internal, therefore it doesn't actually make the country poorer. In fact, you brought up pension funds: these actually have a big problem when there isn't any "safe" government debt to invest in. Heck, they are actually starting to get into trouble now, with the yields of that government debt so incredibly low (recent emissions of Danish and German debt had negative interest rates, so you paid some money to the government for holding onto your money for a while).
- 001sky 14y agoIf you're not trained in economics, or experienced in finance, it is best to assume--based on your comments-- you have no idea what you are talking about. Reading the op-ed pages of the NY times, unfortunately, does not give you either the information or perspective to judge the games Krugman is playing. If you do have this kind of training and this is what you got out of it, it seems you didn't get your money's worth or you have a vested interest in polishing someones ego. But there is nothing original, insightful, or discriminatory in anything you have written in this thread. Which is pretty typical of Krugman's supporters.
- mpweiher 14y agoWell, at least you are consistent, sticking to the ad-hominems and staying well clear of any kind of substantive support for your silly little claims.
- 001sky 14y agoSo far your best comment? Argument ad-hominem is, of course, not indicative of falacy. On the contrary, it is quite usefully devastaing. You can consult wikipedia. Or Neitszche. But I'll leave it to you to do the work.
- mpweiher 14y agoNo, my best comments were where I demolished everything you'd actually said point by point using these things called...wait...ah yes: facts! You may have heard of the concept in passing somewhere. Or not. Wikipedia: "Ad hominem reasoning is normally described as an informal fallacy,[2][3][4] more precisely an irrelevance." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ad_hominem Yep, you're right about that, too. It's really not a falacy. It's a fallacy. And also Nietzsche, not Neitszche. And devastating, not devastaing. As to devastating ad hominems: I'd suggest they might become a trifle more devastating if you start with elementary spelling, work your way up via basic grammar ("its" vs "it's") and simple word semantics such as "quote" and "plagiarism" all the way to reading comprehension before attempting to tackle economics and philosophy. Just sayin'