5 ms·
Yeah. I find it odd that despite Apple winning the world-championship in patent-trolling and is leading the fight for closed systems and walled gardens, FSF sti
by josteink 14y ago
Yeah. I find it odd that despite Apple winning the world-championship in patent-trolling and is leading the fight for closed systems and walled gardens, FSF still decides to go after anyone but Apple.
Despite this tarnished image of a former tech-innovist, does the FSF really still feel it's impossible to fight the root evil here because of public perception?
Is it only picking on Microsoft because that is easier to amass support against?
We, as hackers and developers, should support this. We should fight closed systems. We should fight against the forces against general purpose computing (Cory Doctorow has a nice speach on this) and we should fight those who seek to criminalize writing code because somewhere some troll has a vague patent with no implementation covering your work.
So yes. Support the FSF on this. But also boycot those who are the chief offenders here. Every dollar spent in an Apple-store is money spent against the core of your profession. Stop spending money there. And throw away your iPhones and Macbooks. They are bad karma and software blood-money.
- mtgx 14y agoI agree FSF should fight against Apple, too, and even though they would make a lot of enemies because of it, I think making a lot of enemies this way and becoming that controversial is a lot better than being obscure, because in the same time they'd be gaining a lot of allies, too. I think FSF fighting against Apple's closed policies would ultimately make them more popular and help them. That being said I don't really think that not naming Apple right now, which already has an established closed platform (therefore uphill battle), detracts from them trying to stop Windows 8 machines becoming as closed as iPads before they even get a chance to take off the ground. Better (and easier) to kill off a bad idea early on.
- cooldeal 14y ago>..trying to stop Windows 8 machines becoming as closed as iPads before they even get a chance to take off the ground. Better (and easier) to kill off a bad idea early on. Huh? Where can I access the option on an iPad to turn off secure boot or to add my own keys or to delete Apple's? Windows 8 machines are much much more open than an iPad.
- throwaway2048 14y agoThe ability to disable secure boot only applies to x86, and even there your stance has issues. I wish people would stop repeating this like its some kind of iron clad gaurentee, Microsoft only changed the reqirement to begin with after there was a public outcry, and are free to change it again any time. (they likely will after more systems support secure boot) also please consider the fact that how you should be able to disable secure boot is entirely unspecified. If early models are any indication, its going to be buggy and error prone on tons of systems.
- kryptiskt 14y ago> Better (and easier) to kill off a bad idea early on. Yeah, so they should have gone on an all out offensive when the iPad launched. Now there's a huge precedent they will have to try to explain away, why it doesn't apply and Microsoft's stuff have to be open but not their competitors'.
- sliverstorm 14y agoWhat do you think the chances are Apple has some "influence" in the FSF?
- markrages 14y agoApple and the FSF have long had an antagonistic relationship. Some history in this talk: http://www.ebb.org/bkuhn/talks/LinuxTag-2011/compliance.html http://www.ebb.org/bkuhn/talks/LinuxTag-2011/compliance.html
- sliverstorm 14y agoOK, wasn't aware.
- mistercow 14y agoThere are a lot of negative things that you can say about Richard Stallman, but to suggest that he or his organization might be in anybody's pocket is simply preposterous.
- sliverstorm 14y agoI didn't realize it was "his"
- mistercow 14y agoHe's the founder and president, and they have a staff of 10, so yeah, it's his.
- 14y ago
- danieldk 14y agoWe should fight against the forces against general purpose computing I have very mixed feelings about this very topic. As a developer, I completely agree with you. Hardware should be hackable and software replaceable. But there's also another side: computing has become a lot easier for the average user. E.g. the iPhone and the iPad were the first computers that my mother really grasped and was able to use comfortably on her own. The limited walled garden approach to computing ensures that she doesn't accidentally install malware, etc. In the end, I think the secure, walled gardens are useful to the average user. Of course, the inherent danger is unfair competition - the gatekeeper can decide to reject software whenever it wants and impose fees and crazy rules. Since in EU, we are not completely adverse to government intervention, I think it is best that the European union would regulate such walled gardens, e.g. by limiting the percentage that the gatekeeper can charge, by requiring that the gatekeeper accepts all software that is not malicious, and requiring that a method should be required to unlock hardware. I that putting think such regulations into place will be much more effective than fighting windmills.
- mtgx 14y agoI think that argument is bogus. Having a way to sideload apps in your device or being able to install a different OS, doesn't make grandma more likely to get malware. It's the same model Apple is using in Mac OS X, too, now. Grandma will still use the same OS, and will still install apps from the app store, never knowing that she can even install apps from other places, and it will be just as easy as it if were without that sideloading option. Having the option to do other things doesn't interfere with any of that. And even if it does change things a little in some extreme cases - but everything has its positive and negative sides. Everything. At the end of the day you have to decide which gives the greater benefit. And I think having "open" computing systems over completely closed ones, offers the greater benefit in the long term, just like having an open (also could be read as malware-filled, and cybercriminals-filled) Internet in the end if is of much greater benefit than having one fully controlled by the government and companies.
- SoftwareMaven 14y agoNow compare the difference in malware between OS X and Android. There appears to be a correlation between how easy it is to circumvent the walls and the amount of malware within the garden. I'd love to see some real research on causality here, though, because correlation obviously doesn't imply causation (though it is a reasonable hypothesis, IMO).
- rimantas 14y ago> Every dollar spent in an Apple-store is money spent > against the core of your profession. Bullshit. Every dollar I spent on Apple was spent on top quality product which made me more productive. I also spend a considerable amount on App Store paying my colleagues for their work. > Stop spending money > there. And throw away your iPhones and Macbooks. They are > bad karma and software blood-money. Even more bullshit. You know why FSF avoid fighting Apple? It's because that fight would reveal that they are fighting in the wrong war. Not everybody in the world should be a doctor, a car mechanic, IT technician, or developer. It is so sad to see so many otherwise smart people failing to realise this.
- Karunamon 14y ago>Every dollar I spent on Apple was spent on top quality product which made me more productive. And also spent on patent trolling, stifling innovation, and leading the world of tech down a dark path (locked down "app store", restricted boot, the whole nine yards). How does it feel to know your money will go directly to the cause of stopping the evolution of technology in its tracks? Your view is terrifically selfish if nothing else. >You know why FSF avoid fighting Apple? It's because that fight would reveal that they are fighting in the wrong war. Please explain.
- sigzero 14y agoStallman is that you?
- winter_blue 14y ago> Every dollar spent in an Apple-store is money spent against the core of your profession. Stop spending money there. And throw away your iPhones and Macbooks. They are bad karma and software blood-money. The key problem for mobile app developers is the rampant piracy on Android. iOS has nowhere as much piracy as Android. In this case, economics will dictate where app developers sell, will it not? What we really need is a type of DRM that still permits general purpose computing. A safe way to store proprietary binary data (programs, media, etc) on the system in such a way the user cannot access it. This might mean restricting root, but it will mean goodbye to piracy. We could still give the user maximum power over the system in every way possible (allow him to install his own apps, access to most APIs, etc.)
- lucian1900 14y agoAny DRM by definition tries to keep a general purpose computer from being general (i.e. performing any task). There's not much more piracy on Android than iOS, and it doesn't matter anyway.
- winter_blue 14y ago> There's not much more piracy on Android than iOS, and it doesn't matter anyway. Can you back that up?
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- mlinksva 14y agoFSF campaigns against Apple plenty. https://www.fsf.org/search?SearchableText=apple https://www.fsf.org/search?SearchableText=apple The banner at the top of every page currently says "Giants like Microsoft and Apple are trying harder than ever to control the software you use. The FSF brings software freedom supporters together to amplify your voices and make an impact."