8 ms·
Why Are People More Scared of Facebook Violating Their Privacy than Washington?
- loceng 14y agoIt's more annoying what Facebook does. Washington isn't showing pictures or information to our friends that we don't want them to see. It's assumed I imagine by most that the 'spying' into our activities is done for our safety - this can of course very quickly be turned against us, and abused.
- vaadu 14y agoFacebook may be more annoying but what the political ruling class in Washington is doing is far worse. I don't have a FB account because I value my personal security. I have this choice. With the government there's only the Hobson’s choice of moving out of the country. I foresee the government slowly ratcheting any remaining privacy out of existence. - Obamacare is stripping off all medical privacy. - Patriot act has stripped all financial privacy. - Cameras are being installed in public places at an alarming rate tracking all of our movements. - Obama gave the National Counterterrorism Center the authority to collect any and all data from anywhere. No warrants necessary. - Indefinite detention without trial, even of US citizens. What’s left? This is a Stasi wet dream.
- mmariani 14y agoAll people want is to be safe. In order to do whatever they want, the powers that be need to feed fear to people. An enemy that threatens people's safety is needed, found, and fought. Whatever the cost is, people can feel safe again. You're going to see this pattern throughout history. The question is... What comes next?
- rayiner 14y agoNone of those things are even remotely true, but I don't see how pointing out the facts is going to dissuade you from believing conspiracy theories.
- mahyarm 14y agoYour coping out. Put out your sources.
- baddox 14y agoWhen's the last time Facebook took 30% of your paycheck and used the money to kill children on the other side of the globe with remotely controlled airplanes? When's the last time Facebook broke down someone's door and shot them and/or their dog because they had reportedly been burning the wrong type of plant? When's the last time Facebook used its clandestine paramilitary force to overthrow a democratically elected government and install a puppet dictator? When's the last time Facebook targeted and killed tens if thousands of civilians with conventional or nuclear weapons?
- sliverstorm 14y agoOh, it's "Oversimplify as a form of argument"! I love this game!
- baddox 14y agoPlease, reveal to me the hidden complexity that makes all of those government actions okay.
- tedunangst 14y agoThe government hasn't killed tens of thousands of civilians with nuclear weapons since the founding of Facebook, so I think they're tied in that regard.
- sliverstorm 14y agoI'm not even bothering with "justified or not" yet, I'm noting things like this: used the money TO kill children "To" in this context implies "for the express purpose of". It may not have been your intention to do this, but it is a great example of why simplification of arguments is problematic- intentional or not, in the process of simplifying the issue you completely misrepresented the character of the issue. (Unless it is in fact your stance that the government's express purpose w/ the "War on Terror" was the killing of children)
- baddox 14y ago
- berkay 14y agoBetter question where are all the mighty constitution defenders that go nuts over gun control? Congress just crapped all over the constitution with FISA (4th amendment) and with NAtional defense authorization act (5th amendment) in the name of national security. Yet often the same people oppose any type of gun control citing government tyranny. How does this make any sense? Dazed and confused.
- harold 14y agoHang on there. If you're going to count amendments crapped on by congress, at least count it on both sides. A lot of Obama supporters here on HN seem to be hesitant to call him out, but I'm going to. None of the bad stuff you cite congress as doing could have happened without the co-operation of Obama and a senate controlled by Democrats. They are all crapping on our rights. http://www.ibtimes.com/obama-expected-sign-fisa-amendments-acts-extending-warrantless-wiretapping-americans-977318 http://www.ibtimes.com/obama-expected-sign-fisa-amendments-a... http://investorplace.com/investorpolitics/what-obama-slipped-by-us-on-new-years-eve/ http://investorplace.com/investorpolitics/what-obama-slipped...
- berkay 14y agoWhat part of my comment blames one side? I fully agree that democrats are to be blamed for FISA and NDAA just as much as republicans, if not more. If and when Obama signs them into law, he will share the blame as well. He has been consistently missing in action or on the wrong side on these issues. But my main point is not the congress but the public, media, etc. there is very strong defense of second amendment yet fourth and fifth gets dumped on and it's hardly noticed. I consider these changes as much bigger threats to liberty than ability to have guns, and perplexed that this view is not more widely shared.
- tedunangst 14y agoWhen the government reads your email in some underground bunker 2000 miles away, you don't know about it. When the government comes to confiscate your guns, you damn well do know about it.
- easyfrag 14y agoI guess it's because theoretically the government is accountable to its citizens whereas Facebook is accountable to its shareholders, the citizen can exert some action against Washington via the democratic process, they have no action to take against Facebook other than not participating at all. There's also the question of motive, Facebook exists to make money and there's the fear that the profit motive may outweigh its users privacy. The government can and has defended its actions in the context of keeping people safe. I'm not defending any actions by Facebook or government, just trying to point out the differences. What I'm more interested in is why the most passionate defenders of the second amendment never seem interested in government power grabs like this. Isn't the reason for the 2nd amendment to keep expansive government in check, at what point does government become a threat?
- fotbr 14y agoThere is an attitude common amongst the more radical 2nd amendment supporters: that trying to keep the government in check is a lost cause, and they're merely biding their time until "the sheeple" finally open their eyes and get fed up, at which time they can have their uprising. Like most views espoused by radicals on any subject, it is a load of crap that left rational thinking behind a long time ago, but it does help explain why you see an inconsistency in behavior.
- seiji 14y agoFacebook is accountable to its shareholders Check their ownership structure and you may want to reword that.
- mtgx 14y agoZuckerberg still owns over 50% of Facebook, right?
- sliverstorm 14y agoWhich would make him a shareholder, ergo it is accountable to him.
- pitiburi 14y agoI think the sad true is very human, rooted in psychology: we can SEE facebook, but we do not see the government/Washington. People can relate way better with a danger when it is possible to see it, when you can feel it while it's present in front of you. You can SEE facebook and your data in the screen near their logo. From there to imagine someone looking at the same data (YOUR data) from within facebook, that is a jump that emotionally is very easy to take. On the other hand, even if you KNOW that the government is wiretapping everything, you don't have the emotional connection needed to see it as a danger. Of course you can understand how terrible it is, but the emotional link is -for most of us humans- not there. We just do not feel the danger "in our guts".
- njharman 14y agoWe have strong protections (constitution) and recourse (elections) against the government. While not perfect by any stretch they are far better than what we have against Corporations. Government is much more transparent compared to corporations. For me, it is more insidious to be exploited for profit than to be spied on. Scale and applicability, as mentioned in the article. Facebook and other Corporations "watch" much more of us than government does.
- cloverich 14y agoI sympathize but also find it kind of ironic. In the end, whats the worst a company will do? Show you increasingly relevant ads? Leak your private photo's? Perhaps your address to someone you didn't want to know it? I realize there's a lot (more) to fear, but by comparison, what can the government do? What are governments doing around the world? And I'd argue that for many people, the fear isn't what Facebook does with the data, but what they could hand over to the gov't. I"m not worried about what the government is doing today. But when you look at recent history, or even at what other governments are doing today, its hard for me to understand why people aren't more concerned with the government than with Facebook. > Government is much more transparent compared to corporations. I think many would disagree with that.
- betterunix 14y ago"We have strong protections (constitution)" Which history has shown can be ignored, chipped away, sidestepped, circumvented, reinterpreted, and otherwise abused when it is convenient to do so. "recourse (elections) against the government" Except that in America, the elections are a choice between one set of fascists and another set of fascists. Voting third party is the only real recourse in America, but the major parties have set things up so that third party candidates are marginalized and remain obscure. "While not perfect by any stretch they are far better than what we have against Corporations." Better? Corporations cannot send paramilitary teams to invade your home. Corporations cannot punish you at the airport. Corporations cannot hold in against your will. You are free to ignore Facebook; you are not free to ignore the government. "Facebook and other Corporations "watch" much more of us than government does" The real problem with corporations is that they become a tool used by the government to circumvent the constitution: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1475524 https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1475524
- greesil 14y agoavailability bias.
- DodgyEggplant 14y agoFacebook was not obviously identified as an "establishment". It was "ours". We don't expect much from the government: we even know that some security measures are part of it's job. But Facebook was supposed to be cool, friendly, the dorm friend next door.
- delinquentme 14y agoFacebook we feel like we've got influence. Does anyone still believe that they have ANY say in what happens in the government?
- clobber 14y agoNot according to this: http://dashes.com/anil/2012/11/facebook-makes-it-official-you-have-no-say.html http://dashes.com/anil/2012/11/facebook-makes-it-official-yo... Not that users ever had a say in the first place.
- blueprint 14y agoThe CIA has a backdoor into Facebook's data anyway. I think people are (or should be) more concerned about collusion between corrupt corporate and governmental entities than they are when either one is corrupt because they are stronger and less easy to take down when they are actually working together. Makes people realize the fact that the reality of the society is actually very gloomy.
- MrBlue 14y ago"The CIA has a backdoor into Facebook's data anyway." Don't forget the NSA!
- shuri 14y agobecause the government used to be accountable
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- rayiner 14y agoI am much more worried about Facebook, etc, violating my privacy than Washington, for three reasons: 1) A lot of the hand-wringing over Washington's privacy invasions are overblown. A lot of online commentators are playing fast and loose with the contours of the various laws in question. Sometimes the rhetoric is (ironically) downright Orwellian. Laws designed to restrict federal investigative authority are turned around to seem like they are expanding that authority. This is a great post by tptacek answering some of the points in the FISA debate: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4979925 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4979925. Also, as a lawyer, I have quite a bit more faith and less paranoia about the various legal protections we have against the government. 2) I trust big corporations less than I trust the government, at least the federal government. Through history, the pendulum has swung back and forth on this issue, but I think right now the shoe is on the other foot. Your protections against your government really have never been stronger. Guantanamo has been a huge, wrenching scandal, even though it involves non-Americans captured in Afghanistan that are not even being held in the U.S. It is portrayed as our Soviet Gulags, but the place is literally crawling with attorneys (including many from prominent corporate law firms): http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guantanamo_Bay_attorneys http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guantanamo_Bay_attorneys. This is not a place where things are happening under the cover of darkness. At the same time, the economic power of corporations, relative to the rest of the economy, hasn't been stronger in generations, and the regulations and laws protecting you from them haven't been weaker in generations. This is not to say that I think corporations are evil. I don't. I think they're great. I also think the government is great. But I'm more wary of the people that have the most power and from whom I have the least protection. 3) It's a rational risk-weighted evaluation of the potential harms. Yes, getting detained indefinitely without trial and access to representation would be much worse than my employer getting a hold of my Facebook information, but I think that as a practical matter the latter is orders of magnitude more likely. Look at the credit reporting services. People these days can be denied jobs because they have bad credit. I think that sort of thing is far more likely to happen with social networking sites, than I am to get disappeared by the government for posting critical comments on online forums. It's totally rational to worry more about the former than the latter.
- baddox 14y ago> Your protections against your government really have never been stronger. Assuming you're talking about the USA, that is one of the more ludicrous claims I have read in a long time.
- AlexeiSadeski 14y agoBecause most people are either closet Marxists or closet Fascists?
- baddox 14y agoBecause lots of people spent their most formative years in government schools, not Facebook schools.
- pretoriusB 14y agoSo, it's like because of ...government propaganda in schooling? Strangely that haven't made people in the sixties question the government any less, despite school being even more strict at the time...
- msgilligan 14y agoPeople from the sixties now run the government -- are they questioning it?
- Evbn 14y ago99% of people from the sixties are not running the government.
- msgilligan 14y agoTrue, but more than half of them voted for it.
- pretoriusB 14y agoSo? They dit it because they rather not have a Republican president. Voting is about getting the lesser of two evils.
- baddox 14y agoThere's no point in calling it "government propaganda," as if it's some secret conspiracy or something. It's really not a secret. Children spend 12 or 13 years learning the government's version of its own history. Even on this thread, how many comments are verbatim talking points from public school curriculum? "The government gets its authority from the people (social contract)," "we have a voice in government," "government serves us," "the constitution limits the power of government," "the atomic bombs saved millions of American and Japanese lives," "the goal of the government's foreign policy is to spread and protect democracy," etc. How many people repeat these lines that have been hammered into their brains, and how many actually think about how meaningful and truthful they are?
- noillustrations 14y agoI wish more people would ask this sort of question. Not that reading about the latest spook news or reading about people crusading for government reform isn't at least marginally interesting. Certainly it is. But put this in perspective in terms of actual impact on your life. Generally, the NSA or any enforcement agency does not send me junk mail and spam. They don't try to influence me to pay for things I don't need; they don't put my reputation at risk through some bizarre concept of "sharing" (as in giving people's personal details to corporations or whoever might be scraping Facebook); they don't generally annoy me and care less about it. That's not their job. They do not set out to do that. The government is not sitting on a mountain of personal information, run by 20 somethings and "in search of a business model". When you distill things down to their essence, Facebook is a next generation junk mail company. (Despite how things may appear to the naive user, they are not the medium. They do not enable connectivity, they merely utilise what is available. They are not a network; they use a network: the internet; they are a website with access control.) The amount of information they have is like nothing any direct mail company has ever seen. The level of invasiveness of marketing with this much personal information at the ready is potentially devastating; and when all is said and done, Mark Zuckerberg may have less scruples than the worst of the worst direct marketers sending you junk mail. And he can have a much larger effect on your life than someone filling your mailbox you junk mail. The government has to follow rules. They have to be accountable. In theory, at least. By contrast, Facebook, like a direct marketer, does not have a similar mandate of representation and accountability and Facebook will do everything in its power to try to bend and break the rules. There is very little to reign in Facebook.
- mrlyc 14y agoThe U.S. government already knows everything about me. My friends and future employers don't.