8 ms·
Support the FSF: Help us stop Restricted Boot
- pi18n 14y agoSecure boot is fantastic for users IFF they can change the master keys on the hardware. But you would have to be a complete idiot to trust that Microsoft or Apple would allow that for any longer than it takes to make the hardware ubiquitous; then the iron bars come crashing down around us. I wish the best of luck to FSF in stopping this. I don't have much I can donate, but I hope my little bit of support will help them.
- Surio 14y ago[deleted as it adds no value]
- JoshTriplett 14y agoWhile the name "Secure Boot" seems like horribly misleading doublespeak, this still seems like a case where giving something a more descriptive name results in less effective communication. Calling it 'UEFI "Secure" Boot' would have sufficed, along with describing it as "restricted boot", but attempting to rebrand it seems like an ineffective and actively harmful marketing tactic here.
- Karunamon 14y agoThey're only trying to redefine the label to fit what the software actually does. A strong argument could be made that the name as commonly accepted is a misnomer considering what the endgame is. Digital "rights" management is not about your rights, it's about restricting you from doing what you want with your content. Hence the R in DRM now means "restriction". Same concept here.
- JoshTriplett 14y agoI agree with you entirely that the generally recognized name doesn't fit; however, I still think it seems counterproductive to attempt to rebrand it. "Digital Restrictions Management" worked better, because it still abbreviates as DRM so nobody goes "huh?" when you say it. "Restricted Boot" needs an accompanying explanation to tie it to the official name of 'UEFI "Secure" Boot', which makes the attempted rebranding counterproductive.
- k-mcgrady 14y agoI disagree with secure boot on regular desktops but I'm not sure how I feel about it on ARM devices (specifically tablets). I feel like the only people who are going to change the OS on a tablet are geeks - it won't affect ordinary consumers who won't want to change the OS especially as tablet hardware and software is so integrated. Is it possible to hack this or will it even affect geeks who do want to install the OS of their choice?
- mtgx 14y agoWhy make the difference between the two? What's so special about tablets that they deserve restricted boot, but PC's do not? They're just all computers. What's worse is that in the future these computers will be a lot more popular than PC's ever were. That means more people will be restricted by default. Most tablets and phones just happen to come with a different chip architecture, but there is nothing inherent to them that demands they should be restricted compared to the x86 alternatives.
- tzs 14y agoOne major difference between phones and desktops is that phones are often subsidized.
- josteink 14y agoSo are computers with their "free" antivirus included. But let's not care about that. Why should that make a difference?
- owendbybest 14y agoThis applies mostly to US phone sales.
- greenyoda 14y agoThe subsidy is paid back by the customer being locked into a service contract for some number of years. It shouldn't affect the customers' freedom to run their own software on the phone.
- recoiledsnake 14y ago>We will fight Microsoft's attempt at enforcing Restricted Boot on ARM devices like smartphones and tablets. Like any other computer, users must be able to install free software operating systems on these devices. We will monitor Microsoft's behavior to make sure they do not deceive the public again by expanding these restrictions to other kinds of systems I love how Windows RT devices which are struggling to ship a couple million are "ARM devices" but there is absolutely no mention of tens of millions of iPads, Kindle and some other Android tablets being sold with locked bootloaders. Same with phones, are WP8 phones with a 3.5% marketshare(albeit increasing) a much bigger threat to user and software freedom than iPhones? Atleast with Microsoft you have the choice of OEMs, whereas with Apple you have no freedom of choosing the manufacturer. I think mentioning Apple undermines their point in such a serious way that the FSF(and Mozilla) hasn't mentioned it any of their long blog posts on Secure Boot. Also, with the PCs sold being mandated by Microsoft to have a way for an end user to disable Secure Boot and Add/Remove their own keys, the user is completely in control and can even remove Microsoft's key if they so wish. US $350,000 is a LOT of money to waste going after this, imagine what could be done with that money if it was spent on things like OpenOffice, Samba and other projects sorely lacking in money and resources. I think this is an exercise in baiting Microsoft haters part with their money rather than any productive exercise to increase computing freedom. I hope donators consider better uses of their money.
- josteink 14y agoYeah. I find it odd that despite Apple winning the world-championship in patent-trolling and is leading the fight for closed systems and walled gardens, FSF still decides to go after anyone but Apple. Despite this tarnished image of a former tech-innovist, does the FSF really still feel it's impossible to fight the root evil here because of public perception? Is it only picking on Microsoft because that is easier to amass support against? We, as hackers and developers, should support this. We should fight closed systems. We should fight against the forces against general purpose computing (Cory Doctorow has a nice speach on this) and we should fight those who seek to criminalize writing code because somewhere some troll has a vague patent with no implementation covering your work. So yes. Support the FSF on this. But also boycot those who are the chief offenders here. Every dollar spent in an Apple-store is money spent against the core of your profession. Stop spending money there. And throw away your iPhones and Macbooks. They are bad karma and software blood-money.
- sounds 14y agoThis article has a better list of Linux OEMs than I've ever seen before. (Yeah, yeah, I need to get out more :) • Freedom Included http://freedomincluded.com http://freedomincluded.com • Garlach44 http://garlach44.eu http://garlach44.eu • InaTux http://inatux.com http://inatux.com • Lemote http://lemote.com/en http://lemote.com/en • Los Alamos Computers http://laclinux.com http://laclinux.com • System76 https://www.system76.com https://www.system76.com • ThinkPenguin http://thinkpenguin.com http://thinkpenguin.com • ZaReason http://zareason.com http://zareason.com
- wmf 14y agoActually I think those OEMs need to get the word out more. It's not the customers' fault if a company has such poor marketing that prospective customers haven't even heard of it.
- sounds 14y agoSure. But I want them to succeed-I'm willing to give them a little free publicity. (Emphasis on a little)
- DasIch 14y agoI'm somewhat optimistic in that the EC will tackle this problem and if they do they will have a much better chance at being successful than the FSF.
- CurtMonash 14y agoAs long as there is robust availability of hardware on which you can install your preferred software, why should EVERY bit of hardware offer that feature?
- chimeracoder 14y agoBecause EVERY piece of hardware that I have bought is mine, and that means I should be able to do what I want with it.
- secondChrome 14y agoSo I'll step up and be "that guy" who points out they accept Bitcoin donations. 1BTC sent.
- geofft 14y agoThe FSF's attitude towards new technologies seems awfully reactionary (this is somewhat unsurprising when you remember that rms doesn't use a web browser; occasionally he emails interesting-sounding URLs to a service that emails them back to him in plain text, and he only checks email once a day). Secure Boot where you can only run Microsoft-approved software is bad for software freedom, no question about it. Secure Boot as defined by the spec, where there is no requirement to have preloaded MS keys and where users explicitly can load their own keys, is absolutely _good_ for software freedom -- it makes the "evil maid" attack much, much harder. (The "evil maid" attack on full-disk encryption involves someone having access to your computer while it's off, and trojanning the bootloader and having it leak your disk password or the contents of the disk once your system boots. People naively expect full-disk encryption to stop this, but it's as easy as booting from a CD or thumbdrive. With secure boot, it involves physically opening the case and probably replacing chips.) Let's make sure that Secure Boot stays good for software freedom, instead of throwing out the technology along with the policy, and leaving users with no defense against this sort of attack.
- ajross 14y agoHow many consumer systems have been the victim of evil maid attacks in practice? How many have been infected via browser (or other client) vulnerabilities that never touch the kernel nor interact with a "secure" boot implementation? Secure boot exists primarily because it provides a "feel good" answer to content providers about the feasibility of DRM. It's not an answer to real world security issues and never has been.
- geofft 14y agoSecure Boot does not implement DRM or help in any way for DRM, as it turns out. Secure Boot is about the hardware trusting the OS it's about to boot, not about the OS trusting the hardware it's running on. Once the OS has booted, it has no way to figure out if the "you were secure-booted" flag is trustworthy or not -- a trojan bootloader can easily set that flag and then chainload to the normal OS. If you want the OS to trust the hardware it's on, you need a TPM, and you probably need the machine to be installed by someone who can communicate with the content provider. The entire point of Secure Boot is that it can be implemented just in existing UEFI code, _without_ the additional hardware of a TPM. I develop an OS product that has no browser installed on it at all -- there's one small client application that just interacts with our one server product, and then boots everything else you might want to do in a VM. The biggest threat to the security of our outer layer is, in fact, an evil maid attack. It's certainly worth being aware of that threat, even if there are other, bigger threats. (Nobody says that we should stop worrying about buffer overflows while there are still cross-site scripting attacks, etc.)
- jf 14y agoReminder for Microsoft employees: Remember that Microsoft matches donations to 501(c)(3) non-profit organizations.
- temac 14y agoReminder for Microsoft employees: if you are going to support that, you should has well quit (maybe after having done a donation :p )
- ollysb 14y agoThis really seems like something the market could decide. If there's a large group of people that want an alternative would the opportunity not be great enough for a new company to fulfill it? Who are the restricted bootloaders actually harming? There's still plenty of choices for people that want to install linux on a box and I don't see that this choice will disappear any time soon.